Beauty Telescopic vs Rimmel Scandaleyes: Best Length Mascara Wins
Loreal Telescopic Original and Jeffree Star BeachProof represent two philosophies of lengthening mascara. Telescopic is the precision lengthener with its iconic two sided brush, while BeachProof is the curling lengthener with a curved brush and water resistant wear. Both deliver bold lashes at fair prices, so the choice is purely about the lash effect you want.
| Factor | L'Oreal Paris Telescopic Original Mascar | Jeffree Star Cosmetics BeachProof Mascar |
|---|---|---|
| Main promise | Up to 60 percent longer lashes | Curl, lift and length |
| Brush | Flat plus comb precision brush | Curved lengthening brush |
| Separation | Exceptional, lash by lash | Good, builds without clumping |
| Length | Outstanding | Strong, visible lift |
| Curl | Minimal | Excellent, long lasting |
| Best lash type | Short, sparse, straight | Straight lashes wanting lift |
| Sensitivity | Fragrance free, tested | Standard formula |
| Price | Check price | Check price |
Our Verdict
Choose Telescopic Original if your priority is dramatic length with perfect separation and you have sensitive eyes. Choose Jeffree Star BeachProof if you want curl plus length with water resistant staying power. Length purists go Telescopic, lift lovers go BeachProof.
Waterproof vs Water-Resistant vs Tubing: Which Survives Your Day
No competitor builds a single decision matrix for waterproof vs water-resistant vs tubing, so here is the honest version using these two mascaras as the examples. L'Oreal Telescopic Original is a washable formula: it comes off with warm water and cleanser but will smudge if you cry or sweat heavily. Jeffree Star BeachProof is water-resistant: it survives humidity, light rain, and a workout far better than a washable formula, but it is not a true waterproof, so do not expect it to survive a long swim or a full crying session.
If you swim regularly or your eyes water a lot, neither is the right pick; you need a true waterproof or a tubing formula. Tubing mascaras form polymer tubes that only release with warm water, making them best for swimmers and allergy sufferers, though heat and steam can loosen them by midday. For workouts, humidity, and everyday tears, BeachProof's water resistance is the practical middle ground. For a desk day with no sweat involved, Telescopic's washable formula gives you the dramatic length with the easiest removal. Our tubing mascara guide explains how tubing differs, and the Telescopic waterproof vs washable comparison breaks down L'Oreal's own lineup.
Removal Ranked by Lash Loss: What Each Formula Costs Your Lashes
Telescopic Original comes off with warm water and regular cleanser, with almost no rubbing needed. That is the gentlest possible removal and the reason washable formulas are kindest to lashes long term. BeachProof needs an oil-based or dual-phase remover held against the lashes for twenty to thirty seconds; it releases cleanly with that dwell time, but scrubbing dry pulls out lashes.
Removal difficulty scales with water resistance, and rushed removal is the real cause of lash fallout, not the formula itself. Daily wearers of water-resistant mascara who take the extra thirty seconds lose no more lashes than washable wearers. The worst routine is rubbing water-resistant mascara with a foaming cleanser and no oil, which tugs at the root repeatedly. If you wear BeachProof daily, a proper eye makeup remover is worth it. Our makeup removal guide covers methods that take off stubborn eye makeup without damaging lashes.
Oily Lids: Which Formula Transfers and How to Stop It
Here is the honest answer for this pair on oily lids. Telescopic's washable formula is the more vulnerable of the two: oil breaks down the formula through the day, and by afternoon you may see transfer onto the lid crease or under-eye area. BeachProof's water-resistant film holds up noticeably better against oil, because the same polymers that resist water also resist skin oils.
The system that actually fixes oily-lid transfer has three steps, and most people only do one. First, prime the lid: an eyeshadow primer or translucent powder on the bare lid absorbs oil before mascara touches it. Second, pick the resistant formula; on very oily lids, BeachProof beats Telescopic here. Third, set: a light pass of setting spray over the finished eye locks everything down. If you only do one step, make it the primer, because it matters more than the formula choice. Lower lashes transfer first on oily lids, so skip mascara there on high-oil days, or use a tubing formula, since tubes do not smudge with oil.
Getting All-Day Curl: The Curler and Mascara Combination
Heated lash curlers get one passing tip in competitor content, and nobody tests curler-plus-mascara combinations for all-day curl hold. Since BeachProof promises curl and lift, this is where the combination matters. The curl you get from any mascara depends more on your prep than on the tube. Curl first with a regular eyelash curler on clean, dry lashes, holding for ten seconds at the base and pulsing outward. Apply the mascara immediately, while the curl is fresh.
BeachProof's curved brush lifts as it coats, and its water-resistant film holds the curl better than a washable formula, which tends to weigh it down as the day goes on. Telescopic will not create curl on its own; if you want length plus curl from it, the curler does all the work and the mascara just preserves it. For pin-straight lashes that drop by noon, warm the curler with your hands or a quick blast of a hair dryer on low, test the temperature on your wrist first, and the heat sets the curl like a curling iron sets hair. Pair that with BeachProof and you have the strongest drugstore-range curl combination in this comparison.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.