Beauty OGX vs Paul Mitchell: Purple Toning Drops Showdown Guide
OGX and Paul Mitchell make the two most popular purple toning drops on Amazon. Both promise to kill brassiness with a few drops per wash. But their pigment strength and mixing behavior differ. This comparison breaks down which one suits your hair and routine.
| Factor | OGX Impecca-Blonde Purple Toning Drops | Paul Mitchell Platinum Plus Violet Tonin |
|---|---|---|
| Best for | Weekly brass maintenance | Stubborn brass correction |
| Pigment strength | Medium | Strong |
| Mixability | Blends smoothly into shampoo | Blends smoothly into shampoo |
| Staining risk | Low at normal doses | Medium, wear gloves |
| Scent | Light tropical | Clean salon fresh |
| Bottle value | Good, lasts months | Premium, lasts months |
| Hair types | Fine to medium blonde | All blonde, silver, gray |
| Ease of use | Very forgiving dose | Needs careful dosing |
Our Verdict
Choose Paul Mitchell Platinum Plus for stubborn brass and salon-grade pigment strength. Choose OGX for gentle weekly maintenance at a friendlier price. Porous or platinum hair does better with the milder OGX formula. Resistant or very brassy hair needs the stronger Paul Mitchell drops. Either way, start with two drops and adjust from there.
Medium vs Strong Drops: Dosing by Brass Level
The OGX medium drops and the Paul Mitchell strong drops differ in pigment concentration, and the dosing must differ with them. The medium drops suit weekly maintenance on light brass: three to five drops mixed into your regular shampoo, lathered and left for two to three minutes. The forgiving dose means a drop too many will not turn the hair lavender. The strong drops suit stubborn brass correction: two to four drops for the same effect, with careful counting, because the higher concentration punishes overdosing with violet staining.
The brass-level rule: light, early brass gets the medium drops; entrenched, orange-leaning brass gets the strong drops. Starting with strong drops on light brass is the classic over-toning mistake, the hair goes lavender and needs clarifying to recover. Starting with medium drops on stubborn brass just wastes washes. Assess honestly: if the brass is visible in indoor lighting, it is stubborn; if it only shows in sunlight, it is light. Wear gloves with the strong drops, as the comparison warns, because the concentrated pigment stains hands and nails. Our toning drops complete guide details the mixing method for even results.
Drops vs Shampoo: The Format Decision
Toning drops solve a problem purple shampoo cannot: they turn any shampoo into a toning shampoo. That matters for three buyers. The sensitive-scalp buyer whose medicated or gentle shampoo has no purple version can add drops instead of switching formulas. The traveler who does not want a second bottle adds drops to the hotel shampoo. The budget buyer extends one regular shampoo into a dual-purpose product instead of buying a separate purple bottle.
Purple shampoo wins on consistency: the pigment is pre-measured, the formula is balanced, and the results are repeatable wash to wash. Drops win on flexibility but demand attention: uneven mixing gives patchy toning, with some sections over-toned and others untouched. The mixing technique decides: add the drops to the shampoo in your palm, mix thoroughly with a finger, then apply, rather than dropping directly onto the head. For porous hair that grabs pigment fast, drops offer finer control than shampoo, a single drop less makes a visible difference. Our toning drops hub ranks the top picks for every brass level.
Over-Toning Recovery: The Lavender Fix
Strong drops over-applied turn blonde lavender-gray, and the recovery is mechanical, not chemical. One clarifying wash removes most excess pigment; two restore the pre-toning brightness. Do not reach for bleach or color remover, which is massive overkill for deposited violet pigment that shampoo can lift.
The prevention protocol for strong drops: start with two drops, assess after drying, add one drop per subsequent wash until the tone holds. Hair must be assessed dry, because wet hair always looks darker and more toned than the dry result, and judging wet leads to systematic over-application. Keep a clarifying shampoo on hand as the drops user's safety net; the confidence to dose correctly comes from knowing the mistake is reversible. The medium drops rarely need this protocol, which is their quiet advantage for the nervous toner.
Weaning Off: Transitioning Away From Toning
Growing out color or returning to warm tones requires weaning off purple, and nobody describes the transition. The method: stretch the interval first, from weekly to every other week to monthly, rather than stopping abruptly. The tone warms gradually and controllably instead of swinging brassy overnight. During the transition weeks, the brass that returns is the hair's natural underlying warmth revealing itself, not damage, and it tells you what the grown-out color will actually look like.
If the goal is warm blonde rather than grown-out natural, stop the drops entirely once the desired warmth appears, then maintain with a regular color-safe shampoo. If brass returns too aggressively, the underlying level may need a salon gloss to establish the warm tone properly rather than fighting it with inconsistent toning. The drops format actually eases weaning: reducing by a drop per wash gives finer control than the binary on-off of purple shampoo. For mask-format toning as an alternative maintenance method, our purple toning mask guide covers the deeper weekly treatment option.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.