Beauty Maybelline Voyager Shades Compared: Find Your Perfect Match
You can buy Voyager as a single tube or in a two pack with Exhilarator. The formula is identical in both listings. Your choice comes down to shade variety and price per tube.
| Factor | Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink Liquid L | Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink Liquid L |
|---|---|---|
| Shades included | Voyager deep red only | Voyager deep red plus Exhilarator ruby red |
| Formula | Super Stay Matte Ink liquid | Super Stay Matte Ink liquid |
| Wear time | Up to 16 hours claimed | Up to 16 hours claimed |
| Applicator | Arrow tip doe foot | Arrow tip doe foot |
| Best for | Testing the shade first | Red lipstick lovers |
| Typical price | Check price | Check price |
| Value per tube | Standard | Lower per tube |
Our Verdict
Buy the single Voyager if you are trying the shade for the first time. Buy the two pack if you already love red lips and want Exhilarator too. The bundle cuts the per tube price, making it the smarter buy for regular wearers.
Single vs 2-Pack: The Super Stay Voyager Value Decision
The Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink in Voyager as a single tube versus the two-pack with Exhilarator is a straightforward value question with a hygiene catch. The two-pack's price per tube is lower, and the shade variety is genuinely useful: Voyager and Exhilarator are different enough to cover different moods. The catch is the expiration clock: liquid lipstick should be replaced twelve months after opening, and two open tubes double the waste risk. The disciplined approach is to open one tube, use it for months, then open the second; opening both at once to compare shades starts two countdowns.
For most buyers, the two-pack wins if you will wear both shades within the year, which is likely given how wearable both are. The single wins if you are shade-loyal to Voyager or trying the formula for the first time. One more consideration: Super Stay Matte Ink is a tenacious formula, and heavy users finish a tube in three to four months, which makes the two-pack's timeline comfortable. Light users who wear it weekly may not finish two tubes before expiration, in which case the single is the smarter buy.
Eating, Drinking, and Mask Survival: The Honest Wear Test
No guide gives a real eating and drinking survival comparison, so here is the honest Super Stay assessment. The Matte Ink formula is among the most tenacious drugstore liquids: it survives coffee cups with minimal transfer, handles light meals with only center fading, and resists mask transfer better than most. Oily food is the enemy: grease breaks down the film faster than any other meal type, so expect noticeable center wear after pizza or fried food. The fade pattern is the formula's strength: it wears down evenly rather than flaking or patching, which is why it remains the benchmark.
For maximum wear, the application ritual matters: exfoliate, apply a thin layer, let it set fully for two minutes without pressing lips together, then apply a second thin layer. The full set between layers is what builds the tenacious film; rushing it causes the layers to merge into one thick coat that cracks. For mask days, the transfer resistance is genuinely strong, but the inside of the mask still picks up some color by day's end; that is normal. Touch-ups should be thin: a thick touch-up layer over a worn base creates the cracking that the formula is famous for avoiding. Our SuperStay longevity comparison pits it against its sibling formula.
Removing Super Stay Without Wrecking Your Lips
Super Stay's legendary wear creates legendary removal difficulty, and the wrong removal ruins lips. The method: oil-based cleanser or balm, saturated pad pressed over the lips for thirty seconds, gentle wipe, repeat. The thirty-second press is non-negotiable with this formula; it needs the dwell time to soften. Never scrub, never peel: peeling Super Stay removes lip skin with the color and leaves lips raw and flaking for days. If two gentle passes do not remove it fully, a third press with fresh oil will; patience beats pressure.
For daily Super Stay wearers, the overnight balm step is mandatory: a thick occlusive layer every night prevents the cumulative dryness cycle. Exfoliate gently twice a week with a damp washcloth, and skip the formula on days when your lips are already chapped, since it will look cracked by noon on compromised lips. A useful rotation: Super Stay for long days, a creamy lipstick for short days, which gives lips recovery time. The formula's tenacity is a feature, not a flaw, but it demands respect in removal. For more on making long-wear color comfortable, our long-lasting lipstick guide covers the full routine.
A final note on the two-pack's second shade: Exhilarator is the bolder of the pair, so it suits evenings while Voyager handles daytime. Owning both means you rarely need another red, which is the quiet value of the bundle beyond the per-tube savings.
Store the unopened second tube in a cool drawer, and it will stay fresh until you are ready for it.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.