Beauty Rimmel Thrill Seeker vs Kind Free Waterproof Mascara Compare
Rimmel Thrill Seeker Waterproof and Kind and Free offer different takes on long wear mascara. One is fully waterproof for bold volume, the other is a clean water resistant formula. We compared them to help you choose.
| Factor | Rimmel London Thrill Seeker Mascara Wate | Rimmel Kind + Free Volume & Length Masca |
|---|---|---|
| Price point | Check price | Check price |
| Formula | Waterproof volumizing | Water resistant, vegan |
| Best for | Bold waterproof volume | Clean daily wear |
| Water resistance | Fully waterproof | Water resistant |
| Ingredients | Standard | Vegan, no fragrance |
| Brush | Built in volume brush | Bio based fibers |
Our Verdict
Pick Thrill Seeker Waterproof for maximum waterproof volume that survives water and sweat. Pick Kind and Free for a vegan, cleaner formula with water resistant wear for daily use.
The Waterproof Decision Matrix: When Each Formula Wins
No competitor builds a single decision matrix for waterproof versus water-resistant versus tubing across real conditions, so here it is for these two formulas. For daily indoor wear, Kind and Free's water-resistant vegan formula wins: it handles humidity and light sweat, removes gently, and suits the clean-beauty brief. For workouts, outdoor summer days, and humid commutes, the choice splits, water-resistant survives moderate sweat, but heavy perspiration breaks it within an hour, which is where Thrill Seeker's true waterproof film earns its keep. For swimming, crying, or all-day water exposure, only the waterproof formula survives.
The mistake is defaulting to waterproof for everything. Waterproof removal is the harshest routine in mascara wear, and daily waterproof use causes measurably more lash fallout than alternating with a gentler formula. The smart rotation: water-resistant for the five normal days, waterproof for the two active ones. Your lashes get recovery time, and both tubes last longer. Tubing formulas sit in the middle of this matrix as an honorable mention, they resist sweat and tears nearly as well as waterproof yet remove with warm water, though neither product here is a tubing formula. Our Telescopic waterproof versus washable comparison shows the same tradeoff in another formula family.
Removing Waterproof Without the Lash Damage
No competitor compares removal methods by lash-loss impact, and waterproof removal is where lashes suffer most. Ranked gentlest to harshest: a bi-phase eye makeup remover, pressed over closed eyes for twenty seconds then wiped downward once, causes the least fallout. Cleansing oil massaged gently comes next. Micellar water works but needs more passes on true waterproof film. Harshest is rubbing with a dry wipe or cotton pad, which pulls lashes at the root and is the routine behind most "my lashes are thinning" complaints from waterproof wearers.
Two rules matter most. First, the twenty-second dwell: press the remover-soaked pad over closed eyes and wait a full twenty seconds before wiping. The solvents need contact time to dissolve the film, and wiping after five seconds forces the scrubbing that pulls lashes. Second, never sleep in waterproof mascara. Overnight wear makes lashes brittle, and morning removal then takes triple the friction. The Kind and Free formula, being water-resistant rather than waterproof, forgives rushed removal far more, which is a genuine daily-wear advantage beyond the vegan positioning. For remover options ranked by gentleness, see our makeup removal guide.
Contact Lenses, Dry Eyes, and Waterproof Film
Mascara for contact lens wearers with dry eyes gets almost no specific coverage, and waterproof formulas are the hardest case. The issue is twofold: waterproof films flake less during wear, which is good, but the aggressive removal they demand irritates already-dry eyes, which is bad. For daily lens wearers, the water-resistant Kind and Free formula is the better pick: it removes with gentle pressure that does not inflame dry eyes, and its vegan positioning usually means fewer irritating additives, though you should still check the specific ingredient list.
If you wear lenses and need waterproof for an event, insert lenses before applying mascara, never after, since fingers near freshly coated lashes transfer product onto the lens surface. Keep waterproof off the lower lash line when wearing lenses, the lower line sits closest to the lens edge and the removal rubbing irritates the most there. And carry rewetting drops on waterproof days, since the extra removal effort at night leaves dry eyes drier. Anyone with chronically dry eyes should treat waterproof as an occasional tool, not a daily formula.
Oily Lids: Which Film Holds Up
Oily eyelids are the everyday stress test for both formulas. Waterproof films resist lid oil well, since the same water-repelling chemistry repels oil, which is why Thrill Seeker stays put on oily lids through long days. Water-resistant formulas vary: some handle oil fine, others soften by afternoon as the oil migrates down the lash line. If your lids are oily and you prefer the gentler formula, dust a whisper of translucent powder along the upper lash line before mascara. It absorbs the oil at the source and can double the wear time of a water-resistant film without changing the lash look at all.
Waterproof Mascara Questions
The formula itself is not the main problem, the removal is. Daily aggressive removal causes the fallout most wearers blame on the mascara. With gentle bi-phase removal and rest days in a water-resistant formula, lash damage stays minimal.
Humidity, light sweat, watery eyes, and brief rain. It does not survive swimming, heavy workouts, or sustained crying. Think of it as smudge-proofing for normal days rather than armor for extreme ones.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.