NYX Cherry Skies Compared: Best Deep Wine Shades Ranked

By Emily Rodriguez Makeup Reviewer Published August 9, 2026

Two bold Liquid Suede shades are live on Amazon. Kitten Heels brings bright red energy. Alien brings dramatic black intensity. This comparison picks your bold.

The Stain Problem: Removing Bold Pigments Without Scrubbing

Nobody covers red lipstick removal and staining honestly, and it matters twice as much with these two shades. Red and black pigments in the Liquid Suede formula stain the lips and the surrounding skin, and the waterproof matte film that makes them last also makes them cling. Scrubbing with a foaming cleanser or peeling the dried film damages the lip surface and leaves flaking that ruins the next application.

The method that works is oil and patience. Saturate a cotton pad with an oil-based or dual-phase remover, press it against the lips for thirty seconds without rubbing, then wipe. The dwell time dissolves the film so the pigment lifts instead of tearing. For the residual stain both shades leave behind, especially Kitten Heels' red, which can tint lips pink into the next day, follow with a plain oil massaged in small circles. Do not chase the last trace of stain with repeated scrubbing; a faint tint fades on its own within a day and is not worth damaged lips. If you wear these shades regularly, an overnight healing balm after removal keeps the lip surface smooth for the next application. The matte vs satin lipstick comparison covers how other finishes compare on staining if you want a lower-maintenance option.

The Confidence Curve: Working Up to a Bold Lip

No guide addresses the confidence curve for first-time bold lip wearers, so here is the graduated plan nobody writes down. Do not start with Alien; start with Kitten Heels sheered out. Week one, apply Kitten Heels and immediately blot it down to a stain, or press it in with your fingertip instead of using the applicator. You get the red energy at half intensity and your eye adjusts to seeing yourself in color. Week two, wear it at full opacity for short outings, an evening, a dinner, where the bolder look feels natural. Week three, take it into daytime. Only then consider Alien, and treat it the same way: sheered first, then full.

The psychology is real and worth respecting. A bold lip changes how your whole face reads, and jumping straight to full-opacity black can make you feel costumed rather than confident. Each step up the curve should feel like a small stretch, not a leap. The finger-press technique is the training wheel: it gives you color without the crisp edge that makes bold shades feel severe. For building a red wardrobe beyond the first bold shade, our classic red lipstick guide walks through finding your everyday red once the confidence is there.

Eating, Drinking, and the Waterproof Claim

No competitor gives a real eating and drinking survival comparison across formulas, so here is the honest version for Liquid Suede. The waterproof matte film survives coffee, water, and light snacking well; the center of the lips fades first, usually around hour four or five, while the outer lip holds. Oily food is the real enemy. Anything fried, a salad with dressing, or oily takeout dissolves the film noticeably, because oil breaks down the same film formers that make it waterproof. One oily meal does more damage than six hours of talking.

The survival tactics are specific. Drink through a straw when you can; sipping from a mug fades the lower lip faster. Blot, do not wipe, after eating, then assess: if the center has faded but the edges hold, press a tiny amount of fresh product onto the bare center with your fingertip rather than reapplying a full coat, which pills over the old film. For all-day events, carry the tube; Liquid Suede does not layer cleanly over itself once it has fully set, so a full removal and reapplication beats a patchy touch-up. The MAC Powder Kiss guide covers a softer matte formula if you want bold color with easier reapplication.

One more gap no competitor fills: which liner pairs with which bold shade. Kitten Heels needs a true blue-red liner, not an orange-red one, or the edges will clash with the center. Alien needs a black liner, but a soft kohl rather than a liquid, so you can smudge the edge and avoid a harsh outline. Liner first, then the Liquid Suede over it; the liner grips the lip line and the liquid bonds to the liner, which extends wear at the edges where feathering starts.

More Top Picks in This Category

Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.

Best for: editorial blue lip looks

NYX Professional Makeup Liquid Suede Cream Lipstick, Jet-Set

Verified pick

• Jet-Set true blue shade
• Liquid Suede waterproof matte
• Bold editorial color

Pros

• Unique editorial blue
• Budget-friendly

Cons

• Niche blue shade
• Needs precise application

Check price

Check Price on Amazon

Want the Full Picture?