Beauty Makeup By Mario Eye Palettes, Mattes Vs Ethereal Compared
Master Mattes and Ethereal Eyes Moonlight are the two essential Makeup By Mario eye palettes. Master Mattes is all matte neutrals for definition and depth. Ethereal Eyes Moonlight mixes mattes, satins, and glossy shimmers for luminous looks. This comparison breaks down finishes, versatility, and best buyer.
| Factor | MAKEUP BY MARIO Master Mattes Eyeshadow | MAKEUP BY MARIO Ethereal Eyes Eyeshadow |
|---|---|---|
| Palette | Master Mattes | Ethereal Eyes Moonlight |
| Shade count | 12 matte shades | 12 mixed finish shades |
| Finishes | All matte | Matte, satin, shimmer, metallic |
| Color story | Universal skin tone neutrals | Moonlit luminous neutrals |
| Best for | Everyday definition | Glowy statement eyes |
| Skill level | Beginner friendly | Intermediate |
| Price range | Around sixty dollars | Around sixty dollars |
Our Verdict
Master Mattes wins as the first palette to buy. Its all matte neutrals handle every daily eye look with zero fuss. Ethereal Eyes Moonlight wins for shimmer lovers and evening glam. Its glossy finishes create dimension mattes cannot. Buy Master Mattes first, then add Ethereal Eyes when you crave shine.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.
Best for: Collectors and warm tone lovers wanting the limited Nature edition.
MAKEUP BY MARIO Ethereal Eyes Eyeshadow Palette, Nature Limited Edition
- Limited edition
- Earthy neutral shades
- Sueded matte and shimmer
Pros
- Earthy sunlit tones
- Limited edition collectible
- Blendable longwear formula
Cons
- Limited availability
- Earthy range not for everyone
Choosing Palette Shades by Eye Color
Colored eyeliner guides stop at "try blue," and palette guides rarely map shades to eye colors, so here is the practical chart. Brown eyes are the most versatile and wear almost everything, but plums, bronzes, and coppers make them glow, all present in the Ethereal Eyes Moonlight shimmers. Green and hazel eyes intensify with reddish and plum tones, since red sits opposite green on the color wheel. The warm mattes in both palettes serve this beautifully. Blue eyes pop against warm bronze and copper, while cool grays and taupes create a smoky harmony.
The Master Mattes palette is the workhorse for all of this, since matte transition and crease shades do the structural work regardless of eye color. The Ethereal Eyes Moonlight adds the eye-color-specific magic with its shimmers and glossy finishes. The technique that maximizes the effect: place the eye-color-flattering shade on the mobile lid where it catches light, and keep the crease work neutral. The lid shade is what interacts with the iris. A brown-eyed buyer gets more from a copper shimmer on the lid than from any amount of crease work, and the same principle holds for every eye color.
Wing technique to pair with these palettes is in our Charlotte Tilbury Feline Flick liquid pen guide.
Palette Placement for Deep-Set vs Prominent Eyes
Wing angles differ by eye placement, and so does eyeshadow placement, yet every tutorial assumes the average eye. Deep-set eyes need light and lift. Place the lightest shimmer on the mobile lid and inner corner to bring the eye forward, keep the crease shade soft and blended above the natural crease, and avoid dark colors on the mobile lid, which push deep-set eyes further back. The Ethereal Eyes Moonlight shimmers are ideal here, doing the brightening work that deep-set eyes need.
Prominent eyes need the opposite. Deeper matte shades on the mobile lid recede the eye, while shimmer stays minimal and controlled. The Master Mattes palette is the prominent-eye hero, with its all-matte neutrals providing the depth without the light reflection that emphasizes prominence. The universal mistake is applying the same look to both eye types. Placement is the technique, and the palette is just the tool. Learn your eye placement once, in the mirror with a straight-on photo, and every palette you own gets easier to use.
Mattes on Mature, Crepey Lids
How to line lids with loose skin gets some coverage, but matte eyeshadow on crepey lids needs its own guide. The concern is that matte shadow emphasizes texture, and it can, but the alternative is worse. Shimmer on crepey lids highlights every fold with light reflection. Well-applied matte is actually the kinder choice, because it does not create the contrast that draws the eye to texture. The Master Mattes formula, finely milled and blendable, is well suited to this.
The technique: prime the lid to create a smooth base, which matters more on mature lids than on young ones. Apply matte shades with a fluffy brush in sheer layers, building gradually rather than packing on color. Avoid dragging the brush, which skips on loose skin. Pressing and stippling motions deposit color evenly. Keep the darkest shades tight to the lash line rather than swept across the lid, which minimizes the area where texture shows. And the Ethereal Eyes glossy shimmers are not forbidden on mature lids. A touch of shimmer just in the center of the lid catches light beautifully. The rule is placement, not prohibition.
The iconic pencil liner to pair with any palette look is in our Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On pencil guide.
Cost Per Use: Palette Math
A gel pot versus the alternative pencils gets mentioned, but palette cost-per-use is never calculated. The math favors palettes enormously for regular users. A 14-pan palette used across ten shades delivers hundreds of applications, bringing the per-use cost to pennies. The catch is shade usage. Most buyers rotate four to five favorites and ignore the rest, which means the effective cost per used shade is higher than the sticker suggests. The Master Mattes palette wins on this metric, since its neutral mattes are the shades buyers actually finish. The Ethereal Eyes Moonlight's specialty shimmers get used less often, making its per-use cost higher in practice. The honest advice: buy the palette whose shades you will actually wear daily, not the one with the prettiest promo image.