Beauty NYX Liquid Suede Bold Shades: Blue vs Black vs Berry Lips
Jet-Set, Alien, and Brooklyn Thorn share one formula, so the choice is purely about which bold color fits your life.
| Factor | NYX Professional Makeup Liquid Suede Cre | NYX Professional Makeup Liquid Suede Cre |
|---|---|---|
| Color | True vivid blue | Opaque jet black |
| Wearability | Editorial and costume | Goth, punk, Halloween |
| Staining | Blue stains lips after wear | Black stains the most |
| Beginner friendly | Needs precise application | Shows every smudge |
| Price | Seven to ten dollars | Seven to ten dollars |
Our Verdict
Brooklyn Thorn wins for most buyers because deep berry is bold yet wearable for real life. Choose Alien for true goth looks and Jet-Set for editorial statements, but expect more upkeep with both.
Removing Blue and Black: The Stain Ranking
Bold shades stain in proportion to their drama, and this page's trio sits at the extreme end. Black stains the most, blue next, and both leave a residual tint that survives normal face wash. The removal ranking from gentlest to most effort: a dedicated oil-based lip remover lifts the most pigment with the least scrubbing; micellar water on a soaked cotton pad pressed for thirty seconds comes next; regular cleanser alone barely dents it. What never works is dry wiping or scrubbing with a towel, which grinds pigment into the lip line and irritates the surrounding skin.
The next-day shadow is normal with these shades: a faint blue or gray cast that fades within a day as the top skin layer turns over. Sleeping with a thick layer of lip balm or petroleum jelly speeds the release. Plan removals before events accordingly, and do not wear black liquid lipstick the night before a morning where you need bare lips. Our Liquid Suede bold lip guide covers the full prep-to-removal routine for these statement shades.
The Inner-Rim Fade: Re-Layer or Start Over
Every long-wear matte fades first at the inner rim, where saliva, talking, and drinking attack the color. With Liquid Suede's opaque formula, the fix depends on how far the fade went. Light inner fade: press the lips together, then dab a small amount of product only on the faded inner area with a fingertip, blending outward. The formula re-layers cleanly if the outer color is still intact. Heavy fade with patchiness: remove fully and restart, because layering over patchy matte builds uneven texture that looks worse than bare lips.
The balm balance matters here. A thin balm base applied ten minutes before, then blotted, extends comfortable wear without breaking the matte seal. Too much balm, or balm applied right before the color, prevents the formula from gripping and accelerates the inner fade dramatically. The quantified rule for this formula: balm, wait, blot until the lips feel almost bare, then apply. That sequence buys hours; skipping the blot costs them.
True Color on Pigmented Lips: The Coverage Question
Naturally pigmented or dark lips change how these shades read, and the answer differs per color. The black and deep blue are opaque enough to cover any lip tone in one coat, which is why they work as editorial shades across skin tones. But opacity has a cost: one thick coat looks heavier and cracks sooner than two thin coats, so even with full-coverage shades, the two-thin-coats method wears longer.
Lighter or mid-tone shades in the Liquid Suede range need the lip's natural tone neutralized first on pigmented lips: a thin veil of foundation or concealer over the lips, set with a dusting of translucent powder, gives the color a blank canvas. Without that base, the natural lip tone shifts the shade, muting brights and warming cools. This prep step is the difference between the tube color and the worn color on deeper lips. For how these bolds compare against NYX's other matte lines, our NYX matte lip cream duel puts Copenhagen against Amsterdam on the same wear criteria.
Precision Application for Unforgiving Shades
Blue and black show every smudge, which makes application technique the real product. The doe-foot applicator lays down the center fill; a lip brush handles the edges and the cupid's bow where precision decides the look. Outline first with the brush, fill second with the applicator, and clean the outer edge with a flat concealer brush for the graphic finish these shades demand.
Lip liner is not optional with unforgiving colors: a matching or clear liner gives the liquid a boundary and prevents the feathering that reads as sloppy at this pigment level. Work in thin layers and let the first coat set for a minute before assessing, the color deepens as it dries, and judging wet leads to over-application. Our Liquid Suede shade hub collects the full bold lineup if you want to expand beyond these three.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.
Best for: Fall berry lips on a budget.
NYX Professional Makeup Liquid Suede Cream Lipstick, Brooklyn Thorn
- Deep berry wine shade
- Soft matte finish
- Waterproof liquid cream
- Up to 8 hours of wear
Pros
- Flattering berry for fall
- Wearable bold shade
- Low price
Cons
- Berry bleeds without liner
- Fades at the inner lip
- Can stain skin