Beauty L'Oreal Voluminous Mascara Showdown: 4 Compared Side by Side
Four mascaras, four brushes, four different lash outcomes: that is the Voluminous line in a nutshell. We compared the Original, Miss Manga, Feline, and Panorama across brush design, volume, length, formula behavior, waterproofing, and best lash type, so you can match the wand to your eyes instead of guessing.
| Factor | L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Origi | L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Miss | L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Felin |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brush design | Classic dense volume brush | Cone-shaped Mega Impact | Curved panther brush |
| Primary effect | Maximum volume | Spiky doll-like flare | Winged cat-eye lift |
| Shade covered | Waterproof Carbon Black | Blackest Black | Black |
| Waterproof option | Yes, covered here | Standard washable | Standard washable |
| Clump resistance | Moderate | Good | Good |
| Best lash type | Sparse, short lashes | Medium lashes, small eyes | All, hooded eyes love it |
| Curl hold | Excellent (waterproof) | Moderate | Moderate |
| Removal ease | Needs oil-based remover | Cleanser and water | Cleanser and water |
| Typical price | Check price | Check price | Check price |
| Best for beginners | Yes, most forgiving | Needs a specific taste | Easy winged look |
Our Verdict
Buy the Original if you want proven, no-fuss volume and do not mind oil-based removal for the waterproof version. Buy Panorama if length and separation matter most, especially on short or straight lashes. Buy Miss Manga for a deliberate doll-like lash style, and Feline when you want your mascara to wing the eye like subtle liner. At eight to eleven dollars each, the real pro move is owning two: the Original for everyday volume and whichever specialist matches your mood.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.
Best for: A cat-eye lash look with length and thickness
L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Feline Mascara, Black
- Panther brush with a curved shape for an eyeliner-like effect
- Lengthening and thickening formula in one pass
- Black shade keeps the look sharp rather than soft
- Designed to wing lashes outward like a feline eye
Pros
- Curved brush naturally pushes lashes outward for a lifted look
- Gives eyeliner-adjacent definition without actual liner
- Works well on straight lashes that need a curl illusion
Cons
- Curved brush takes a few uses to master the angle
- Less ideal if you prefer a straight, even lash fringe
- Formula can transfer to lids on very oily skin by evening
Best for: Corner-to-corner fanned lashes with panoramic length
L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Panorama Mascara, Blackest Black
- Multi-level bristle brush coats lashes from corner to corner
- Panoramic effect formula for length plus volume
- Blackest Black shade for high-contrast definition
- One of the newer Voluminous line extensions
Pros
- Brush design separates while it volumizes, fewer clumps
- Length is noticeable even on short, straight lashes
- Holds a curl better than some older Voluminous versions
Cons
- Slightly pricier than the Original in the same line
- Multi-level brush can deposit too much at the base if rushed
- Availability and shade range vary by retailer
Want the Full Picture?
The Lower-Lash Question: Fine Brush vs Regular Wand
Volumizing mascaras are built for upper lashes, and using the same big wand on lower lashes is how most people end up with smudges by noon. The dedicated lower-lash approach uses a fine, small brush that deposits minimal product with precision; several brands now sell lower-lash-specific formulas, but the technique matters more than the tube. Load the wand, wipe most of the product off on the tube rim, then apply with the very tip using vertical strokes. The wiped-off step is non-negotiable, because lower lashes need a fraction of the product uppers do, and excess is what transfers to the under-eye area. If you prefer one mascara for both, apply uppers first, then use whatever remains on the wand for lowers without reloading. Waterproof on lower lashes is worth considering even for daily wear, since the under-eye area collects oil and tears that break down regular formulas fastest; the small amount of product means removal stays easy. For buyers deciding between formula types for this job, our tubing mascara guide is relevant because tubing formulas barely transfer once set, which solves the lower-lash smudge problem elegantly. Test any lower-lash routine on a full workday before trusting it for an event.
Waterproof, Water-Resistant, or Tubing: Picking by Your Actual Day
Volume showdowns usually compare formulas head to head, but the format decision matters as much as the brand. Here is the short version of the matrix. Choose waterproof when the day includes swimming, heavy sweating, or tears you can predict, like weddings; accept that removal needs oil and patience. Choose water-resistant for humid climates and long office days where you want easier removal than waterproof offers. Choose tubing when smudging is the enemy but you want the gentlest removal; tubing survives oily lids and long days but surrenders in saunas and very hot showers. Most buyers overbuy waterproof out of smudge anxiety when tubing would serve them better with far less lash damage at night. The honest test is a week with each format on your normal routine, noting smudge timing and how your lashes feel during removal. Lash health is the tiebreaker that spec sheets ignore: the format you can remove without rubbing is the format your lashes will thank you for. For the detailed breakdown of how tubing differs at the formula level, the L'Oreal Telescopic waterproof vs washable comparison on this site walks through the same decision with specific products, a useful companion read before you buy.