Beauty Volumizing Mascara Showdown: The Best Volume Compared Here
We compare the classic Lash Blast against the waterproof version to help you choose. Both deliver the same iconic volume, so the decision comes down to your lifestyle and how much water resistance you need.
| Factor | CoverGirl Lash Blast Volume Mascara, 5-P | CoverGirl Lash Blast Volume Waterproof M |
|---|---|---|
| Formula | Classic volumizing | Waterproof volumizing |
| Volume | 10x instant volume | 10x instant volume |
| Best for | Everyday bold lashes | Events, humidity, tears |
| Removal | Warm water and cleanser | Oil-based remover needed |
| Comfort | Lightweight, flexible | Slightly drier feel |
| Clumping | Minimal with good technique | Minimal with good technique |
| Price | Check price | Check price |
| Size | 5 x 0.44 fl oz | 0.44 fl oz |
Our Verdict
Choose the classic if you want everyday bold volume with easy removal and the most comfortable wear, especially if you remove makeup nightly without special removers. Choose the waterproof if your lifestyle demands it: weddings, workouts, watery eyes, humid climates, or emotional days. The volume is identical, so let water resistance decide. Many lash lovers keep both, classic for daily life and waterproof for occasions, since the five-pack makes stocking up affordable.
Oily Lids and Volume Formulas: The Honest Picture
Volume mascaras like CoverGirl Lash Blast are the worst offenders for smudging on oily lids, and the reason is structural. Volume formulas lay down more product per lash, more pigment, more wax, more fiber, which means more material for migrating skin oil to soften. A lengthening formula puts down a thin coat that dries fast; a volume formula puts down a thick coat that stays slightly pliable for longer, and pliable plus oil equals transfer. If your lids are oily by midday, the standard Lash Blast will likely stamp itself under your lower lashes and onto the brow bone by late afternoon, especially on hooded eyes where the lashes touch skin.
The waterproof version changes this equation meaningfully. Its film formers resist oil softening far better than the standard formula's waxes do, which is why oily-lidded buyers often find the waterproof version smudge-proof while the washable version fails. That does not make waterproof the automatic winner; it makes it the situational winner for oily skin. The supporting routine still helps: translucent powder along the lower lash line, primer on the lid, and no mascara on lower lashes. Test both versions on the same kind of day before deciding, because lid oiliness varies enormously person to person, and some buyers get all-day wear from the standard formula with just the powder trick. Our volumizing mascara guide breaks down which volume formulas resist oil best across brands.
Waterproof vs Washable: The Real Trade
The choice between Lash Blast Volume and Lash Blast Volume Waterproof is the purest form of the waterproof question, because everything else about the two formulas is nearly identical. Waterproof wins on hold: swimming, sweating, crying, humid commutes, oily lids. Washable wins on removal: micellar water and thirty seconds versus oil cleanser and a full minute of soaking. What buyers underestimate is that the removal difference is a daily cost while the hold difference only matters on some days. Wearing waterproof every day for a desk job means paying the removal toll 365 days a year for hold you needed maybe twenty of them.
The lash-loss math is what should decide. Every waterproof removal involves more contact time and more wiping than a washable removal, and over months that mechanical stress thins the lash line. If you wear mascara daily, the washable version with a good routine is the lash-health choice, reserving waterproof for the days with actual water exposure. If you wear mascara occasionally, the daily-cost argument weakens and waterproof becomes more reasonable as your one tube. Neither choice is wrong; the wrong move is defaulting to waterproof out of habit without weighing how often you actually need it. Our makeup removal guide details the soak-first method that minimizes damage whichever version you choose.
Removal Ranked by Lash-Loss Risk
Not all removal methods cost the same in lashes. Gentlest is warm water plus gentle pressure for tubing formulas, which is irrelevant here but sets the baseline. Next is micellar water or dual-phase remover with a proper soak: press, hold twenty to thirty seconds, wipe downward once. This handles the washable Lash Blast with minimal stress. Harsher is oil cleanser massaged directly onto dry lashes, which dissolves waterproof formulas effectively but involves more manipulation. Harshest is the quick scrub: dry cotton or a makeup wipe rubbed back and forth over waterproof mascara with no soak time, which is the number-one cause of lash breakage in daily mascara wearers.
The warning signs of a too-harsh routine are unmistakable: lashes visible on the cotton pad nightly, a sparser outer corner on one eye, or lashes that look stubby compared to a few months ago. The fix is always more soak time and less pressure, never a stronger product. For the waterproof version specifically, hold the soaked pad against the closed eye for a full thirty seconds before the first wipe; most buyers wipe after five seconds, which is why they end up scrubbing. Patience at the sink is the cheapest lash serum there is.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.