Beauty Jeffree Star Velour Liquid Lipstick Shades Compared Here
Velour Liquid Lipstick and Shiny Trap both do nude glam beautifully. Velour brings long-wear matte polish. Shiny Trap brings juicy glossy dimension. Here is how the nude options compare.
| Factor | Jeffree Star Cosmetics Velour Liquid Lip | Jeffree Star Cosmetics Shiny Trap Lipsti |
|---|---|---|
| Formula | Velour Liquid long-wear matte | Shiny Trap high-shine gloss |
| Nude effect | Polished defined nude | Juicy plump nude |
| Finish | Fully matte | Wet-look shine |
| Pigment | Opaque nude coverage | Sheer to medium nude |
| Comfort | Lightweight matte feel | Hydrating gloss feel |
| Wear time | Many hours | Two to three hours |
| Best occasion | Events and photos | Daily wear and office |
| Layering | Base for gloss on top | Topper over Velour |
Our Verdict
Velour Liquid Lipstick wins for polished nude glam that lasts. Its matte finish looks expensive and refined in photos. Shiny Trap wins for everyday juicy nudes that feel effortless. Buy Velour for occasions and Shiny Trap for daily rotation. Layering them gives the ultimate nude lip with both longevity and shine. Nude glam is timeless. Find yours and shine. Shine on.
Velour Liquid vs Shiny Trap: Matte Polish or Glossy Dimension
The Jeffree Star Velour Liquid Lipstick and the Shiny Trap Lipstick both do nude glam, but the finishes could not differ more. The Velour Liquid is a classic long-wear liquid matte: it sets to a flat, opaque film with serious staying power, the kind of matte that survives meals with only center touch-ups. The Shiny Trap is a high-shine gloss: juicy, dimensional, comfortable, and honest about needing reapplication. For nude glam specifically, the Velour gives the polished, filtered look, while the Shiny Trap gives the plump, reflective look.
Nude shade selection is the hidden difficulty with both. Nudes must match your undertone or they look wrong: too light and the lips disappear, too pink and it clashes with warm skin, too brown and it muddies. The Velour's opacity means the shade reads true to the tube, which helps selection. The Shiny Trap's sheerness means your natural lip pigment shifts the color, so test on the lips. For deep skin tones, nude glosses need enough pigment to show up; sheer nudes vanish on pigmented lips. Our MAC Creme D'Nude guide explores the iconic nude for reference.
Long-Wear Matte Removal: The Oil Method Done Right
Velour Liquid is a firmly setting liquid matte, which puts it on the harder end of the removal spectrum. The method: cleansing oil or balm, press a saturated pad over the lips for a full twenty to thirty seconds, then wipe gently in one direction. The long press matters more than the product: the oil needs time to dissolve the film, and impatience is what leads to scrubbing. Repeat with a fresh pad section rather than pressing harder. Never peel the dried film off: peeling takes lip skin with it and leaves the lips raw for days.
For daily Velour wearers, the overnight recovery step is essential: a thick occlusive balm every night prevents the cumulative dryness that makes long-wear mattes unwearable over time. Exfoliate gently twice a week, not daily, since over-exfoliation thins the lip surface and makes the next matte application look worse. If removal consistently takes more than two gentle passes, the formula may be too tenacious for daily wear on your lips; rotate in the Shiny Trap on lighter days to give your lips recovery time. The lips, like skin, need rest days from the most demanding formulas.
Cost Per Wear: Luxury Liquid Matte Math
Nobody compares cost per wear for liquid mattes, so here is the math for the Velour Liquid. A standard liquid lipstick tube delivers roughly 150 to 200 applications. At the Velour's price point, that works out to around fifteen to twenty cents per wear, which is comparable to mid-range liquid mattes used the same way. The Shiny Trap, used more heavily per application and reapplied more often, costs more per day of wear despite a similar tube price: gloss economics always favor the matte on cost per day.
The value question is really about finish rate: liquid mattes expire about twelve months after opening, and buyers with large collections rarely finish a tube before it goes off. If you rotate many shades, the Velour's value drops because you discard half-used tubes; if you have a signature nude you wear daily, the value is excellent. Minis change the math for shade collectors: a mini you finish beats a full size you toss. For budget liquid mattes with strong wear, our SuperStay longevity comparison covers drugstore marathon formulas.
A final note on the Velour formula's staying power: it is one of the few liquid mattes that survives oily foods reasonably well, though the center will still need a touch-up after a full meal. For the longest wear, avoid layering gloss over the Velour, since oils break down the matte film; if you want shine, wear the Shiny Trap on its own instead. The two formulas are designed as alternatives, not layers, and each performs best solo.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.