Beauty NYX Slim Eye Pencil Black vs Taupe: Which Should You Buy
Classic black meets soft taupe. Each shade serves a different eye look. Here is which NYX pencil your eyes need.
| Factor | NYX Professional Makeup Slim Eye Pencil, | NYX Professional Makeup Slim Eye Pencil, |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Check price | Check price |
| Key feature | Intense black definition | Soft natural taupe |
| Best for | Dramatic evening eyes | Daytime natural looks |
| Ease of use | Shows mistakes more | Forgiving soft color |
| Versatility | Liner essential | Liner plus brow filler |
Our Verdict
Black wins as the essential. Every makeup bag needs a reliable black pencil, and this one performs far above its price. Taupe wins for daytime softness and doubles as a brow filler. If you buy one, black covers the classic need. If you already own black liner, taupe adds welcome softness. For most buyers, black is the first purchase. Few options combine beautiful black color with smooth affordable definition as effortlessly as Slim Eye Pencil. For black lovers, Slim Eye Pencil delivers smooth affordable definition that few rivals match at this price.
Black vs Taupe: Choosing by Eye Color, Skin Tone, and Occasion
The NYX Slim Eye Pencil in black and in taupe serve opposite purposes, and competitors never explain the choice beyond "try brown." Black is the maximum-definition shade: it darkens the lash base, sharpens the eye shape, and photographs with high contrast. On deep skin tones and dark eyes, black reads as natural intensity. On very fair skin with light eyes, the same black can dominate the face, especially without mascara or brow definition to balance it. Taupe is the quiet alternative, a gray-brown that defines without announcing itself. It is the better daytime shade for fair to light skin, for professional settings, and for anyone whose style leans natural.
Eye color changes the calculus. Brown eyes gain the most from black liner because the dark frame makes the iris look richer. Blue and green eyes often look better with taupe or brown, since black can overpower lighter irises in daylight. Hazel eyes sit in the middle and wear both well. For the waterline specifically, taupe is the underrated pick: a taupe waterline defines the eye while keeping it looking open, where black on the lower waterline visually shrinks the eye. If you are building a minimal kit, taupe covers daytime and black covers evening, and the two pencils together cost less than most single prestige liners. For waterline-specific formulas, our kajal for sensitive eyes guide covers options designed for the inner rim.
Lining Mature, Crepey Lids Without Skipping
Eyeliner on mature lids fails in one specific way: the pencil skips over fine lines and loose skin, leaving a dotted, broken line. The fix is technique, not product. First, the lid must be set: apply eyeshadow primer or a light layer of powder over the lid so the pencil has a dry, even surface. A creamy pencil like the NYX Slim glides over primed skin far better than over bare, textured skin. Second, stretch the lid gently taut with a fingertip while lining, which smooths the surface temporarily and lets the pencil lay down continuous color. Release slowly and let the line settle into the natural folds.
Formula choice matters too. The black Slim pencil is soft enough to grip textured lids without dragging, which is exactly what mature lids need; a hard, dry pencil skips worse. Taupe is the smarter shade for crepey lids because a softer color forgives an imperfect line, while black exposes every wobble. Placement should stay visible when the lid folds: keep the line close to the lashes rather than drawing a thick band that disappears into the crease when the eye opens. And skip the lower lash line or keep it to a whisper of taupe at the outer corner, since heavy lower liner emphasizes under-eye texture. Tightlining the upper lashes gives definition that survives the lid fold better than any visible line above it.
Lower Lash Line Strategy: Definition Without the Raccoon Effect
The lower lash line is where good eyeliner intentions go wrong. A full black lower line connects visually with under-eye shadows and reads as tiredness, not definition. The honest rule: the lower line should always be softer than the upper line. If you wear black on top, wear taupe below, or wear black only on the outer third of the lower lash line and blend it out. The NYX Slim pencil's fine tip is ideal for this, because it lets you draw a thin, controlled line that you then soften with a smudge brush or fingertip. A thick lower line is what ages the eye; a thin, diffused one defines it.
The raccoon-eye prevention routine has three parts. First, set the lower line with a matching eyeshadow pressed over it, which locks the pencil in place. Second, keep concealer and powder off the lower lash line itself, since product buildup there grabs the liner and drags it down. Third, check the outer corner at midday, because that is where lower liner migrates first. The taupe shade is far more forgiving here than black: migrated taupe looks like soft shadow, migrated black looks like smudging. For evening looks where you want real lower-lash drama, our Feline Flick guide covers wing techniques that balance a stronger lower line with an equally strong upper line so the eye stays balanced.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.