Beauty BADgal BANG Waterproof vs Wild Plum: Full Shade Showdown
BADgal BANG comes in a tough Waterproof formula and a playful Wild Plum shade. Waterproof promises all day staying power. Wild Plum offers the classic formula with a twist. Here is the full shade showdown.
| Factor | Benefit BADgal BANG Waterproof Mascara | Benefit BADgal BANG Wild Plum Mascara |
|---|---|---|
| Formula base | Waterproof volumizing | Classic volumizing |
| Shade | Intense black | Deep plum |
| Wear time | All day, resists water | Long wear, not waterproof |
| Volume level | Big bold volume | Big bold volume |
| Removal ease | Needs oil based remover | Removes with cleanser |
| Price range | Check price | Check price |
| Best for | Humid days and events | Everyday fun color |
Our Verdict
Pick Waterproof for maximum staying power through sweat and tears. Pick Wild Plum for the classic BANG experience with playful color. Both deliver the famous big volume. Your lifestyle decides which formula fits better.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.
Best for: Travelers and first time BANG triers.
Benefit BADgal BANG Mini Black
- Travel size mini tube
- Same volumizing formula
- Perfect for trial
- TSA friendly
Pros
- Try before committing
- Great for travel
- Less waste
Cons
- Higher cost per ml
- Runs out fast with daily use
Best for: Blue mascara fans and brown eyed beauties.
Benefit BADgal BANG Brightening Blue
- Eye brightening blue shade
- Volumizing BANG formula
- Makes eyes look whiter
- Washable formula
Pros
- Stunning on brown eyes
- Fun pop of color
- Same volume power
Cons
- Bold for everyday
- Blue fades to navy
Best for: Devotees wanting the full size original icon.
Benefit BADgal BANG Volumizing Mascara
- Original full size formula
- Maximum volume brush
- Rich black pigment
- Cult classic status
Pros
- The iconic original
- Huge dramatic volume
- Lasts months
Cons
- Premium price
- Big brush learning curve
Waterproof vs Wild Plum: The Real Decision
The Waterproof and the Wild Plum are not just different shades, they are different technologies, and the decision matrix makes it concrete. The Waterproof is the endurance formula, surviving swimming, tears, sweat, and humidity, with the removal price to match, it needs the full oil-based press-and-dissolve routine. The Wild Plum is the classic washable formula in a playful shade, coming off with regular cleanser and treating lashes gently. The scenario guide, choose Waterproof for weddings, beach days, emotional events, and workouts, choose Wild Plum, or the classic black, for everyday wear where gentle removal preserves lashes. The common mistake, defaulting to Waterproof for everything, which costs lashes at removal over months, when most days do not need it. The rotation most long-term users land on, washable most days, waterproof for the days that earn it. Shade is the secondary decision, the plum is the fun variable once the formula choice is made. Decide by your day's demands first, the color second. Our BADgal BANG application guide covers bold maximum volume technique.
Blue and Plum Mascara: Who Should Try Color
Colored mascara beyond black gets minimal serious coverage, but the Brightening Blue and Wild Plum deserve real guidance. Who colored mascara flatters, blue mascara makes the whites of the eyes look whiter and brightens blue eyes through harmony, while plum flatters green and hazel eyes spectacularly, the purple tones contrast the green. Fair skin, blondes, and redheads, where black can look harsh, often find colored mascaras more flattering for daytime than expected. How to wear it without looking costume, keep the rest of the eye makeup minimal, one bold element per eye, and apply the color to the upper lashes only, with black or brown on the lower lashes for grounding. The Wild Plum is the easier entry point, since plum reads as a soft black in most lighting, while the blue is the statement, unmistakable and fun. For the office, the plum passes as interesting black, the blue does not, choose accordingly. Color is a tool, not a dare, when placed with restraint.
Removing BADgal: Waterproof vs Washable Methods
The two formulas need completely different removal, and the method protects the lash line. Waterproof BADgal, saturate a pad with oil-based remover, press over closed eyes for a full 30 seconds, then wipe downward gently, letting the dissolver do the work, never scrubbing. Washable BADgal, including the Wild Plum and blue, comes off with warm water and regular cleanser or micellar water, dramatically gentler. Ranked by lash impact, the washable removal is the kindest daily routine, while waterproof removal, done correctly, is acceptable occasionally but costly as a habit. Never pick dried waterproof off with fingers, never sleep in it, and never use the same aggressive removal on the waterline as the lid. For daily waterproof wearers, alternating with the washable formula some days and using a nighttime lash serum supports the follicles through the routine. The mini tube here is worth noting for removal too, a fresh mini means a fresh formula, and old mascara is harder to remove and flakes more. Removal is half the mascara, treat it as carefully as application.
Mini Tubes and Mascara Hygiene
The BADgal mini is not just a travel convenience, it is a hygiene advantage that deserves explicit mention. The three-month replacement rule starts at opening, and full-size mascaras often get stretched past it, while a mini runs out in about a month of regular use, which means the formula is always fresh. Never pump the wand, the in-and-out motion forces air in, drying the formula and introducing bacteria, swirl once instead. Do not share mascara under any circumstances, eye infections transfer through shared wands efficiently. Watch for the contamination signals, sudden smell change, unusual clumping, or eye irritation after application, all mean immediate disposal regardless of age. Never add water or saline to revive a drying mascara, which creates bacteria soup. The mini format also suits the shade experimenter, trying Wild Plum or blue without committing to a full tube that might expire before it is finished. Fresh, small, and replaced often is the hygienic ideal, and the mini delivers it naturally. For the full ranking, see our best BADgal BANG picks compared.