Beauty Too Faced Melted vs Plumping Cream: Which Lip Wins Today?
Too Faced Melted liquified lipstick in Melted Peony takes on the Lip Injection plumping cream here. One delivers bold matte color, the other plumping tint with tingle. Both bring the fun Too Faced energy. Here is how they compare.
| Factor | Too Faced Melted Liquified Long Wear Lip | Too Faced Lip Injection Power Plumping L |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Liquid lipstick with matte finish. | Plumping lip cream. |
| Color Payoff | Intense opaque pink. | Sheer to medium tint. |
| Finish | Velvety matte. | Creamy glossy. |
| Plumping | No plumping action. | Visible peptide plumping. |
| Feel | Normal liquid lipstick feel. | Noticeable tingle. |
| Wear Time | 5 to 7 hours. | 3 to 4 hours. |
| Price | 18 to 22 dollars. | 25 to 30 dollars. |
Our Verdict
Too Faced Melted liquified lipstick wins for intense matte color that lasts for hours. Melted Peony delivers the bold payoff the line is famous for. The Lip Injection plumping cream wins for those prioritizing fuller-looking lips with comfortable tint. They serve different needs, so the real winner is your goal: color drama or plumping comfort. Given Melted scarcity, secure your shade soon.
Thin Lips: Plumping Cream vs Matte Finish
This page is the perfect thin-lip laboratory: one product plumps, the other mattifies, and the visual difference is immediate. The Lip Injection's peptide plumping with its noticeable tingle increases blood flow to create visible fullness, and the creamy glossy finish reflects light, which amplifies the plumping optically. The Melted Matte's velvety matte absorbs light, defining the lip shape crisply but making thin lips look smaller by contrast.
The thin-lip strategy depends on the occasion. For maximum fullness, the plumping cream alone, possibly with a touch of the Melted Peony dabbed in the center for color depth. For bold matte color on thin lips, counteract the flattening: apply the matte, then press a tiny amount of the plumping cream or any gloss into the center of the lower lip. The glossy center creates dimension that the matte alone cannot. Never overline matte on thin lips; the flat finish exposes the overline as an obvious edge, while gloss forgives it. Our Melted Matte application guide covers technique for getting the bold color right.
The Tingle Question: Sensitivity and Plumpers
Plumping tingle is irritation by design: the peptides and warming agents irritate the lips just enough to swell them. Most users feel a noticeable tingle that fades within minutes; sensitive users feel burning that lingers. The sensitivity screen: if your lips react to menthol, cinnamon, or spicy foods, patch-test the plumping cream on the outer lip corner first and wait ten minutes. Persistent burning, swelling beyond the lip line, or small bumps mean the formula is not for you.
Matte formulas carry their own sensitivity flags that nobody lists: fragrance, which many liquid mattes include, and the drying alcohols in some long-wear bases. If your lips chap cyclically with matte use, the formula's fragrance or base may be the trigger rather than the matte finish itself. The Lip Injection's tingle plus any lip sensitivity is a combination to approach cautiously: do not layer the plumper over freshly exfoliated or cracked lips, where the irritants penetrate deeper and the reaction intensifies.
Dry Lips: Which Too Faced Pick Survives
Dry lips split this pair decisively. The Melted Matte's five to seven hour wear assumes reasonably smooth lips; on flaky lips, the velvety matte catches on every flake within the first hour and the look deteriorates. The Lip Injection's creamy base cushions dry lips far better, and its three to four hour wear is honest about needing reapplication rather than pretending to a full day.
The dry-lip protocol for the matte: exfoliate gently, balm for ten minutes, blot thoroughly, then apply in thin coats. For the plumping cream: apply directly, no prep needed, and reapply freely since the formula is forgiving. Buyers with chronically dry lips who love the Melted Peony shade should consider it a special-occasion product rather than a daily driver, while the plumping cream can be the everyday pick. Neither contains SPF, so dedicated lip sunscreen handles sun days for both.
Cost Per Wear and the Two-Product Routine
At eighteen to twenty-two dollars for the matte and twenty-five to thirty for the plumping cream, the pair represents a complete lip system for around fifty dollars. The per-wear math favors the plumping cream for daily use: its forgiving formula and easy reapplication mean it actually gets used, while a matte that demands prep often sits unused. A product's cost per wear is infinite if it stays in the drawer.
The smartest routine uses both as intended: the plumping cream for daytime fullness and comfort, the Melted Matte for evenings when bold opaque color matters. The balm balance applies to the matte: thin balm base, full blot, then color. The plumping cream needs no base at all. Together they cover the full week, which is the real value proposition beyond either product alone. Our best lip products roundup compares more color-that-lasts options across the category.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.