Beauty Falsies Mascara Compared: Lash Lift vs Volume Formulas Guide
We compared Falsies Lash Lift against Falsies Volum Express across lift, volume, wear, and price. One curls and the other builds drama. Here is which falsies formula matches your lash goals.
| Factor | Maybelline Falsies Lash Lift Mascara, Wa | Maybelline Falsies Lash Lift Mascara, Wa |
|---|---|---|
| Lash lift/curl | Excellent curled effect | Moderate curl |
| Volume | Good natural volume | Bold dramatic volume |
| Length | Strong lengthening | Good lengthening |
| Wear time | All day, minimal flaking | All day, minimal flaking |
| Waterproof option | Available | Available |
| Price | Eight to twelve dollars | Six to ten dollars |
Our Verdict
Lash Lift wins for shoppers who want curled, lengthened lashes that look like a lash lift. Volum Express wins for maximum bold drama. Choose Lash Lift for everyday polish and Volum Express for night-out intensity.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.
Best for: Maximum bold volume on a budget.
Maybelline Volum Express Falsies Mascara
- Original Falsies volume formula
- Spoon brush builds bold volume
- False-lash drama effect
- Ultra-affordable price
Pros
- Huge volume for the price
- Iconic formula for a reason
- Great for night looks
Cons
- Can clump if overapplied
- Less length than Lash Lift
Best for: Winged, fanned-out lash looks cheaply.
Maybelline Falsies Push Up Angel Mascara
- Push-up brush for winged lashes
- Lifts outer corners for angel effect
- Lengthening and defining formula
- Lowest price of the family
Pros
- Beautiful fanned-out look
- Cheapest Falsies option
- Good everyday drama
Cons
- Brush takes practice
- Less volume than original
Best for: Waterproof volume for active days.
Maybelline Falsies Waterproof Mascara
- Waterproof false-lash volume
- Holds through water and sweat
- Classic Falsies brush
- Reliable all-day wear
Pros
- Stays put in tough conditions
- Good volume payoff
- Trusted waterproof formula
Cons
- Tough removal
- Can dry lashes with daily use
Falsies vs Push Up Angel: Which False Lash Effect
Maybelline Volum Express Falsies and Falsies Push Up Angel both promise the false lash look, but they build it differently. The original Falsies uses a spoon shaped brush that loads volume at the base and fans outward, creating the full, fluffy false lash effect. The Push Up Angel uses a winged brush designed to push lashes up and outward, creating lift and separation with a more defined, eye opening effect. The choice maps to lash type: short, straight lashes benefit more from the Push Up Angel's lift, while sparse lashes benefit more from the original's volumizing fullness. Both are traditional washable formulas, which means dramatic volume with easy removal, but also means they need the oily lid prep system for long or humid days. The clumping risk is real with both, and the prevention is the same: wipe the wand once before applying, work in thin coats, and let the first coat dry a full minute before the second. The false lash comparison has a limit worth stating: no mascara replicates actual false lashes, and expecting it leads to over application and the spidery look. Two thin coats is the maximum for either formula; beyond that, lashes clump rather than build. For buyers who want this volume in a waterproof format, our BADgal BANG buyer guide covers the heavy duty alternative.
Mascara Over Lash Lifts and Tints
Lash lifts and tints change the mascara equation, and the guidance is nearly absent. The good news first: mascara is safe over a lash lift once the initial setting period passes, typically 24 to 48 hours, and it actually extends the visible life of the lift as it grows out. The formula choice matters: tubing mascaras are the safest pairing, since they remove with water alone and the oil based removers needed for waterproof formulas degrade the lift faster. Traditional washable formulas sit in the middle, fine with gentle removal. Avoid waterproof mascara on a fresh lift entirely; the removal stress undoes the lift's longevity and can pull on the treated lashes. Application technique shifts too: the lift already provides the curl, so focus mascara on length and definition rather than piling on volume at the base, which can overwhelm the lifted shape. A lash tint plus a brown or black brown mascara is often enough for daily definition, since the tint darkens what the lift curls. Do not use heated lash curlers on lifted lashes; the lift is the curl, and additional heat stresses the treated hair. As the lift grows out over six to eight weeks, mascara becomes more important for blending the grown out sections. For sensitive eyes considering lifts, our Clinique Rimel guide covers gentle formulas that suit reactive eyes.
Contact Lens Wearers: The Particle Problem
Contact lens wearers with dry eyes face a specific mascara problem that generic sensitive eye advice misses: particles under the lens. Traditional volumizing mascaras with fibers shed microscopic particles through the day, and those particles migrate onto the lens surface, causing irritation, blurriness, and the urge to remove the lens. Tubing mascaras are the clear winner here, since the polymer tubes do not shed fibers and come off in pieces rather than particles. If you wear a traditional formula, the rules are strict: never apply mascara to the very base of the lashes where particles shed directly onto the eye, avoid fiber containing formulas entirely, and replace the tube on schedule, since old mascara sheds more. Waterproof formulas are a mixed bag for lens wearers: they resist the tearing that dry eyes produce, but their removal requires rubbing near the lens. Insertion order matters: put lenses in before makeup, so particles land on the lens rather than getting trapped underneath, and remove lenses before makeup removal at night. If eyes are red or irritated by evening consistently, the mascara is a prime suspect even when the lenses are new. Daily disposable lenses plus a tubing mascara is the lowest irritation combination. For the gentlest traditional formulas, our Clinique Rimel guide is formulated with sensitive eyes in mind.