Beauty Maybelline 80 Ruler Lip Color Comparison: Top Options Here
The two verified Maybelline SuperStay products below serve the same long-wear brief in different formats. The Ink Crayon offers precision and comfort; the Matte Ink 2-pack offers maximum intensity and marathon wear at a value price. Neither is the exact 80 Ruler shade, which is not currently indexed on Amazon; both are genuine SuperStay products.
| Factor | Maybelline SuperStay Ink Crayon Lipstick | Maybelline SuperStay Matte Ink Liquid Li |
|---|---|---|
| Product | SuperStay Ink Crayon | SuperStay Matte Ink, Loyalist 2-pack |
| Format | Twist-up crayon | Liquid lipstick |
| Finish | Creamy long-wear | True matte |
| Wear time | 5 to 8 hours | Up to 16 hours claimed |
| Application ease | Very easy, no mirror needed | Needs care, sets fast |
| Comfort | Creamy, flexible | Drier matte film |
| Removal | Standard remover | Needs oil-based remover |
| Pack value | Check price | 2-pack value |
| Best for | Daily long-wear, beginners | Events, marathon days |
| Overall winner | Best everyday long-wear | Best maximum wear |
Our Verdict
For most shoppers, the Ink Crayon is the smarter buy: at around four dollars it delivers genuine long wear with crayon ease and comfort, and it is the friendlier introduction to the SuperStay family. The Matte Ink 2-pack is the choice when staying power is non-negotiable, for weddings, long workdays, and events where touch-ups are impossible, and the two-pack pricing rewards commitment to the liquid formula. The honest framing holds: these are verified SuperStay products matching the long-wear bold-color brief, not the exact Ruler shade, and either one shows what the line does best.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.
Want the Full Picture?
Matte Lipstick on Dry vs Normal Lips: The Comfort Split
Matte lipstick comfort reviews are meaningless without splitting by lip condition, because the same formula behaves like two different products. On normal, hydrated lips, modern matte formulas like the Maybelline shades compared here wear comfortably for six to eight hours, with the tight feeling arriving only at the very end of wear. On chronically dry lips, the same formula feels tight within two hours, emphasizes every flake, and cracks at the inner lip by afternoon. The formula did not change; the canvas did.
The dry-lip adaptation has three parts. First, prep the night before with gentle exfoliation and a heavy balm, not the morning of, when exfoliation leaves lips raw. Second, apply a thin balm layer, wait three minutes, then blot firmly before the matte goes on; the blotting leaves hydration in the lip while removing the surface slip that breaks down matte. Third, choose the application thickness by lip condition: one thin layer for dry lips, since thin layers crack less, versus the standard application for normal lips.
The reapplication rule differs too. Normal lips can layer fresh matte over faded matte once with acceptable results. Dry lips cannot; the second layer over dry remains cakes immediately. Dry-lip wearers should blot clean and reapply fresh, or better, carry a tinted balm for afternoon refresh instead of more matte. Knowing your lip type and adapting accordingly matters more than the formula choice. Our Aquaphor lip repair guide covers healing dry lips back to a matte-ready state.
Fixing the Inner-Rim Center Fade
The center of the lips fades first on every matte lipstick because saliva, talking, and eating attack the inner rim constantly. The per-formula fixes differ. For liquid mattes like Super Stay Matte Ink, the fix is the blot-and-single-layer method: apply one thin layer, blot after sixty seconds, and do not add a second coat, since the blotted single layer bonds better than two coats. For bullet mattes, the fix is the liner base: fill the entire lip with a matching liner first, which gives the fading center something to fade into rather than bare lip.
What never works is reapplying over the faded center without blotting first. Fresh matte over patchy remains creates the textured, cakey ring that looks worse than the fade did. The correct touch-up sequence: blot the whole lip firmly with a tissue, removing the faded center and evening the remains, then apply one fresh thin layer over everything. This takes thirty seconds and restores a near-fresh application.
The eating strategy for matte wearers: choose foods wisely when the color matters. Oily foods dissolve matte fastest; dry foods and drinking through a straw preserve it. For important evenings, plan the touch-up for after the meal rather than fighting the fade during it. And accept that no matte survives a greasy meal intact; the goal is graceful fading, not invincibility. The long-lasting lipstick guide compares fade patterns across formulas.
Removing Long-Wear Matte Without Scrubbing Lips Raw
Long-wear mattes rank among the hardest lip products to remove, and the scrubbing people resort to causes the next-day dryness they blame on the formula. The removal ranking by difficulty: standard bullet mattes come off with micellar water; soft-matte liquids need an oil-based remover; true long-wear liquids like Super Stay need the full oil treatment, a generous amount of cleansing oil or dedicated lip remover massaged for a full thirty seconds before wiping.
The technique that protects lips: saturate, wait, then wipe softly. Apply the remover, let it sit and dissolve the film rather than scrubbing immediately, then remove with a soft damp cloth in gentle strokes. The waiting does the work; the wiping should be nearly pressure-free. Follow immediately with a hydrating balm, since even gentle removal strips some moisture.
The overnight mistake to avoid is sleeping in long-wear matte because removal felt like too much effort. Overnight wear dehydrates the lips severely and the pigment migrates into lip lines, staining them. The two-minute removal routine is always worth it. For the gentlest daily option, micellar water on a cotton pad handles non-long-wear mattes without any oil. Our best long-lasting lipsticks review notes removal difficulty per formula.