We compare Unicorn Blood in the Velour liquid matte against the Shiny Trap gloss. Same iconic deep red, opposite finishes. One is maximum drama, the other wearable comfort. Our five-point comparison covers finish, wear, and best use.
Factor
Jeffree Star Cosmetics Velour Liquid Lip
Jeffree Star Cosmetics Shiny Trap Lipsti
Finish
True matte Velour
Glossy Shiny Trap
Comfort
Drying over hours
Comfortable shine
Wear time
6 to 8 hours
3 to 4 hours
Application
Needs precision
More forgiving
Best for
Maximum vampy drama
Everyday deep red
Our Verdict
The Velour Liquid Lipstick wins for the full iconic Unicorn Blood experience with unbeatable staying power. The Shiny Trap wins for comfort and daily wearability of the same gorgeous shade. Dark lip veterans should own the Velour. Everyone else starts happier with Shiny Trap.
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.
Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Deep Red Removal and Staining: The Full Protocol
Unicorn Blood's deep red pigment stains, and no guide covers removal properly. The method is an oil-based cleanser or micellar water held on a soaked pad against the lips for thirty seconds, then wiped gently; the soak dissolves the pigment so there is no scrubbing. Scrubbing to remove deep red drives the pigment deeper into the lip lines and causes the staining you are trying to avoid.
The residual pink stain the next day is normal with deep reds; it fades within a day and is not a sign of damage. A gentle lip scrub followed by balm removes the last of it if needed. On veneers or crowns, deep red can leave a temporary tint if worn for many hours; normal brushing removes it. The Shiny Trap gloss version stains less than the Velour liquid because there is less pigment load per application.
Eating and Drinking Survival: Matte vs Gloss Red
Which red finish survives oily food, coffee cups, and masks is the honest wear question. The Velour liquid matte survives oily food better than the Shiny Trap gloss, because the matte film resists oil dissolution longer; expect the matte to hold through a light meal with center softening, and the gloss to need reapplication after eating. Coffee cups take a ring from either finish, which is normal.
Mask wear transfers less from the matte than the gloss, but neither is transfer-proof; the matte leaves a faint imprint while the gloss leaves a visible one. The touch-up strategy differs: the Velour re-layers cleanly in the center, while the gloss can be reapplied over the whole lip. For all-day red events, the matte with one midday touch-up is the lower-maintenance system. More red wear comparisons live in the main red lipsticks guide.
Red Lipstick and the Confidence Curve
First-time red wearers need a graduated plan, not a single bold recommendation. Step one is a sheer red, blotted or finger-pressed, worn for short outings. Step two is a satin red at full application for a full day. Step three is the full matte deep red like Unicorn Blood Velour for an evening. Each step builds the comfort that makes the next one feel natural rather than costume-like.
The Shiny Trap gloss is the step-one-friendly version of this exact shade, which makes this comparison a built-in confidence ladder: start with the gloss, graduate to the matte. Finger-tapping the matte to sheer it out is the bridge technique between steps. Most people who "cannot wear red" simply started at step three; the graduated plan works because comfort is trained, not innate. The Bawse Lady guide covers another bold red for the collection.
Seasonal Red Wardrobe: Rotating Unicorn Blood
One deep red cannot cover the whole year gracefully. Summer calls for sheer reds and coral-reds that suit bright light; the Shiny Trap gloss in Unicorn Blood sheered out works for summer evenings. Winter and holiday season are the deep matte's natural habitat, where the Velour's full drama suits the light and the dress codes. Spring suits blue-reds that brighten the face after winter.
The same person rotating reds through the year gets more wear from each tube because no single red is overused to the point of boredom. Outfit coordination matters: deep red lip with red clothing can clash unless the tones match deliberately; with colorful outfits, the lip should be the single red element. The monochrome red look, matching lip and outfit, works when the reds are in the same family.
Red Lipstick With Glasses: Frame Interplay
Bold red plus bold frames compete visually, making the face look busy. With statement frames, the Shiny Trap gloss in a blotted application balances better than the full Velour matte, because the sheerer finish does not fight the frames. With thin or rimless frames, the full matte drama works because the frames do not compete. Frame color matters too: black frames suit the blue-red depth of Unicorn Blood naturally.
Red Liner Pairing for Unicorn Blood
Which liner undertone pairs with which red family is never explained systematically. Unicorn Blood is a blue-based deep red, so the liner should be a similarly blue-based deep red or a neutral deep liner, never an orange-red liner, which creates a visible warm ring as the center fades. Fill the whole lip with the liner before the Velour matte; the liner base grips the matte and delays the center-fade ring that deep reds show badly.