Beauty VASANTI Kajal Vs Rimmel Scandaleyes: Best Kajal Compared
VASANTI and Rimmel make two of the most loved kajal pencils. One focuses on waterline safety, the other on waterproof intensity. Here is how they compare.
| Factor | L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Smoldering Eyel | VASANTI Kajal Waterline Eyeliner Intense |
|---|---|---|
| Product | VASANTI Kajal Waterline Intense Black | Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Kohl Kajal |
| Waterline safety | Designed for waterline | Ophthalmologist tested |
| Waterproof | Water-resistant | Fully waterproof |
| Best for | Sensitive eyes | Bold all-day wear |
| Formula | Velvety matte | Creamy kohl |
| Ease of use | Twist-up, no sharpener | Needs sharpening |
| Typical price | Check price | Check price |
Our Verdict
Choose VASANTI if you want the safest waterline kajal for sensitive eyes. The ophthalmologist-tested formula stays comfortable for hours. Choose Rimmel Scandaleyes if you want waterproof intensity at a drugstore price. It delivers bold kohl color that survives the whole day. VASANTI wins for eye safety and waterline comfort. Rimmel wins for price and waterproof wear. Both glide smoothly and smudge well for smoky looks. Pick VASANTI for daily waterline wear and Rimmel for dramatic waterproof lines.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.
Best for: Waterproof kajal at the lowest price
Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Kohl Kajal
- Waterproof kohl formula
- High-intensity color
- Creamy glide texture
Pros
- Stays put all day
- Very cheap
- Ophthalmologist tested
Cons
- Hard to remove
- Few shades available
Eyeliner for Contact Lens Wearers: The Specifics
No competitor covers eyeliner for contact lens wearers with specifics, so here they are. The migration problem: soft kohl and kajal formulas flake or smudge into the tear film, and particles on the lens cause irritation, blurred vision, and protein deposits that shorten lens life. The formulas that migrate least: waterproof pencils and well-set gel liners; the formulas that migrate most: loose kohl powders and soft traditional kajals, which is directly relevant to the kajal comparison in this guide.
Tightlining with lenses requires care: apply the liner with the eye looking down and the lid gently lifted, keeping product on the lash line rather than the waterline where it meets the lens directly. Insertion order: put lenses in before makeup, so liner particles never get trapped under a lens during insertion; remove lenses before removing makeup, so remover and dissolved liner do not coat the lens. Daily disposable lenses reduce the stakes considerably: any liner transfer gets discarded with the lens at night instead of accumulating on a reusable pair.
For kajal formulated for sensitive eyes, the kajal for sensitive eyes guide is the natural companion.
Removal Difficulty Across Formats: Ranked Honestly
Nobody ranks eyeliner removal difficulty, so buyers discover it painfully. Easiest: regular pencil and non-waterproof liquid, which dissolve with standard makeup remover or micellar water. Moderate: waterproof pencil and gel, which need an oil-based or dual-phase remover and 30 seconds of soaking before wiping. Hardest: waterproof liquid and long-wear ink liners, which often need dedicated eye makeup remover plus gentle repeated passes.
The lash-loss risk is real and unaddressed: scrubbing stubborn liner back and forth pulls lashes out at the root, and repeated aggressive removal thins the lash line over time. The safe technique: saturate a cotton pad with remover, press it against the closed eye for 30 seconds to dissolve the product, then wipe gently downward once. Never rub side to side on the lash line.
For waterproof pencil options that balance wear and removability, the waterproof pencil guide covers the category.
Colored Liner by Eye Color: Beyond "Try Blue"
Colored eyeliner advice stops at "try blue," so here are real shade names by eye color. Brown eyes: bronze, copper, and plum liners intensify the warmth; navy adds contrast without the harshness of black. Blue eyes: bronze and copper make blue irises look bluer through complementary contrast; grey softens the look for daytime. Green and hazel eyes: plum, burgundy, and eggplant pull out the green; gold adds warmth.
Brown versus black for daytime: brown defines without the severity black brings, which suits fair skin and professional settings; black reads evening and drama. White or nude on the waterline: opens the eye and makes it look larger, which suits small or deep-set eyes, but on very fair skin it can look stark, so nude usually beats white.
For the iconic pencil liner range with extensive shade options, the Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On guide covers the benchmark.
Waterproof Liner for Swimmers and Athletes
Waterproof eyeliner for swimmers and athletes gets no real coverage. Which formulas survive: true waterproof pencils and tubing liquid liners survive pool chlorine and sweat best; water-resistant softens under sustained water exposure. Goggle pressure is the overlooked factor: tight goggles press on the outer eye area and can smudge even waterproof liner at the pressure points, so keep the wing clear of the goggle seal line.
The post-swim touch-up routine: pat the eye area dry rather than rubbing, check the outer corners and lower line where water collects, and carry the pencil for touch-ups rather than expecting one application to survive a full swim session. Chlorine dries the eye area, so moisturize after swimming before reapplying. Salt water is similarly drying, and sand particles demand the same pat-dry care as pool water to avoid grinding grit into the liner. For wing technique once the basics hold, the Charlotte Tilbury Feline Flick guide is the technique anchor.