Beauty Revlon 008 Show Off vs ColorStay Suede Ink: Which 008 Wins?
Revlon 008 appears in two formulas: Luscious Mattes Show Off and ColorStay Suede Ink That Girl. One is a comfortable matte bullet, the other is a waterproof long wear stick. We compared them to find the best 008.
| Factor | Revlon Super Lustrous The Luscious Matte | Revlon Lipstick, ColorStay Suede Ink, Bu |
|---|---|---|
| Price point | Check price | Check price |
| Formula | Luscious Mattes bullet | ColorStay Suede Ink stick |
| Shade | 008 Show Off | 008 That Girl |
| Wear time | 4 to 6 hours | Up to 8 hours, waterproof |
| Finish | Velvety matte | Suede matte |
| Best for | Comfort, easy reapply | Long days, events |
Our Verdict
Pick Luscious Mattes Show Off for a comfortable classic matte bullet. Pick ColorStay Suede Ink That Girl for waterproof, all day wear that survives meals.
Comfortable Matte Versus Waterproof Matte: The Real Tradeoff
Nobody compares matte lipsticks for dry versus normal lips with real wear expectations, and this pairing makes the tradeoff concrete. The Luscious Mattes bullet is a comfortable matte: it wears four to six hours, feels good doing it, and fades gracefully. The ColorStay Suede Ink is a waterproof long-wear stick: it holds up to eight hours and resists water, but the film that delivers that wear is drier and less forgiving. On normal lips, the choice is lifestyle, comfort for office days, armor for long ones. On dry lips, the comfortable matte wins outright, since the waterproof film grabs dry patches and emphasizes texture within hours.
The wear-time gap also changes the touch-up math. The comfortable matte needs one touch-up after lunch and re-layers cleanly over itself. The waterproof stick needs no touch-up for most of the day but re-layers poorly, fresh waterproof film over partially worn film pills and flakes. So the "longer wear" formula actually demands more planning: get the application right in the morning, because fixing it later is harder. For the prep routine that makes either formula wearable, the lip repair guide covers the overnight steps that matter most.
Removing Waterproof Matte Without Damage
No competitor compares removal difficulty per formula, and waterproof matte is near the top of the difficulty ranking. The method that works: saturate a cotton pad with an oil-based remover, press it over the lips for a full thirty seconds, then wipe gently in one direction. The dwell time dissolves the waterproof film so it releases instead of being scrubbed off. Micellar water needs several passes on waterproof formulas. Makeup wipes alone are the worst option, demanding the scrubbing that leaves lips raw.
What not to do: peel the dried film off with your fingers, which pulls up lip skin with it, or follow removal with an exfoliating scrub the same night, which rawens already-stressed lips. After removing the waterproof stick, apply a plain balm immediately, since the removal strips the lip barrier thoroughly. The comfortable matte, by contrast, removes with a single gentle cleanse, which is a genuine daily-wear advantage the wear-time numbers do not capture. If you wear the waterproof formula daily, an overnight lip mask twice a week keeps lips resilient. The long-lasting lipstick guide ranks removal across more matte formulas.
Cost Per Wear: Comfort Versus Armor
Nobody compares cost per wear across matte lipsticks, so here is the math. The comfortable matte, worn daily with one touch-up, lasts roughly two to three months per bullet, working out to around ten to fifteen cents per day. The waterproof stick lasts longer per application, needing no touch-up, and the bullet lasts three to four months, working out to a similar or slightly lower daily cost for all-day wearers. The value flips for light wearers: someone who wears lipstick three days a week finishes neither bullet before the twelve to eighteen month expiry, so the cheaper bullet wastes less.
The hidden cost is lip care. The waterproof formula's aggressive removal and drier film increase the need for lip masks and balms, which narrows the price gap in practice. The comfortable matte's gentle removal keeps lip-care costs near zero. Factor your routine honestly: if you already own the balms and masks, the waterproof stick's per-day cost holds. If you would be buying lip care specifically to survive the waterproof formula, the comfortable matte is the cheaper total package.
The Center-Fade Fix for Both Formulas
The inner-rim fade hits both formulas, and the fixes differ. For the comfortable matte, the double-center technique works: blot after the first coat, then apply a second thin coat concentrated on the center of the lips. It re-layers cleanly, so touch-ups after meals just need a blot first. For the waterproof stick, prevention beats correction: get the morning application right with thin, even coats, because re-layering waterproof film over worn film pills. At touch-up time, blot thoroughly and apply one thin coat only to the faded center, never the whole lip.
Revlon 008 Formula Questions
The Luscious Mattes bullet, comfortably. Its emollient base does not grab dry patches the way the waterproof film does. If you love long wear but have dry lips, the overnight prep routine matters more than any morning balm.
Better than the comfortable matte, but not immune. Oil breaks down even waterproof films, so expect fading at the inner rim after oily meals. Blot and touch up the center rather than reapplying the whole lip.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.