Beauty Redken Oil For All Compared: Which Redken Hair Oil Wins For
The Redken Naked Gloss Shine Hair Oil and the Redken All Soft Argan-6 Oil Treatment both target the same goal, but they take different routes to get there. We compared their formulas, ease of use and value to show where each one wins.
| Factor | Redken All Soft Argan-6 Oil Treatment | Redken Naked Gloss Shine Hair Oil |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Naked Gloss is the universal shine oil for all types. Shine first. | Argan-6 is the dry-hair moisture treatment. Repair first. |
| Best for | Everyone, especially mixed households. The safe universal pick. | Dry, rough hair needing deep softness. Targeted care. |
| Shine | 130 percent more shine, the highest claim here. Glass-like. | Healthy shine as a side effect of moisture. Softer glow. |
| Feel | Truly weightless on all hair types. Never heavy. | Melts in with no grease, but richer than Naked Gloss. |
| Value | Premium price for universal performance. Worth it. | Similar premium price. The original formula costs less. |
Our Verdict
Naked Gloss wins for most buyers because a truly universal weightless shine oil suits every head of hair. Choose All Soft Argan-6 if your hair is dry and needs moisture and strength more than pure shine.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.
Best for: Best for budget buyers who want the classic All Soft oil.
Redken All Soft Argan Oil (Original Formula)
- Original All Soft argan oil
- Argan oil moisture complex
- Softness and manageability
- Daily use on wet or dry hair
Pros
- Lower price than the reformulation
- Proven classic formula
Cons
- Older stock may vary
- Less heat protection than the new version
Fine Hair: Which Oil and How to Apply It
Moisturizing oil guides rarely explain how these formulas behave on fine or low-density hair, so fine-haired buyers either avoid oils entirely or drown their hair. Of the three here, Naked Gloss is the fine-hair pick, its weightless shine formula was built to disappear into the hair rather than sit on it. Use two to three drops on damp hair from the mid-lengths down, never at the roots, and you get the gloss without the collapse. The All Soft Argan-6 Oil Treatment is a different animal, it is richer and aimed at dry hair that needs real moisture and strength, so on fine hair it works only as an occasional ends-only treatment, not a daily oil.
The budget-friendly All Soft Argan Oil original formula sits between the two in weight, a workable everyday option for fine to medium hair when applied sparingly. Application technique matters as much as formula choice. Warm the oil between your palms first, which thins it and spreads it evenly, then smooth over the lengths rather than scrunching it in, scrunching drives oil toward the scalp. On dry hair, use half the damp-hair dose as a finisher for flyaways. Our thin dry hair guide covers the full volume-plus-moisture routine for this hair type.
Is Your Moisture Routine Actually Working?
No guide explains how to judge whether a moisturizing oil routine is working, so buyers switch products long before any formula had a fair chance. Give any new oil routine three weeks of consistent use before judging, hair needs several wash cycles to show whether moisture is building or just coating. Genuine improvement looks like supple ends, frizz that stays down past midday, and less breakage on the brush. The signs of over-moisturizing are equally clear and widely missed: hair that feels mushy when wet, stretches excessively, looks limp despite being clean, or takes noticeably longer to dry. That is hygral fatigue, the hair equivalent of waterlogged, and the fix is a clarifying wash followed by a break from heavy oils, not a different oil.
Under-moisturizing looks different: frizz returns within hours, ends feel rough again by evening, and static increases in dry air. If you see that with the All Soft Argan-6, the answer is usually application frequency or damp-hair application rather than a product swap. Change one variable at a time, dose or timing before product, so you learn what your hair responds to. A monthly clarifying wash belongs in every oil routine regardless, because even the lightest oils leave trace buildup that gradually dulls shine. For the broader repair picture beyond oils, our dry hair treatments guide covers masks, leave-ins, and the full hydration sequence.
Oil Treatment Versus Co-Wash for Very Dry Hair
Nobody compares moisturizing oil treatments against co-wash for very dry or coily hair, yet buyers constantly wonder whether a cleansing conditioner can replace shampoo entirely. The honest answer is that they solve different problems. Co-wash cleanses gently while depositing light moisture, which suits very dry or coily hair stripped by frequent shampooing. An oil treatment like the All Soft Argan-6 does not cleanse at all, it seals and nourishes but cannot replace washing, only complement it. The two can coexist: co-wash on most wash days, a proper shampoo weekly, and the oil treatment on damp hair after either.
Co-wash cannot fully replace shampoo under real buildup, silicones, sweat, and sebum accumulate, and co-wash lacks the surfactants to remove them. Signs you have pushed co-wash too far: itchy scalp, dull coated lengths, and curls that lose definition. A real shampoo reset followed by All Soft Argan-6 on damp hair then restores both at once. Fine hair should be cautious with co-wash generally, it over-moisturizes low-density hair fast, which is another reason Naked Gloss exists as the lightweight alternative. The Biolage HydraSource comparison shows a shampoo plus balm system tackling the same dryness from the wash step.