Best Eyeshadows: Top Picks & Buying Guide

Compare the best eyeshadow side by side. Browse 87 in-depth reviews, head-to-head comparisons and guides to find your perfect match. Updated regula...

Eyeshadow can be subtle or dramatic, and the formula determines which you get. We compare powder, cream, and stick eyeshadows on pigment, blendability, fallout, and wear time. Our reviews test palettes and singles, showing swatches on different skin tones and how shades perform with and without primer.

We cover everyday neutrals, colorful looks, and smoky eyes, plus application techniques for hooded or deep-set eyes. Our guides explain finishes from matte to metallic to glitter, and how to build a versatile collection. Create any eye look with confidence. We also test creasing specifically on oily lids, the toughest test for any shadow.

Our reviews compare single shadows versus palettes for value and versatility. We swatch on multiple skin tones because pigment shows differently. Our guides include brush basics, explaining which brushes do what so beginners can start with just three. Our testing methodology stays consistent across every review, so you can compare our ratings between products with confidence.