Beauty NYX Eye Pencil Duel: Jumbo Milk vs Slide On Sunrise Blue
The icon against the color statement. Jumbo Milk, the famous white multi-tasker, faces Slide On Sunrise Blue, the vivid waterproof liner. Different formulas, different missions. We compare versatility, wear and value.
| Factor | NYX Professional Makeup Jumbo Eye Pencil | NYX Professional Makeup Jumbo Eye Pencil |
|---|---|---|
| Format | Thick jumbo crayon | Slim waterproof pencil |
| Shade | Matte white Milk | Vivid Sunrise Blue |
| Use | Shadow base, liner, highlight | Precise waterproof liner |
| Waterproof | No, needs setting | Yes, smudge-proof |
| Versatility | Many uses in one | Liner focused |
| Price | Check price | Check price |
Our Verdict
Choose Jumbo Milk for unmatched versatility and the famous shadow-base trick. Choose Slide On Sunrise Blue for vivid waterproof color that stays put. Most NYX fans own both since they serve totally different purposes. At these prices, get both.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.
Best for: Inner-corner brightness.
NYX Professional Makeup Jumbo Eye Pencil, Iced Latte
- Jumbo pencil in Iced Latte, champagne
- Shimmery nude for inner corners
- Creamy, easy-glide crayon
- Brightens tired eyes
Pros
- Champagne brightens instantly
- Pretty as a brow bone highlight
- Affordable glow
Cons
- Shimmer can look frosty
- Fades without primer
- Thick pencil, imprecise lines
Best for: Bold blue liner looks.
NYX Professional Makeup Slide On Pencil, Sunrise Blue
- Slide On pencil in Sunrise Blue
- Waterproof, smudge-proof formula
- Silky soft, intense color
- Like liquid liner in pencil form
Pros
- Vivid blue with one swipe
- Truly waterproof wear
- Glides without tugging
Cons
- Blue is bold for daily wear
- Hard to remove fully
- Needs sharpening
Best for: Smoky eyes without black.
NYX Professional Makeup Slide On Pencil, Gun Metal
- Slide On pencil in Gun Metal
- Dark grey with metallic sheen
- Waterproof, no-smudge formula
- Softer alternative to black
Pros
- Smoky grey with edge
- Softer than harsh black
- Stays put all day
Cons
- Metallic sheen fades to flat grey
- Tough removal
- Pencil tip breaks if pressed hard
Want the Full Picture?
Which Blue Flatters Your Eyes: Colored Liner Beyond the Trend
Sunrise Blue is not a one-shade-suits-all color, and the old advice to just try blue misses the actual color theory. Blue liner makes brown eyes look warmer and deeper by contrast, which is why it photographs so dramatically on brown eyes. On blue eyes, a vivid blue liner can blend into the iris and disappear; navy or teal usually defines better. Green and hazel eyes get the most striking effect from blue, since the contrast pulls out green tones that neutral liners hide.
For daytime wear, keep the vivid shade to a thin line along the upper lashes rather than a full wing; the color reads as intentional without overwhelming. Brown remains the best daytime neutral for most eye colors, softer than black and more defining than no liner. Reserve black for evening or for tightlining, where it adds density without a visible line. If you love the Sunrise Blue but find it loud, layer it: a thin blue line over a black base gives dimension that reads interesting up close and neutral from across the room.
Removal Difficulty Ranked: What Each Formula Actually Needs
Not all NYX pencils remove the same way, and scrubbing a stubborn liner is how lashes get lost. Easiest is the Jumbo Eye Pencil in Milk and Iced Latte: non-waterproof crayons that dissolve with any basic makeup remover or micellar water, no rubbing needed. Hardest is the Slide On in Sunrise Blue: genuinely waterproof, it needs an oil-based or dual-phase remover and a full sixty-second soak on a cotton pad before wiping.
The safe removal method for the waterproof shade: saturate a pad with oil-based remover, press it over the closed eye for a full minute without moving, then glide, do not scrub, downward and outward. Repeat rather than pressing harder. Scrubbing at waterproof liner tugs the lash line and breaks lashes over time, which is a real cost of daily waterproof wear. Never sleep in the Slide On formula; waterproof pigments plus overnight eye movement is the fastest route to irritated eyes. For more on choosing pencils that survive the day without a fight at night, our waterproof eye pencil guide compares the tradeoffs across brands.
Tightlining for Beginners: Where the Product Actually Goes
Tightlining, filling between the lashes rather than drawing on the lid, is the technique that makes lashes look thicker with no visible liner, and the Jumbo pencil's thick crayon is actually well suited to learning it. The product goes into the tiny gaps between lash roots on the upper lash line, not on the waterline itself. Look down into a mirror, gently lift the lid, and dot the crayon between lashes with small presses rather than drawing a line.
Two beginner mistakes cause most irritation: pressing the crayon directly onto the waterline, which transfers product onto the eye surface, and dragging the tip along the lash roots, which tugs. Dotting is gentler and gives a more even result. Set the tightline with a matching eyeshadow pressed over it if you need it to last all day, since the Jumbo formula is not waterproof and fades faster on the moist lash line. Those new to pencil liners generally will find the learning curve short; our Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On guide covers the iconic pencil liner many graduates reach for next, with technique tips that transfer directly.