Beauty Rimmel Maybelline Lash Sensational: Top Two Compared Here
The Sky High 2-Count Bundle and the Sky High plus Lash Primer Bundle are two popular value picks. One doubles your mascara, the other boosts it with primer. Here is how they compare.
| Factor | Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mas | Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High plu |
|---|---|---|
| Contents | 2 mascaras | Mascara plus primer |
| Main benefit | Long supply | Extra volume |
| Shades | Blackest Black, Cosmic Black | Sky High black |
| Value | Lowest per tube | Complete routine |
| Best for | Mascara loyalists | Fine lash owners |
| Gift appeal | High | Very high |
Our Verdict
The 2-count bundle wins for pure mascara value. It keeps you stocked for 6 months. The primer bundle wins for performance. Primer transforms fine lashes before mascara. Pick the 2-count if you love Sky High already. Pick the primer bundle to upgrade your whole lash routine.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.
Best for: Short, sparse lashes needing a boost.
Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High plus Boosting Lash Primer Bundle
- Sky High Mascara in Blackest Black
- Amplifying Lash Primer in Soft Black
- Primer lengthens, thickens, darkens
- Ceramide and Vitamin B5 serum base
Pros
- Primer boosts mascara performance
- Lashes feel softer after 4 weeks
- Tinted primer works alone too
Cons
- Two-step routine takes longer
- Primer adds to the cost
- Soft black primer is subtle
Best for: Going-out lashes without extensions.
Maybelline Lash Sensational Firework Washable Mascara, Very Black
- Firework 360-degree lash impact
- SuperSpark spiral brush
- Pro-Vitamin B5 conditioning
- Up to 24-hour wear, smudge resistant
Pros
- Dramatic flare without falsies
- Conditioning formula feels soft
- Great value for the effect
Cons
- Bold for minimal makeup days
- Spiral brush has a learning curve
- Washable version can smudge
Best for: Natural waterproof wear for lighter coloring.
Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Waterproof Mascara, Brownish Black
- Waterproof brownish black shade
- Flex Tower brush, bamboo extract
- Full volume, limitless length
- Suitable for sensitive eyes
Pros
- Softer waterproof option
- Great for natural waterproof looks
- Holds curl in humidity
Cons
- Brownish tone not for dramatic looks
- Waterproof removal effort
- Fewer reviews than core shades
Want the Full Picture?
The Waterproof Decision: Pool, Gym, Tears, Humidity
Waterproof is not an all-or-nothing choice, and the scenario decides. For swimming, only true waterproof survives, and the Sky High Waterproof in Brownish Black compared on this page is the pool-safe pick of the group. For gym sessions, both waterproof and tubing formulas work, since the enemy is sweat rather than submersion. For emotional days, waterproof is the only safe bet. For humid commutes and oily lids, the answer is less obvious: waterproof resists moisture, but tubing resists the oil transfer that humidity accelerates, so either can work depending on your bigger problem.
The daily-office scenario is where waterproof is usually the wrong call. Waterproof formulas require oil-based or dual-phase removers and more rubbing, which costs lashes over time. If your day involves no water exposure, a washable formula like the Lash Sensational Firework gives you the length with a gentler exit. Reserve waterproof for the days that need it. If you want to understand the full waterproof versus water-resistant versus tubing landscape, our tubing mascara guide explains where each formula wins and where each fails.
Removing Waterproof Formulas Without Lash Fallout
Waterproof mascara removal is where most lash damage happens, and the technique matters more than the product. The method: soak a cotton pad in dual-phase remover, hold it against the closed eye for a full minute, and let the formula dissolve. Then sweep downward once. Repeat if needed, but never scrub back and forth. The holding time is the entire secret, because waterproof polymers need solvent contact time to release their grip on the lash.
Micellar water alone usually cannot cut waterproof formulas, which is why people end up scrubbing and losing lashes. An oil-based balm or dedicated eye makeup remover is the correct tool. After cleansing, run a clean spoolie through the lashes: if you feel stiffness or see clumps, residue remains and needs a second gentle pass. Leaving waterproof residue overnight makes lashes brittle, and brittle lashes snap the next morning during application. For a complete ranking of removal methods by gentleness, our makeup removal guide covers every approach without the damage.
Oily Lids: Which Formula Transfers Least
Oily eyelids dissolve mascara from the outside in. The skin's natural oils migrate onto the lashes over the day and soften whatever film the mascara formed, which is why even the Sky High Waterproof can leave a soft smudge on very oily lids by evening. Waterproof resists water, not oil, and that distinction is the source of most disappointment. The formulas that actually resist oil transfer are tubing mascaras, whose polymer sleeves grip the lash shaft mechanically rather than relying on a wax film that oil can dissolve.
Before switching formulas, try the oil-control steps. Prime the lid with a mattifying eyeshadow primer, set it with translucent powder, and keep morning skincare away from the lash line. If smudging continues, the realistic ranking for oily lids is tubing first, waterproof second, washable last. When comparing lengthening formulas like the ones on this page, our waterproof vs washable comparison breaks down which finish suits which lid type and lifestyle.