Beauty Lime Crime Red Velvet Alternatives, Scandal Vs Salem Shades
Scandal and Salem are the two closest Velvetines shades to Red Velvet on amazon.com. Scandal is a deep rich plum red with dramatic depth. Salem is a true brown red with everyday edge. Both share the same vegan long wearing matte formula. This comparison breaks down color, mood, and best use.
| Factor | Lime Crime Velvetines Liquid Matte Lipst | Lime Crime Velvetines Liquid Matte Lipst |
|---|---|---|
| Shade | Scandal, deep rich plum | Salem, true brown |
| Red intensity | Deep and vampy | Medium, wearable |
| Mood | Dramatic evening | Edgy daytime |
| Finish | Velvet matte | Velvet matte |
| Wear time | Six to eight hours | Six to eight hours |
| Scent | French vanilla | French vanilla |
| Price range | Around twenty dollars | Around twenty dollars |
Our Verdict
Scandal wins for bold evening looks and maximum drama. Its deep plum red reads luxurious and powerful. Salem wins for daily wear and first time bold lip buyers. Its true brown tone is striking without overwhelming. Pick Scandal for nights out and Salem for the office. Both deliver the Velvetines formula Red Velvet fans expect.
Coverage on Pigmented Lips: How Many Coats for True Color
Nobody addresses matte coverage on naturally pigmented or dark lips, so here is the coat math for these deep shades. On fair to medium lips, both Scandal and Salem deliver true color in one coat. On naturally pigmented or dark lips, one coat of Salem, the medium brown-red, may read sheer or uneven, because the natural lip tone competes with the pigment. Scandal's deeper plum has more pigment load and covers in one coat on most lip tones.
The technique for full coverage on dark lips: one thin first coat, blot, then a second thin coat. Two thin coats beat one thick coat for both coverage and wear; thick coats crack. Do not use the concealer trick under a liquid matte; the liquid film slides over the concealer base and pills. If you need serious coverage, Scandal is the pick; if you want a wearable stain effect on dark lips, one sheered coat of Salem pressed in with a fingertip gives color without the full-coverage demand. Our long-lasting lipstick guide covers the thin-coat method across formulas.
Center Fade, Removal, and the Vanilla Scent Question
The inner-rim center fade hits liquid mattes hardest, and Velvetines is no exception. The center fades first around hour four or five, leaving color on the outer lip. The fix nobody ranks per formula: Velvetines does not re-layer cleanly, so do not touch up over the fade. Blot the remaining color down hard, then decide: minor fade gets a fingertip-pressed touch-up on the bare center only; major fade gets full removal and reapplication. A full coat over a faded base pills and cracks, always.
Removal needs an oil-based or dual-phase remover held on the lips for thirty seconds; scrubbing or peeling the film damages the lip surface. The French vanilla scent deserves its own note, because fragrance is a buying factor nobody treats seriously. Velvetines is noticeably vanilla-scented, which most wearers enjoy, but fragrance-sensitive users and those prone to lip irritation should know before buying; vanilla fragrance is a common lip irritant. If you react to fragranced lip products, the scent is a reason to choose differently, not a minor detail. For a vanilla-free long-wear option, the SuperStay longevity comparison covers drugstore alternatives.
Eating, Drinking, and the 6 to 8 Hour Claim
The wear-time claim both shades share deserves an honest breakdown. Six to eight hours assumes no oily food: talking, water, and coffee through a straw barely dent the film. An oily meal dissolves it noticeably, because oil breaks down the film formers that make it transfer-proof. The center fades first in every case, which is why the blot-and-assess method from the previous section matters more than the clock.
The survival tactics: drink through a straw when possible, blot rather than wipe after eating, and carry the tube plus remover for full reapplication rather than attempting a patchy touch-up. For events with a seated dinner, apply after the meal, not before; a fresh application at 8pm outlasts a 6pm application that went through dinner. Neither shade survives a full oily meal intact, and expecting otherwise leads to the disappointment that gets blamed on the formula.
Deep Reds and Skin: Undertone, Hair Color, and Aging
Shade and undertone guidance for deep skin tones stays generic everywhere, so here is the specific version. Scandal's deep plum-red flatters deep skin beautifully; the plum undertone harmonizes rather than contrasting harshly. Salem's brown-red is the safer everyday pick across skin depths, reading as a rich neutral rather than a statement. On fair skin, Scandal is dramatic by design; on deep skin, it is elegant without trying.
The hair-color pairing nobody covers: Scandal's plum depth pairs gorgeously with dark hair and makes blonde hair look striking by contrast; Salem's brown-red is the easy match for redheads, since the brown base harmonizes with red hair where blue-reds clash. For mature lips, deep mattes demand the prep routine: exfoliate gently, hydrate overnight, apply to smooth lips, because every line shows in a flat deep matte. Scandal on unprepped mature lips emphasizes texture; the same shade on prepped lips looks luxurious. Our Aquaphor lip repair guide covers the overnight prep that makes deep mattes wearable.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.