Both Toasting Glasses picks share the same beloved warm rosy shade. The lipstick brings classic creamy pigment, the balm brings sheer comfortable shine. Format is the decision.
Factor
Revlon Super Lustrous Lipstick, 009 Toas
REVLON Super Lustrous Glass Shine Balm,
Product
Super Lustrous lipstick 009
Super Lustrous Glass Shine balm 013
Shade
Toasting Glasses
Toasting Glasses
Coverage
Medium, creamy
Sheer, balm like
Finish
Luminous shine
Glass like glow
Comfort
Creamy classic
Lightweight balm feel
Wear time
4 to 5 hours
3 to 4 hours
Typical price
Check price
Check price
Our Verdict
Pick the Super Lustrous lipstick for richer color with classic creamy shine. Pick the Glass Shine balm for a sheer, balm like glow you can reapply mindlessly. Both deliver the famous Toasting Glasses shade.
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.
Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Lipstick Expiration and Hygiene, Honestly
Bullet lipsticks like the Super Lustrous formula stay good for about 12 to 24 months after opening, while the balm format lasts closer to 12 months because its softer, more emollient base is more hospitable to bacteria. The signs a lipstick has gone off are a change in smell toward something waxy or rancid, a texture that drags instead of gliding, and color that looks off from the original shade. Wax bloom, a whitish film on the bullet surface, is usually harmless and wipes away, but oil separation or a grainy texture means the formula has broken down.
Sharing lipstick spreads illness more readily than people assume; cold sores and bacterial transfer happen through the bullet surface. Never share, and sanitize a bullet after illness by wiping the surface with alcohol and shaving off the top layer with a clean tissue. The balm's doe-foot or bullet applicator picks up more bacteria than a firm bullet, so the balm deserves the shorter end of the lifespan range. Store both upright in a cool drawer, not a hot car, because heat cycling degrades the wax structure permanently.
One Lipstick Worn Five Ways
Toasting Glasses in the classic Super Lustrous bullet is a strong candidate for the versatility play: one shade, five different looks. As a full bullet application, it is a polished warm rose. Blotted with a tissue after application, it becomes a soft stain that lasts through coffee. Finger-pressed, just dabbed on with a fingertip, it gives the lived-in flush that looks like your lips but better. Mixed with a dab of balm, it sheers into a tinted balm for no-makeup days. And dabbed on the cheeks and blended quickly, it doubles as a cream blush in a pinch.
The balm version covers the sheer end of this range on its own, so the versatility argument favors buying the bullet if you want the full range. The cheek trick works best with the bullet's pigment load; work fast because the wax base sets quickly on skin. This is how a single-class lipstick replaces three separate products in a minimal routine. For the balm-hybrid category more broadly, the Charlotte Tilbury Happikiss guide covers a luxury take on the same sheer-shine concept.
Lipstick and Teeth: Keeping the Smile Clean
Lipstick on teeth is the most common wear failure, and blotting with a finger is only the first step. The full prevention routine is: apply, blot once with a tissue, do the finger trick to clear the inner rim, then smile in a mirror and check. The inner rim is where teeth contact happens, so product sitting there is the entire problem; the finger trick removes it mechanically, which no blotting technique fully achieves.
Red and deep shades like the Toasting Glasses family stain teeth more visibly than nudes, and they can temporarily stain veneers or crowns if left on for hours, though normal brushing removes it. Blue-red undertones make teeth look whiter by contrast, which is why blue-based reds are the classic "bright smile" recommendation. If lipstick keeps migrating to your teeth within an hour, the formula is too creamy for your lip shape and a liner base will anchor it. The Black Honey lip guide covers another iconic shade with the same teeth-contrast dynamics.
Bullet Survival in Heat: Summer Storage Rules
Both Toasting Glasses formats suffer in heat, but differently. The classic bullet softens and can bend or break at the base in a hot bag; a bent bullet never twists up cleanly again. The balm, with its softer formula, melts faster and can leak oils into the cap. The storage rules are simple: never leave either in a car, store upright in the coolest drawer you have, and if a bullet has softened, stand it upright in the refrigerator for an hour to re-firm the wax structure before use.
A heat-damaged bullet with sweat beads on the surface is still usable; wipe the beads off and the formula underneath is fine. A bullet that has fully melted and re-solidified at an angle is usable but will apply unevenly, and at that point replacing it is the practical call. For travel, the balm's slimmer format survives bags better than the full bullet, which is one genuine advantage of the sheer format. Compare more everyday shades in the main lipsticks guide, which ranks finishes by wear time and comfort for every budget.
Beauty 
