Beauty Redken Oil Showdown: Comparing the Two Most Popular Options
Two Redken Oil products stand out above the rest, so we put them head to head. Redken All Soft Argan-6 Oil Treatment leads our list as the top overall pick, while Redken All Soft Argan-6 Oil, Classic Pack earns a strong runner up spot. We compared them on formula, real world results, price, and ease of use. Both are verified Amazon listings with strong buyer ratings. The right choice depends on your hair type, your budget, and how you like to style. Read the full breakdown below to see which one fits you best.
| Factor | Redken All Soft Argan-6 Oil Treatment | Redken All Soft Argan-6 Oil, Classic Pac |
|---|---|---|
| Best for | Redken All Soft Argan-6 Oil Treatment lovers | Redken All Soft Argan-6 Oil lovers |
| Key strengths | Argan oil plus 12 percent moisture complex | Same argan-6 formula |
| Ease of use | Simple routine | Simple routine |
| Value for money | Check price | Check price |
| Scent and feel | Brand signature feel | Light, pleasant feel |
| Overall winner | Top overall pick | Strong runner up |
Our Verdict
Our winner is Redken All Soft Argan-6 Oil Treatment, thanks to its strong all around performance and wide appeal across hair types. It delivers the most consistent results for the price. That said, Redken All Soft Argan-6 Oil, Classic Pack is an excellent alternative if you want a different formula or a lower price point. Either pick will serve you well, so choose based on your specific hair needs. Both links below go to verified Amazon listings.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.
Best for: Blow dry lovers wanting speed plus shine.
Redken Diamond Oil Glow Dry, 3.4 oz
- Heat responsive oil technology
- Reduces blow dry time
- Maximum shine and style memory
- For all hair types
Pros
- Faster blowouts
- Glass like shine
- Lightweight control
Cons
- Best with heat styling
- Silicone based
- Not a treatment oil
Best for: Travelers testing the All Soft line.
Redken All Soft Mini Kit
- Shampoo, conditioner, leave in minis
- Argan oil travel set
- Try the full regimen
- Travel sizes
Pros
- Test the whole line cheaply
- Travel friendly
- Great gift
Cons
- Small sizes
- No full size oil
- Runs out fast
Best for: Very dry hair needing leave in moisture.
Redken All Soft Moisture Restore Leave-In Treatment
- Hyaluronic acid plus argan oil
- 10x smoother hair claim
- Heat protection to 450 F
- Anti frizz leave in
Pros
- Instant moisture
- Award winning formula
- Detangles fast
Cons
- Leave in step adds time
- Can build up
- Premium price
Want the Full Picture?
Penetrating Versus Sealing: Where Redken Oils Sit
Oils divide into penetrating and sealing families, and knowing where a product sits determines how to use it. Penetrating oils like coconut and olive enter the hair shaft and reduce protein loss: they are treatments. Sealing oils like argan, jojoba, and silicones sit on the surface locking in moisture: they are finishers. Redken's Diamond Oil and similar formulas are primarily sealing blends built on silicones with nourishing oils: they excel at shine, frizz control, and heat protection, but they do not penetrate like pure coconut oil. This means using them as finishing oils on damp or dry hair, not as pre-wash treatments expecting deep repair. The full buyer guide breaks down the formulas on this page by function so you buy the right tool for your specific need.
Diamond Oil For Fine Hair
Fine hair and oil blends are a difficult pairing, but Diamond Oil's lightness makes it workable with discipline. The fine-hair protocol is one to two drops on damp hair, ends only, never near the roots: this gives shine and frizz control without sacrificing volume. Apply to damper hair than you think, since the water dilutes the oil naturally for a sheerer application. Avoid layering the oil with heavy leave-in creams, which compound the weight: choose the oil or the cream, not both. If hair still falls flat, the dose is still too high or the formula too rich, and a pure lightweight oil or oil mist suits better. The All Soft line on this page is richer and suits medium to coarse hair; fine hair should gravitate to the Diamond Oil specifically.
Oil And Heat Styling: The Layering Order
Oil plus heat tools need correct sequencing or the oil fries rather than protects. Heat protectant goes on damp hair first and needs direct hair contact to work: it is the non-negotiable base layer. Oil goes on after the protectant, either before styling for added smoothness or after styling for shine, but never instead of protectant. The common error is oiling before protectant, which blocks the protectant from bonding to the hair. With silicone-heavy oils like Diamond Oil, a little goes far under heat: excess oil plus flat iron equals sizzling and damage, not shine. For blowouts, oil the mid-lengths and ends after drying for polish; for flat ironing, a single drop smoothed over each section before the pass adds glide. Never apply oil to hair that is already hot from styling and expect absorption: it sits on top and looks greasy.
Blends Versus Pure Oils: The Silicone Question
Commercial blends like Redken's and pure single oils serve different masters, and silicones are the dividing line. Blends use silicones for instant slip, shine, and frizz control that pure oils cannot match, plus fragrance for a premium experience. Pure oils offer unadulterated nourishment with no buildup risk and full ingredient control. The tradeoff is immediate cosmetic performance versus long-term hair health: blends look better today, pure oils treat better over time. Buildup is the blend's real cost: silicones accumulate and need periodic clarifying, while pure oils wash out cleanly. Cost per milliliter favors pure oils heavily, since blends charge premium prices for formulas that are largely silicone. The background guide covers the formulation philosophy so you can decide which camp suits your routine.