MAC Over The Taupe Compared: Which Nude Lipstick Wins Out

By Emily Rodriguez Makeup Reviewer Published December 20, 2025

We compare Over the Taupe against Brickthrough in the Powder Kiss Velvet Blur Slim Stick. Same formula, opposite temperatures. One is the cool trend shade, the other the warm safe pick. Our five-point comparison covers tone, wearability, and best undertone.

Undertone Testing Beyond the Wrist Vein

The wrist-vein trick is the beginning of undertone testing, not the end, and the full battery gives a more reliable answer for nude lipstick. The jewelry test: gold jewelry flattering suggests warm undertones, silver suggests cool, both suggesting neutral, and it works because metals interact with skin undertones visibly. The white fabric test: hold pure white fabric near your face in daylight, if your skin looks yellowish against it you lean warm, if pinkish you lean cool, if neither you are neutral. The foundation mapping test: your foundation shade's undertone, which you have already matched through wear, maps directly to lipstick undertones, so a warm-foundation wearer should start with warm nudes. The daylight test: evaluate all of these in natural daylight, because indoor lighting is warm and flatters everything, hiding the undertone truth. For the Over the Taupe versus Brickthrough choice, the undertone answer is decisive: cool and neutral undertones take the taupe greige, warm undertones take the brick rose, and getting this wrong is why nudes look off. The seasonal note: undertones can appear to shift slightly with tanning, so retest in summer if your winter nude stops working. No single test is definitive, but agreement across three tests is reliable. For more on shade matching, our MAC Blankety guide covers nude selection.

Rescuing a Wrong Nude: Layering Fixes That Work

A wrong nude does not have to be a wasted tube, because layering rescues most mismatches. Too light, the concealer-lips effect: layer a deeper liner underneath, fill the whole lip with a brown or berry liner, then apply the nude over it, which deepens the result while keeping the nude character. Alternatively, press a deeper gloss in the center, which adds dimension and distracts from the paleness. Too dark, the muddy effect: blot the nude down to a stain, then press a lighter gloss or balm over it, which sheers it out. Alternatively, mix the dark nude with a lighter one on the back of your hand before applying. Wrong undertone: a cool nude on warm skin, or warm on cool, can be corrected by layering the opposite-undertone gloss over it, which nudges the overall effect. For Over the Taupe specifically, the common rescue is warming it up: it runs cool, so warm-skinned buyers who bought it for the trend can layer a warm gloss over it to make it wearable. For Brickthrough, the rescue is usually deepening or lightening rather than undertone correction, since its warm brick tone suits most warm undertones already. The mixing method deserves more use: two wrong nudes mixed often make a right one. For more on getting nudes right the first time, our lipstick hub covers the selection process.

Why the Same Nude Looks Different on Everyone

The same nude tube produces different results on different people, and the three variables explain why. Natural lip pigmentation: the lipstick mixes with your lip color, so a taupe nude on naturally pink lips reads warmer than on naturally pale lips, and on deeply pigmented lips it may barely show. This is why swatches on other people mislead, their canvas differs from yours. Tooth color contrast: whiter teeth make nudes look brighter and more flattering by contrast, while yellower teeth can make the same nude look dull, which is why the teeth effect matters more for nudes than for bold colors. Skin depth and undertone: the identical nude is a different color relative to fair versus deep skin, reading as a natural lip on one and a statement on the other. For Over the Taupe, these variables explain the polarized reviews: on cool, fair skin with light lip pigmentation, it is the perfect greige nude, on warm or pigmented lips, it can look muddy or ashy. The practical implication: test nudes on your own lips in daylight, never buy based on arm swatches or other people's photos. The undertone testing from the previous section plus a lip swatch is the complete pre-purchase routine. It takes five minutes and prevents the most common nude lipstick disappointment. Most nude returns happen because the buyer skipped the lip swatch, not because the shade was unwearable. For more on how lip color interacts with your coloring, our Clinique Black Honey guide covers an adaptive shade.

More Top Picks in This Category

Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.

Want the Full Picture?