Beauty Benefit Magnet vs Original: They Are Real Mascara Winner
Benefit sells two main versions of They are Real on Amazon. Magnet promises extra length with its mineral enriched core. The original delivers the classic lengthen and volumize result. Both use jet black long wearing formulas. The table below compares price, size, brush design, claims, and ratings. Read the verdict to pick the right tube for your lash goals.
| Factor | Benefit They are Real! Mascara, Magnet, | Benefit Cosmetics They are Real! Mascara |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Check price | Check price |
| Size | 0.3 oz | 8.5 g |
| Best for | Maximum lash length | Classic defined volume |
| Key ingredient | Magnetic minerals | Long wearing polymers |
| Brush | Extender brush design | Staggered bristle brush |
| Rating | ~4.4 | ~4.5 |
| Formula type | Lengthening mascara | Lengthening mascara |
| Length claim | 36 percent longer look | Beyond belief length |
Our Verdict
Magnet wins for length chasers. Its mineral enriched core and extender brush genuinely push lashes further. The price premium is small for the upgrade. The original wins for loyalists who love the classic result. It has more reviews and a slightly higher rating from years of sales. Both resist smudging and wear all day. If your lashes are short and straight, Magnet is worth the extra cost. If you already love the original, there is no reason to switch.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.
Want the Full Picture?
Lower-Lash Mascara: The Fine-Brush Question
Lower-lash mascaras are reviewed in isolation but never ranked head to head, so here is the framework. The challenge with lower lashes: standard mascara wands are too big, depositing too much product and causing the smudging and spider-lash effect that ages the eye. Fine-brush mascaras designed for lower lashes solve this with tiny wands that place product precisely.
Can the They're Real wand work on lower lashes? The original's spiky ball-tipped wand is actually more maneuverable on lower lashes than most volumizing wands, the ball tip allows precise placement. The Magnet version's core is designed for upper-lash length and is less suited to the delicate lower line. The technique: use only the tip of the wand, one light coat, and stop, lower lashes need a whisper of product, not a full application. If smudging is the issue, a tubing mascara on the lower lashes only, with the regular formula on top, is the veteran combination, smudge-proof where it matters, volumizing where it shows. The volumizing mascara guide covers wand shapes that work best for precise lower-lash application.
Primer Pairings for Long-Wear Formulas
Long-wear mascaras like They're Real interact with primers differently than regular formulas. The long-wear film is designed to grip the bare lash, and a primer underneath can either help or interfere depending on type. Conditioning primers without fibers generally help, adding a smooth base that the long-wear film adheres to evenly. Fiber primers can interfere with the lengthening effect, the fibers compete with the formula's own lengthening mechanism.
The test for your combination: apply primer on one eye and not the other, then the mascara on both, and compare at the end of the day for flaking, smudging, and length. If the primed eye looks better, the pairing works for you. The Magnet version's mineral-enriched core is itself a kind of built-in primer effect, which is why it may need primer less than the original. As a rule, the more hardworking the mascara formula, the less it needs underneath, save primers for simpler formulas that benefit from the base.
Long-Wear Mascara and Contact Lenses
Contact lens wearers need specific guidance for long-wear mascaras. The concern: long-wear formulas are designed not to break down, which means any flakes that do shed are more persistent under lenses than regular-mascara flakes. They're Real is known for minimal flaking when fresh, but as the tube ages past two months, flaking increases, and lens wearers notice it first.
The mitigation: replace long-wear mascara on schedule, do not stretch the tube, aging formula is the main flake source. Apply from mid-lash outward, keeping product away from the roots. Insert lenses before any eye makeup, never after. If lenses get consistently cloudy with a long-wear mascara, the formula is shedding micro-particles, and switching to a tubing mascara resolves it in most cases. The waterproof question for lens wearers: waterproof long-wear requires oil-based removal, and residual oil on the lids can film the lenses the next morning, so cleanse thoroughly.
Long-Wear Mascara in Heat, Steam, and Humidity
Tubing mascara's warm-water removal becomes a mid-day bug in heat, but long-wear traditional formulas have their own heat behavior. They're Real's long-wear film holds up well in humidity and sweat, which is its strength, but steam, saunas, and hot showers soften the film, causing the smudging that the formula is famous for resisting in normal conditions.
The real-world ranking for hot conditions: true waterproof mascara wins for swimming and heavy sweating, long-wear regular formulas like They're Real handle humidity and light sweat well, and tubing mascaras are the most vulnerable to steam and hot water. For a beach vacation, the waterproof version of your mascara is the rational choice despite the harder removal. For a humid city summer, the long-wear regular formula is the sweet spot, holding through the day without the waterproof removal penalty. The Magnet versus Original choice matters less here than the waterproof versus regular choice, pick by the forecast. The L'Oreal Telescopic waterproof comparison tests water-resistant versus washable formulas head to head.