Beauty Redken Hair Oil Compared: 5 Salon Formulas Side by Side
We compared five Redken hair oils and treatments on Amazon. The All Soft Argan-6 Oil is the best all-rounder for dry hair with 72-hour moisture. The Naked Gloss Shine Oil wins for color-treated hair chasing mirror shine. This comparison covers moisture power, shine, price, and ideal hair types. Damaged hair benefits from layering: All Soft Argan-6 on damp hair for moisture, then a touch of Naked Gloss on dry ends for shine. Fine hair should pick just one lightweight formula to avoid overload. Start small.
| Factor | Redken All Soft Argan-6 Oil Treatment | Redken Naked Gloss Shine Hair Oil |
|---|---|---|
| Main benefit | All Soft Argan-6 leads on deep moisture for dry hair. Naked Gloss leads on shine for color-treated hair. Diamond Oil leads on blow-dry speed. Leave-ins lead on daily convenience. | |
| Best hair type | All Soft suits dry, coarse, or brittle hair. Naked Gloss suits color-treated and dull hair. Diamond Oil suits thick hair that takes forever to blow-dry. Leave-ins suit anyone wanting easy daily conditioning. | |
| Price comparison | The 1 oz leave-in is the cheapest trial at around ten dollars. Full-size oils range from thirty to forty-five dollars. Naked Gloss costs the most but targets a premium shine need. | |
| Texture and weight | Naked Gloss feels the lightest and suits fine hair. All Soft Argan-6 is richer for dry hair. Diamond Oil sits in the middle. Leave-in treatments absorb fastest of all. | |
| Heat protection | All Soft Argan-6 and Naked Gloss both protect up to 450 degrees. Diamond Oil also shields during blow-drying. Leave-ins offer lighter thermal protection. All four beat using no protectant. | |
| Ease of use | Leave-in treatments win for simplicity with no-rinse daily use. Oils need careful dosing to avoid greasiness. The 1 oz leave-in is perfect for travel. Pumps on full sizes dose well. | |
| Salon pedigree | All five are genuine Redken pro formulas. Diamond Oil is the longest-running classic. Naked Gloss is the newest shine science. All Soft is the most repurchased moisture line. | |
Our Verdict
The All Soft Argan-6 Oil wins as the best all-round Redken hair oil for dry hair, with 72-hour moisture and heat protection in one bottle. Shine chasers with color-treated hair should pick Naked Gloss instead. Budget testers grab the 1 oz leave-in. Blow-dry lovers keep Diamond Oil on the shelf. Match the formula to your number one hair concern. Start with the 1 oz leave-in if you are still.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.
Best for: Blow-dry lovers who want speed plus salon-level shine.
Redken Diamond Oil Glow Dry Detangling Shine Oil, 3.4 oz
- Micro-diamond formula for high shine
- Speeds up blow-dry time
- Detangles while adding glow
- Lightweight oil, no greasy finish
Pros
- Faster blow-drying
- High-shine finish
- A salon classic
Cons
- Older packaging varies
- Price creeps up online
- Not for very fine hair
Best for: Dry, brittle hair owners who want daily leave-in moisture.
Redken All Soft Moisture Restore Leave-In Treatment
- Leave-in conditioning treatment for dry hair
- Restores moisture balance with argan oil complex
- Adds softness and manageability
- Use daily, no rinse needed
Pros
- Convenient no-rinse formula
- Pairs with All Soft system
- Good for brittle ends
Cons
- Can build up with daily use
- Scent divides opinions
- Bottle is small for the price
Best for: Travelers and first-time Redken buyers testing the All Soft leave-in.
Redken All Soft Moisture Restore Leave-In, 1.0 fl oz
- Travel-size All Soft leave-in treatment
- Same argan moisture formula as full size
- TSA-friendly 1 oz bottle
- Ideal trial size before committing
Pros
- Cheap way to try the formula
- Travel friendly
- Lasts weeks as trial
Cons
- Tiny bottle
- Poor value per ounce
- Hard to find in stores
Want the Full Picture?
Penetrating vs sealing oils: which does what
Hair oils divide into two functional families that nobody explains clearly. Penetrating oils (coconut, olive, avocado) have small molecular structures that enter the hair shaft, where they reduce protein loss and strengthen from within. They work best as pre-wash treatments with time to absorb. Sealing oils (jojoba, argan, grapeseed) sit on the surface, smoothing the cuticle, adding shine, and locking in moisture: they work best as finishing oils on damp or dry hair. Using a sealing oil as a pre-wash treatment wastes its strengths; using a penetrating oil as a finisher can leave hair feeling heavy.
Porosity decides which family you need most. High-porosity hair (damaged, bleached, very curly) drinks up penetrating oils and needs them, plus sealing oils to lock the moisture in. Low-porosity hair resists absorption, so heavy penetrating oils sit on top and look greasy: lightweight sealing oils in small amounts work better. The Redken Diamond Oil in this comparison is a sealing-style shine oil: it excels as a finisher, not as a deep treatment. Match the oil's job to your hair's need rather than buying by brand. The Redken hair oil buyer guide covers the products, and the Redken routine guide shows how the oils fit the full regimen.
Commercial blends vs pure single oils
Commercial oil blends (like most salon hair oils) and pure single oils (a bottle of pure argan) are different products with different math. Blends typically combine a small amount of featured oil with silicones, lighter carrier oils, and fragrance: the silicones give the instant slip and shine, which is why blends feel more transformative on first use. Pure oils give you exactly what the label says, with no silicones masking the true conditioning effect, but they can feel heavier and less cosmetically elegant.
The cost comparison favors pure oils dramatically per milliliter of actual oil, but the comparison is not quite fair: you are paying in blends for the cosmetic elegance and the formulation work. The honest buying rule: if you want shine and manageability today, a well-made blend delivers. If you want a pre-wash treatment or you avoid silicones, buy pure. And read blend labels: when the featured oil appears after silicones and fragrance in the ingredient list, you are buying mostly silicone with a story. Neither choice is wrong, but know which one you are making.