Beauty NYX Line Loud vs Suede Matte: Which Lip Liner Wins Out?
NYX Line Loud and NYX Suede Matte are the brand's two star liners. Line Loud is waterproof and ultra-longwearing. Suede Matte is creamy, twist-up, and blendable. We compare them on pigment, precision, wear, and value.
| Factor | NYX Line Loud Lip Pencil, No Wine-ing 35 | NYX Suede Matte Lip Liner, Spicy, 0.03 o |
|---|---|---|
| Pigment payoff | High, one-swipe color | Medium, buildable color |
| Wear time | Up to 12 hours | 4 to 6 hours |
| Water resistance | Waterproof formula | Not waterproof |
| Texture | Creamy with jojoba oil | Velvety, very blendable |
| Format | Needs sharpening | Twist-up, no sharpener |
| Blendability | Sets fast, harder to blend | Stays blendable longer |
| Price | Check price | Check price |
Our Verdict
Pick Line Loud for maximum wear and waterproof confidence. Choose Suede Matte for creamy blending and twist-up ease. Both cost very little, so many fans own both. Long days call for Line Loud, quick looks call for Suede.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.
Best for: Everyday mauve lovers who line lips in seconds.
NYX Suede Matte Lip Liner, Sweet Tooth, 0.03 oz
- Soft mauve-pink Sweet Tooth
- Velvety matte texture
- Retractable twist-up design
- Matches Suede lipstick range
Pros
- Pretty everyday mauve
- No sharpener to carry
- Easy to overline with
Cons
- Light shade needs reapplying
- Can look chalky over dark lips
Best for: Cool-undertoned shoppers who want a lasting nude liner.
NYX Line Loud Lip Liner, Ten Out Of Ten 31, 0.06 oz
- Cool nude shade Ten Out Of Ten
- Waterproof longwear formula
- Jojoba oil and vitamin E
- Vegan, cruelty-free
Pros
- Cool nude suits fair skin
- Stays put for hours
- Creamy despite waterproof claim
Cons
- Cool tone may gray out warm skin
- Needs oil-based remover
Best for: Warm-undertoned shoppers who want a nude liner that lasts.
NYX Line Loud Lip Liner, Too Blessed 33, 0.06 oz
- Warm nude shade Too Blessed
- Waterproof, smudge-resistant wear
- Jojoba oil and vitamin E
- Soft matte finish
Pros
- Warm nude flatters medium skin
- All-day wear
- Comfortable, non-drying
Cons
- Waterproof needs effort to remove
- Warm shade may clash with cool lips
Want the Full Picture?
Line Loud vs Suede Matte: Which NYX Liner for Which Job
NYX's two hero liner formulas serve different masters, and the picks above let you choose correctly. Line Loud is the long-wear, high-pigment vegan formula: it sets firmly, resists eating better, and suits long days and bold lip looks. Suede Matte is the creamy, comfortable classic: easier to apply, kinder to dry lips, but it migrates and fades faster. The skin-type matching: dry or lined lips should default to Suede Matte for comfort; oily skin or long-wear needs should default to Line Loud for staying power. The shade strategy differs too: Line Loud's intense pigmentation means one swipe suffices, while Suede Matte often needs two passes for full opacity. For overlining, Line Loud's precision and staying power win; for the all-over-lip color technique, Suede Matte's creaminess wears more comfortably across the full lip. Both are retractable, which eliminates the sharpener waste and breakage issues of wood pencils, though the twist mechanism means you cannot sharpen to a finer point. If you can only buy one, match it to your most common lip scenario: office long days favor Line Loud, comfort-first everyday wear favors Suede Matte. For the broader drugstore liner field, the best lip pencil guide puts these in category context.
Wood vs Retractable: The Sharpening and Cost Reality
The wood versus retractable debate has concrete answers that go beyond preference. Sharpening technique for wood pencils: use a sharp, clean sharpener, rotate the pencil rather than the sharpener, and chill soft kohl pencils in the fridge for ten minutes before sharpening to prevent the tip crumbling. The waste math: each sharpening removes product, and heavy users lose a meaningful percentage of a wood pencil to shavings over its life; retractable pencils waste nothing but cannot be sharpened to precision. The jumbo sharpener problem is real: prestige wood pencils like Charlotte Tilbury's need the large hole, and standard sharpeners chew them; buy the sharpener matched to the pencil. Cost per use favors retractable for most buyers when waste is factored in, though wood pencils often contain more total product. Hygiene favors wood slightly: each sharpening exposes fresh product, while retractable tips accumulate bacteria; clean retractable tips with a tissue regularly. For the liner-only all-over-lip look, retractable wins on comfort and speed; for the sharpest defined line, a freshly sharpened wood pencil wins on precision. Neither format is universally superior; match the format to the technique you actually use. For prestige pencil specifics, the Charlotte Tilbury lip pencil guide covers the jumbo format.
The 90s Brown Liner Ombre: Technique Guide
The 90s brown-liner ombre is driving liner sales again, and the technique has specifics that single-line mentions skip. The method: line and fill the outer third of the lips with a deep brown liner, then apply a lighter nude or pink lipstick to the center, then blend the boundary with a fingertip or lip brush using small patting motions, never swiping, which muddies the gradient. The shade pairing rule: the liner should be two to three shades deeper than the center color with a compatible undertone; warm brown liner with warm nude center, cool brown with cool pink center. Mismatched undertones create the muddy look that ruins the trend. The blending tool matters: a small synthetic lip brush gives the most controlled gradient, fingertips work for a softer lived-in version, and cotton swabs clean the outer edge for sharpness. For pigmented or two-toned lips, the ombre technique actually flatters: the deeper liner harmonizes with darker lip edges while the light center brightens. Set the look by blotting once and reapplying the center color; this layers the gradient so it wears evenly instead of the center disappearing first. For nude center shades that pair with brown liners, the MAC Whirl guide covers the iconic pairing shade and its dupes.