Beauty They're Real Magnet vs Original: Which Mascara Wins Now?
Benefit They're Real Magnet takes on the original They're Real in this lash showdown. One brings magnetic minerals and 36-hour wear claims, the other brings the classic formula millions love. Both use spiked brushes for separation. Here is how they compare on length, curl, wear, and value.
| Factor | Benefit They are Real Magnet Extreme Len | Benefit They are Real Lengthening Mascar |
|---|---|---|
| Technology | Magnetic minerals for extreme length. | Classic lengthening polymers. |
| Length | More dramatic length. | Noticeable natural length. |
| Wear Time | Up to 36-hour wear claim. | Reliable full-day wear. |
| Curl Hold | Slightly stronger hold. | Good daily curl hold. |
| Removal | Needs extra soaking time. | Removes more easily. |
| Price | 24 to 28 dollars. | 24 to 28 dollars. |
| Best For | Maximum drama and events. | Easy daily wear. |
Our Verdict
They're Real Magnet wins for maximum length and multi-day wear. Its magnetic formula delivers the most dramatic results in the line. The original They're Real remains the smarter daily choice with easier removal and natural-looking length. Start with the original to learn the brush, then add Magnet for nights out. Either way, your lashes get the separated, lengthened look the line is famous for.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.
Want the Full Picture?
Removing Magnet vs Original Without Losing Lashes
The biggest real-world difference between They're Real Magnet and the original is not how they look at 8 a.m., it is how they come off at 11 p.m. The original is a traditional lengthening formula that dissolves with a standard oil or balm cleanser and a little patience. The Magnet version, with its magnetic mineral powder formula built for extreme length and multi-day wear claims, clings to lashes noticeably harder. That staying power is the point, but it means removal needs more intention: a warm compress held over the eyes for 30 seconds to loosen the formula, then a thorough oil-based cleanse, then a second pass if needed.
This matters because aggressive removal is one of the top causes of lash fallout, and it is the variable nobody controls for in wear tests. Rubbing, tugging, and scrubbing with a cotton pad cost you lashes regardless of which formula you wear. Ranked by how gently they come off, the order runs: warm-water tubing mascaras first, then traditional formulas removed with oil, then long-wear and waterproof formulas, with vigorous scrubbing dead last. Magnet sits in that third tier, so treat removal as part of the product, not an afterthought. If you wear it daily, invest in a proper cleansing balm rather than fighting it with micellar water every night. Our makeup removal guide compares the least damaging routines in detail.
A related caution: because Magnet is harder to dissolve, some wearers compensate by applying it more heavily, assuming more product equals more drama. It does not. The formula is already pigmented and lengthening at one or two coats, and excess product is what creates the spidery, brittle look plus a harder removal job. Two thin coats, with a few seconds between them, outperform one heavy coat every time.
Lash Lifts, Tints, and Hooded Eyes: Where the Two Formulas Diverge
If you have a lash lift, the choice between these two deserves more thought than most roundups give it. Lash lifts reshape your natural lashes with a chemical process, and aftercare usually means avoiding oil-based products that can relax the lift early. That creates a genuine tension with the Magnet formula, which practically demands an oil cleanser for comfortable removal. The original They're Real is the easier companion to a fresh lift: lighter feel, simpler removal, less risk of dragging on reshaped lashes. If you are set on Magnet over a lift, ask your technician what removal method they recommend rather than guessing.
For lash tints, either formula works, though dark mascaras over a fresh tint can look heavy if you apply your usual number of coats. Start with one and build only if you need it. Tubing mascaras are often the kindest option over lifts and tints because they slide off with warm water and zero rubbing, so if your lift aftercare is strict, the Clinique Lash Power tubing guide is worth a read.
Hooded eyes are the other scenario where the two formulas behave differently. Transfer to the brow bone and lid crease is the main failure mode for hooded lids, and a long-wear formula like Magnet genuinely helps because it sets and stays. The original can transfer more on very hooded eyes by late afternoon. Either way, technique matters as much as formula: keep coats thin on the upper lashes, go very light on lower lashes, and consider a dusting of translucent powder on the lid where transfer happens. For length-focused alternatives that reviewers compare against these two, the L'Oreal Telescopic comparison covers waterproof versus washable wear in depth.
Quick Answers Before You Choose
Can you layer Magnet over the original? Yes, and it is actually a smart combination: one coat of the original for separation, then Magnet on the tips for extra length, which keeps the total product load lower than two coats of Magnet alone. Does Magnet work on lower lashes? Use a very light hand, because its intense pigment and staying power punish mistakes on the lower lash line. And if you wear contact lenses, the original is the safer daily pick, since Magnet's long-wear formula is harder to remove completely and residue near lenses causes irritation.