Beauty Lime Crime Plushies Compared: Top Two Models Face Off Today
Plushies in Jam and Velvetines in Airborne Unicorn represent two matte philosophies from Lime Crime. Plushies prioritize comfort with a whipped, cushiony bullet that blurs the lips. Velvetines prioritize endurance with a liquid formula that dries transfer-proof. The shades differ too, with Jam offering deep berry richness and Airborne Unicorn offering playful pastel.
| Factor | Lime Crime Plushies Soft Matte Lipstick, | Lime Crime Velvetines Liquid Lipstick, A |
|---|---|---|
| Format | Bullet lipstick | Liquid lipstick |
| Finish | Soft, blurred matte | Flat transfer-proof matte |
| Comfort | Cushiony, non-drying | Drier, needs lip prep |
| Wear time | 3 to 5 hours | 6 to 8 hours |
| Transfer | Transfers to cups | Minimal transfer |
| Shade | Jam, deep berry plum | Airborne Unicorn, lavender pink |
| Best for | Daily comfortable wear | Events and long days |
| Reapplication | Layers smoothly | Best removed and reapplied |
Our Verdict
Pick Plushies in Jam if you want comfortable daily color with a modern blurred finish. Pick Velvetines in Airborne Unicorn if you need bold pastel color that survives hours without touch-ups. Comfort seekers choose Plushies, long-wear lovers choose Velvetines.
Center Fade and Reapplication: Which Formula Forgives
The inner-rim center fade problem gets advice but no per-formula fixes, so here is the specific answer for this pair. Plushies in Jam re-layers cleanly: its cushiony bullet formula melts into the existing layer, so you can reapply straight over a faded center without patchiness. Velvetines in Airborne Unicorn does not: its transfer-proof liquid film cracks and pills when a fresh coat goes over a partially worn one, which is why the table correctly says it is best removed and reapplied.
The practical routines differ completely. With Plushies, blot the faded center with a tissue, then reapply directly; the blurred finish hides the join. With Velvetines, remove fully with an oil-based remover, then start fresh; a patchy touch-up always looks worse than the fade. Prevention for both: one thin coat wears more evenly than two thick ones, and blotting once after application removes the excess that would flake first. For all-day events with Velvetines, carry the remover as well as the lipstick; you cannot touch up without it. Our long-lasting lipstick guide covers the thin-coat technique across formulas.
Removing Each Formula Without Damaging Lips
Nobody ranks removal difficulty per formula beyond one-line notes, so here is the breakdown. Velvetines is the harder removal: its transfer-proof film needs an oil-based or dual-phase remover held on the lips for thirty seconds before wiping. Do not scrub or peel the dried film; both damage the lip surface and cause the flaking that ruins the next application. Plushies comes off easily with any cleanser or even a damp tissue, which is the comfort trade-off made visible: easy on, easy off.
Daily Velvetines wearers need the recovery routine: after removal, apply a thick healing balm overnight, because repeated film removal dries the lip surface over time. The pastel Airborne Unicorn shade adds a specific removal concern: light pastels can leave a faint stain in lip lines that looks like dryness, so follow removal with a gentle lip scrub once a week, not daily. If you love the Velvetines endurance but hate the removal, the Armani Lip Maestro guide covers a velvet matte with easier takeoff.
The Balm Question: What Goes Under Each Formula
The "too much balm ruins matte" balance is stated everywhere but never quantified per formula, so here it is for this pair. Plushies tolerates a thin balm base well; its cushiony formula is designed for comfort and the balm simply adds to it. Velvetines tolerates almost no balm; any slick base makes the liquid film slide, pill, and wear off in patches. The method for Velvetines is lip prep the night before, exfoliate gently, sleep in a healing balm, then apply to clean, dry lips in the morning. For Plushies, a light balm ten minutes before, blotted down, is plenty. Getting this wrong is the most common reason Velvetines disappoints; the formula is fine, the base is the problem.
Nobody compares cost per wear for matte lipsticks, so let us do it for this pair. Plushies lasts 3 to 5 hours per application, which means two to three applications on a full day. Velvetines lasts 6 to 8 hours, usually one application plus a reapplication after a meal. Over a month of daily wear, Plushies gets used up roughly twice as fast, which narrows the value gap between the two formats considerably. The cheaper-feeling option is not always the cheaper one.
The comfort-endurance trade-off is the real decision. Plushies' cushiony, non-drying formula is the one you reach for daily without thinking; Velvetines' drier film demands lip prep and recovery, which is a routine cost beyond the price tag. For dry-lipped wearers, Plushies is the clear pick; Velvetines on dry lips without prep cracks within hours. For mature lips with fine lines, the same logic applies: Plushies' blurred, cushiony finish does not settle into lines the way Velvetines' flat film does, making it the more forgiving choice after 50. For long event days where reapplication is impossible, Velvetines earns its keep. Many buyers end up owning both and choosing by the day's demands, which is the honest answer no comparison wants to give. The SuperStay longevity comparison shows how drugstore long-wear formulas handle the same trade-off.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.