Beauty NYX Slide On Sunrise Blue Vs Jumbo Eye Pencil Iced Latte
The Slide On Pencil in Sunrise Blue and the Jumbo Eye Pencil in Iced Latte are two verified NYX eye pencils. One is bold and waterproof, the other neutral and versatile. This comparison helps you choose.
| Factor | NYX Professional Makeup Slide On Pencil, | NYX Professional Makeup Jumbo Eye Pencil |
|---|---|---|
| Product | Slide On, Sunrise Blue | Jumbo Eye Pencil, Iced Latte |
| Color | Vivid blue | Shimmery neutral |
| Formula | Waterproof liner | Creamy multitasker |
| Best for | Bold liner looks | Shadow, base, liner |
| Typical price | Check price | Check price |
| Versatility | Liner only | Eyes, base, highlight |
Our Verdict
Pick Sunrise Blue for bold waterproof color. Pick the Jumbo pencil for everyday neutral versatility. Both are affordable NYX essentials under ten dollars.
Colored Eyeliner by Eye Color: Beyond "Try Blue"
No competitor covers colored eyeliner beyond "try blue": which colors flatter which eye colors with real shade names. The Sunrise Blue here is the test case. On brown eyes, vivid blue creates the highest contrast in the eye makeup world, making brown eyes look warmer and deeper by opposition. On blue eyes, blue liner intensifies the eye color but risks a matchy flatness, the fix is using it as a wing or lower-line accent rather than all-around. On green and hazel eyes, blue is the most dramatic choice, pulling green tones forward powerfully.
The Iced Latte neutral plays a different role: shimmery champagne-nude on the waterline makes eyes look bigger and brighter, which is why makeup artists call it the "awake" trick. On the lid as a base, it evens discoloration and grips powder shadow applied over it. For daytime, the blue as a thin upper line with the nude on the waterline is striking but wearable. For evening, blue on both upper and lower lines with the nude in the inner corner is a full editorial look. The wing technique guide covers application methods that suit bold colors.
Waterproof Pencil Removal Ranked by Difficulty
No competitor compares eyeliner removal difficulty across formats ranked by what remover they actually need. The Slide On's waterproof formula sits in the middle of the difficulty ranking: it needs an oil-based or bi-phase remover, since micellar water alone requires too many passes. The method: press a remover-soaked pad over the closed eye for fifteen seconds, then wipe outward once. The dwell time dissolves the waterproof film so it releases instead of being scrubbed.
The Jumbo pencil's creamy non-waterproof formula removes with any gentle cleanser, which is a genuine daily-wear advantage. The lash-loss angle matters here: scrubbing waterproof liner off nightly with dry pads pulls lashes at the root and roughens the lash line, so the press-and-hold method is not just comfort, it is lash preservation. Never sleep in the waterproof formula, overnight wear makes the film bond harder and morning removal takes triple the friction. For swimmers and athletes who need the waterproof to actually perform, the waterproof pencil guide tests which formulas survive pools and sweat.
The Lower Lash Line: When It Ages Versus Defines
Nobody addresses the lower lash line honestly: when lining the lower lashes ages the eye versus defines it. The rule is about placement and intensity. Lining the full lower waterline in a dark or vivid shade closes the eye down and can read aging, especially on smaller or deep-set eyes. Lining only the outer third of the lower lash line, not the waterline, defines without closing. The Sunrise Blue on the lower lash line, kept to the outer half and softly smudged, is modern and defining; the same blue all around the waterline is a statement that suits evening better.
The Iced Latte on the lower waterline is the anti-aging trick: the light shimmer opens the eye and counteracts the closing effect of upper liner. For mature eyes, this combination, defined upper line plus light lower waterline, lifts the eye more than any single product. The raccoon-eye prevention routine: set the lower line with a matching powder shadow pressed over it, which locks the pencil and stops the migration that creates under-eye smudging by afternoon. And keep lower-line product off the inner corner, where it collects and emphasizes dark circles.
Oily Lids: Making Pencil Liner Last
No guide covers eyeliner for oily lids as a system. The combination that works: eyeshadow primer on the lid first, pencil over it, then a matching powder shadow pressed on top to set. The primer grips, the powder locks, and each layer is thin. The Slide On's waterproof formula already resists oil well, but the Jumbo's creamy texture needs the full system on oily lids or it migrates by midday. The step that matters most is the powder set, which most people skip and which makes the biggest single difference.
NYX Eye Pencil Questions
Yes, that is its best multitasker use. Apply it across the lid as a cream shadow base, blend the edges with a finger, and set with powder shadow for all-day wear. The shimmer shade works beautifully as a one-and-done lid color.
Vivid blue pencils can leave a faint tint on the waterline after removal, which fades within an hour. An oil-based remover minimizes staining versus micellar water. If staining bothers you, wear the blue on the lash line rather than the waterline.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.