Beauty Maybelline Color Tattoo Stix Rebellious Vs Lilac Lust Crayon
The Stix in I am Rebellious and the Concentrated Crayon in Lilac Lust represent two generations of Color Tattoo. One is bold matte black, the other playful lilac shimmer. The table compares them directly.
| Factor | Maybelline New York Eyestudio ColorTatto | MAYBELLINE Color Tattoo Longwear Multi-U |
|---|---|---|
| Product | Maybelline Color Tattoo Stix, I am Rebellious | Maybelline Eyestudio ColorTattoo Crayon, Lilac Lust |
| Format | Slim stick, built-in sharpener | Chubby crayon |
| Shade | Matte black | Lilac shimmer |
| Uses | Shadow, liner, primer | Shadow and base |
| Wear | Up to 24 hours | Up to 24 hours |
| Best for | Versatile definition | Playful shimmer |
| Price | Check price | Check price |
Our Verdict
Buy the I am Rebellious Stix if you want the modern multi-use format. Its matte black works for shadow, liner, and primer. It is the more useful single product. Buy the Lilac Lust crayon if you want creamy lilac shimmer for playful eye looks. Both deliver 24-hour tattoo wear, so choose by shade need. Most buyers should start with the Stix for its versatility. If you love purple eye looks, the crayon is a joyful addition.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.
Best for: gold shimmer glow
MAYBELLINE Color Tattoo Longwear Multi-Use Eye Shadow Stix, All-In-One Eye Makeup for Up to 24HR Wear, I am Rare (Gold Shimmer), 1 Count
- Gold shimmer shade
- Multi-use stick format
- Crease-resistant color
Pros
- Beautiful gold light
- Easy application
- Long wear
Cons
- Shimmer not for everyone
- Sets fast
Want the Full Picture?
Stick Shadows on Hooded Lids: What Actually Lasts
Hooded lids are the durability test for any eyeshadow format, and stick shadows like the Color Tattoo Stix have a specific advantage: they set fast and bond directly to the skin without the powder migration that ruins powder shadows on hooded eyes. The crease-resistant claim matters most here, since the hood folds over the shadow with every blink and any mobile formula transfers within the hour. Applied to primed lids, the Stix format typically outlasts powder on hooded eyes by hours.
The technique for hooded lids differs from standard application. Apply with the eye open, looking straight into the mirror, and place the color where it remains visible when the eye is open, which is higher than instinct suggests. Blend the edges with a finger immediately, since stick formulas set within a minute and unblended edges after setting look harsh. The shimmer shades, Lilac Lust and I am Rare, suit hooded lids better than the matte black for daytime: shimmer reflects light and opens the eye, while dark matte on hooded lids can close it down. For the long-wear drugstore benchmark, our L'Oreal Infallible eye guide covers the powder alternative.
The One-and-Done Wash of Color: Beginner Technique
Every tutorial assumes a four-shade gradient, but the single-shadow look is the most wearable technique beginners never learn. The method with a stick shadow: draw the color across the mobile lid in one layer, then blend the upper edge with a clean finger until it fades into the brow bone. That is the entire look. The I am Rare gold shimmer does this beautifully alone, giving dimension through the shimmer's light play rather than through multiple shades.
The shade choice makes or breaks the one-shadow look. Shimmers and satins work alone because they create depth through reflectivity; flat mattes alone can look unfinished unless the application is precise. Lilac Lust's shimmer gives the lilac dimension that a matte lilac could not carry solo. Keep the rest of the face simple when wearing one bold shade: the eye is the statement, and competing blush or lip color turns the look busy. This technique also suits rushed mornings and travel, since it needs one product and ninety seconds. For technique fundamentals that elevate the simple look, our Makeup by Mario eye guide covers the application basics.
Fixing Muddy Blending Mid-Application
Over-blended eyeshadow turns muddy when too many shades mix into an indistinct gray-brown, and the standard advice of "blend more" actively worsens it. The recovery has specific steps. First, stop blending: every additional stroke mixes the colors further. Second, re-establish definition by reapplying the deepest shade to the outer corner only, pressing rather than sweeping, which restores the contrast the over-blending erased. Third, clean the outer edge with a small amount of concealer on a flat brush, carving the sharp boundary that makes the look intentional again.
Prevention beats recovery. Use a light hand with transition shades and build the dark shades in thin layers, since it is easier to add depth than to remove muddiness. Keep brushes clean between shades: the muddy look often comes from a dirty brush depositing yesterday's colors into today's look. With stick shadows specifically, the fast set time is both the risk and the protection: work one eye at a time and blend immediately, since the formula forgives nothing after it sets. The Rebellious black matte demands the most respect here: black over-blended with shimmer turns gray instantly, so keep it precise and limited.
Eyeshadow Expiration and Eye Safety
Powder eyeshadows last longer than their owners assume, but stick and cream formulas have shorter clocks that buyers ignore. Powder shadows stay safe for two to three years if kept dry, since the dry environment inhibits bacterial growth. Cream and stick shadows like the Color Tattoo Stix last twelve to eighteen months after opening: the emollient base that makes them blendable also makes them hospitable to bacteria once the preservatives weaken.
The warning signs cross all formats. A change in smell, especially sour or chemical, means the preservatives failed. Unusual eye irritation, itching, or redness after application that did not happen before signals contamination, not a new allergy. Texture changes, stick shadows turning grainy or separating, mean the formula broke down. The wet-brush habit accelerates everything: dipping a damp brush into powder introduces water and bacteria directly, so always use dry brushes on powder and clean them regularly. Never share eye products, and discard everything used during any eye infection. For the premium blendability benchmark and its care requirements, our Natasha Denona palette guide covers the high-end maintenance.