Beauty Eye Kohl Compared: Maybelline Kajal vs Rimmel Waterproof
Maybelline Colossal Kajal and Rimmel Scandaleyes are drugstore kohl legends. Maybelline offers waterproof 24 hour kajal in a value two pack. Rimmel counters with a sparkling black waterproof formula. Both deliver bold definition at tiny prices. We compare them head to head. Both are drugstore legends with loyal followings worldwide. Your personal finish preference decides the winner. Drugstore prices deliver luxury impact.
| Factor | Maybelline New York Colossal Kajal Dark | LAURA GELLER NEW YORK Kajal Longwear Koh |
|---|---|---|
| Formula | Waterproof kajal, 24 hour stay claim | Waterproof kohl kajal liner |
| Finish | Deep matte black | Sparkling black with shimmer |
| Pack | Pack of 2, great value | Single pencil |
| Best for | Intense matte waterline | Dramatic shimmer eyes |
| Price | Check price | Check price |
Our Verdict
Maybelline Colossal Kajal wins for most buyers. The two pack value is unbeatable, and the deep matte black suits every kohl look. Its waterproof 24 hour claim holds up well in real wear. Rimmel Scandaleyes wins for shimmer lovers who want dimension. The sparkling black adds festive drama that matte cannot match. Choose Maybelline for everyday intense kohl at the best price. Choose Rimmel when you want your black liner to catch the light. Keep both in your kit for maximum versatility.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.
Best for: Buyers who want a shimmery black waterproof kajal at a drugstore price.
Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Kohl Kajal Liner, Sparkling Black, 0.04 Fluid Ounce
- Waterproof kohl kajal formula
- Sparkling Black has subtle shimmer
- 0.04 fl oz pencil
- Drugstore classic for bold eyes
Pros
- Shimmer adds dimension to black liner
- Waterproof hold for the price
Cons
- Shimmer is not ideal for matte looks
- Can drag on dry lids
Removal Difficulty Ranked: Kohl vs Waterproof vs Gel
Kohl eyeliners remove more easily than their reputation suggests, and the format ranking matters for lash health. Soft kohl like the Maybelline Colossal Kajal dissolves with a standard oil cleanser or micellar water with minimal rubbing. Waterproof pencils like the Rimmel Scandaleyes need a dual-phase or oil remover and more dwell time. Gel pots in waterproof formulas are the most stubborn, often needing dedicated eye makeup remover and gentle patience.
The lash-loss risk comes from the removal, not the formula. Scrubbing waterproof kohl off nightly with makeup wipes pulls lashes steadily. The safe method for any kohl: saturate a cotton pad with oil-based remover, press against the closed eye for thirty seconds, then wipe gently outward. Never drag inward toward the tear duct with pressure. If kohl remains in the waterline after cleansing, a cotton swab with micellar water handles the residue without rubbing the lashes. Daily kohl wearers should favor the removal their lashes can sustain for years. The waterproof eye pencil guide ranks removal effort across waterproof options.
Kohl for Contact Lens Wearers: The Specifics
Kohl and contact lenses have a workable relationship with the right rules. The migration risk is real: kohl particles can transfer onto lenses, causing irritation and blurry vision. Tightlining, applying between the lashes rather than on the waterline, keeps product away from the lens surface. If you tightline, use a freshly sharpened pencil, since a blunt tip deposits chunks that migrate more.
Insertion order matters: put lenses in before applying kohl, so any fallout during application does not get trapped under the lens. Remove lenses before removing makeup at night. Waterproof kohl is actually the better lens choice despite harder removal, since it migrates less during wear. The Rimmel Scandaleyes waterproof on this page suits lens wearers for that reason. If irritation occurs, the kohl is the first suspect: discontinue for a week and see if symptoms resolve. The sensitive kajal guide covers low-irritation kohl options.
Lower Lash Line: When It Works and When It Ages
Lining the lower lashes defines the eye but can also age it, and the difference is placement and intensity. A soft smudged line along the outer two-thirds of the lower lash line defines without closing the eye. A harsh full lower line, especially in black, makes eyes look smaller and older. The Maybelline Colossal Kajal's intense black needs a light hand below; the Rimmel shimmer black is more forgiving since its sparkle reads softer.
Placement options rank by effect. Tightlining the upper only is the most eye-opening. Adding soft lower outer-third definition adds drama without shrinkage. Full lower waterline in black is the most aging and should be reserved for deliberate dramatic looks. The raccoon-eye prevention routine: set the lower line with a matching eyeshadow pressed over it, which locks the kohl and absorbs the oil that causes midday migration. Check the lower line at midday; kohl always travels somewhat, and a quick clean with a cotton swab restores the definition. The glide-on liner guide covers smudge-resistant lower-line techniques.
Want the Full Picture?
Getting the Most From Your Eye Makeup
The Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Kohl Kajal Liner, Sparkling Black, 0.04 Fluid Ounc and the other picks in this roundup both perform better with the right technique, since eye makeup is one of the categories where application skill matters most. Apply mascara by wiggling at the base of the lashes first, because that is what builds volume where it shows. Let the first coat set for a few seconds before adding a second, since wet-on-wet layering is what causes clumps.
For eyeliner, rest your elbow on a table to steady your hand, because a stable hand draws a cleaner line than a floating one.