Beauty NYX Liquid Suede vs Top Rivals: Matte Lip Color Showdown Now
The NYX Liquid Suede Cream Lipstick in Kitten Heels and in Brooklyn Thorn share the same waterproof matte formula in two statement shades. Kitten Heels is the bright classic red. Brooklyn Thorn is the deep brown with purple undertones. We compared them on pigment, wear, versatility, and best occasions.
| Factor | NYX Liquid Suede Cream Lipstick, Kitten | NYX Liquid Suede Cream Lipstick, Brookly |
|---|---|---|
| Shade | Bright classic red | Deep brown, purple undertone |
| Finish | Velvety matte | Velvety matte |
| Pigment in one swipe | Full coverage | Full coverage |
| Waterproof wear | Yes, 4 to 6 hours | Yes, 4 to 6 hours |
| Versatility | Day and evening | Mostly evening |
| Best skin tones | All skin tones | Medium to deep |
| Beginner friendly | Very | Moderate |
| Statement level | Classic bold | Edgy dramatic |
Our Verdict
Choose Kitten Heels if you want a timeless bright red that works for day, evening, and every skin tone. Choose Brooklyn Thorn if you love deep, vampy lips and want a shade with real drama. Both deliver the same smooth application and waterproof matte wear, so the choice is purely about which color story fits your style. Either way, prep lips with balm first so the matte formula applies smoothly and evenly.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.
Want the Full Picture?
Building Up to Bold Red in Three Steps
Most people who think they cannot wear red lipstick have simply never been given a graduated plan, so here is one that works. Step one is a sheer red: press NYX Liquid Suede on with a fingertip or layer it over balm for a stained effect that reads as a flush rather than a statement. Wear that for a week until it feels like nothing. Step two moves to a satin or cream applied normally, which gives real color with a forgiving finish. Step three is the full matte or long-wear red, worn with the liner technique that keeps the edges clean. Each step takes about a week, and by the end the bold red feels like your lipstick, not a costume.
Keep the rest of your makeup minimal during the adjustment weeks, since red lips combined with heavy eyes is what makes first-timers feel overdone. One focal point is the rule: groomed brows, quiet eyes, and the red doing all the talking. Pick a low-stakes daytime outing for the debut rather than a major event, because casual repetition builds the comfort that formal occasions cannot. When the red starts feeling like nothing special to you, it reads as effortless to everyone else. Our NYX Liquid Suede Guide: Application Tips for a Perfect Matte walks through the full routine step by step.
Lipstick Expiration: When to Keep It and When to Toss It
Most lipsticks are good for about 12 to 24 months after opening, timed from first use. Watch for three warning signs: the scent shifts stale and waxy, the bullet drags grainy instead of gliding, and the color looks faded on the surface. When NYX Liquid Suede starts skipping, treat that as the formula aging out, because forcing a dried bullet across your lips causes the unevenness people blame on the shade.
A few habits stretch the safe life of any lipstick. Keep the cap on between uses, since the exposed tip dries fastest, and store the tube upright in a cool drawer instead of a humid bathroom where heat cycles break the wax down. Do not lend the bullet directly, since no formula handles saliva-borne bacteria. Refresh the surface by shaving off the top layer with a tissue instead of alcohol, which damages the waxes that give the bullet structure. Shade-level detail lives in our INTO YOU Lip Mud Guide: How to Apply Matte Lipstick Smoothly.
Red Lipstick for the Office: Keeping It Professional
Workplace red is about calibration, not avoidance. Sheer it down and red becomes one of the most professional lip looks there is: apply NYX Liquid Suede, blot well, and the color keeps its authority at half the intensity. In conservative fields, lean toward brick, berry, and deeper reds over vivid blue-reds, which demand more attention under fluorescent light. The full opaque matte red still has its place, just save it for the industries and evenings where boldness is the point.
Industry norms are the real variable, so read your specific room. Creative fields, fashion, media, and beauty treat a bold red as practically a uniform, while finance, law, and client-facing corporate roles reward the sheered version. When starting a new job, default to the blotted red for the first weeks and observe what the senior women wear; matching the room's level is savvier than making a statement on day one. Whatever the setting, keep application immaculate, since a chipped red undermines the polish that makes it work-appropriate. We answer the most common buying questions in our complete red lipstick buying guide.
Red Lipstick Through a Meal: Honest Expectations
Judge red wear honestly by finish, not miracle claims. Long-wear liquid reds keep their outline through dinner and fade mostly centrally, where one reapplication restores the look. Traditional bullet reds fade more evenly across the lip but mark glasses and napkins, so plan on carrying the tube for a touch-up. NYX Liquid Suede will follow the pattern of its finish family, so compare it against similar formulas rather than against an imaginary bulletproof red. And remember that oily food breaks down every finish faster than anything else on the menu.
The touch-up strategy matters more than the formula for evening wear. Blot the remaining color gently rather than layering fresh lipstick over a greasy base, then reapply one thin layer, which looks far cleaner than building over the meal's residue. For coffee dates specifically, drink through a straw when you can and choose the long-wear option, since cup transfer is where most daytime reds visibly fail. A red that needs one planned touch-up is still an excellent red; the failures are the ones that smear beyond the lip line instead of fading gracefully.