Beauty Lippie Pencil Lip Products Compared: 5 Shades Ranked Today
We compared five ColourPop Lippie options: three individual pencils in BFF 3, Ashton, and Double Tap, plus the Dream Duo and Best Besties duos. Prices range from seven to eighteen dollars. The individual pencils win on shade choice, the duos win on coordinated convenience. BFF 3 remains the most versatile single shade. Below is the full breakdown of pigment, wear, versatility, and value.
| Factor | ColourPop Dream Duo Lip Kit, Five Stars | ColourPop Best Besties Lip Pencil and Gl |
|---|---|---|
| Pigment Richness | All five deliver the strong Lippie pigment the line is known for. Ashton shows the deepest, most dramatic color. BFF 3 and Double Tap give rich but wearable pigment. The duo liners match their individual counterparts. No weak pigment in the group. | |
| Wear Time | The long-wear formula holds three to five hours across all shades. Filled-in application lasts longer than outline alone. The duos gloss components fade faster than their liners. For maximum wear, fill the lip fully with liner. Consistent performance across the line. | |
| Versatility | BFF 3 wins versatility, pairing with nearly any lip product. Double Tap suits soft everyday looks. Ashton is more occasion-specific but perfect for its trend. The Dream Duo is a complete look in one box. The Best Besties duo is the boldest and least versatile. Most buyers get most use from BFF 3. | |
| Shade Uniqueness | Ashton offers the distinctive 90s brown that few liners match well. Double Tap warm rose fills a specific niche nicely. BFF 3 nude is excellent but has more competitors. The duo shades are curated for their pairings. For something different, Ashton stands out. | |
| Beginner Friendliness | BFF 3 is the most forgiving for beginners since nude mistakes show less. Double Tap is similarly easy. Ashton demands more precision as a dark shade. The duos simplify decisions with pre-matched pairs. Beginners should start with BFF 3. | |
| Value for Money | Individual pencils at seven to nine dollars are excellent value. The duos bundle liner plus gloss at fair prices. Cost per wear is tiny given how long pencils last. The Dream Duo is the best duo value. Overall, the whole line is a value standout. | |
| Overall Winner | The Lippie Pencil in BFF 3 wins overall for its unmatched versatility, cult-proven performance, and tiny price. Ashton is the pick for trend lovers. The Dream Duo is the pick for coordinated convenience. Start with BFF 3, then expand. | |
Our Verdict
The ColourPop Lippie Pencil in BFF 3 is the overall winner, offering the versatile nude shade that started the cult following at an unbeatable price. Ashton is the essential pick for the 90s brown lip trend. Double Tap serves warm rose lovers beautifully. The duos are smart buys for coordinated looks without shade-matching stress. At these prices, building a small Lippie wardrobe is easy. Start with BFF 3 and add shades as your style evolves.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.
Best for: The everyday nude liner that goes with everything.
ColourPop Lippie Lip Pencil, BFF 3
- Bestselling Lippie pencil in BFF 3 nude
- Creamy long-wear formula with strong pigment
- Thousands of monthly buyers on Amazon
- Versatile nude suits many lip colors
Pros
- The cult nude liner shade
- Stays put through talking and sipping
- Pairs with almost any lipstick
Cons
- Nude may wash out deep skin tones
- Needs sharpening, not retractable
- Can tug if lips are dry
Best for: The 90s brown lip liner look done right.
ColourPop Lippie Pencil, Ashton
- Lippie pencil in Ashton deep taupe
- 90s-inspired brown liner shade
- Smooth creamy application
- Long-wear formula resists feathering
Pros
- Perfect for the brown lip trend
- Defines lips for an overlined look
- Great with clear gloss on top
Cons
- Dark shade demands careful application
- Can look harsh on very fair skin
- Sharpening wastes product
Best for: A warm rose liner for soft defined lips daily.
ColourPop Lippie Lip Pencil, Double Tap
- Lippie pencil in Double Tap warm rose
- Warm rose tone flatters many undertones
- Creamy pigment with long wear
- Full-size 0.35 oz pencil
Pros
- Warm rose is very wearable
- Good middle ground between nude and bold
- Smooth formula blends easily
Cons
- Similar to other rose liners
- Warm tone may clash with cool lipsticks
- Not retractable
Want the Full Picture?
The Invisible Ring Problem and How to Prevent It
Every lip liner wearer knows the look: by afternoon the lipstick in the center has worn off but a dark outline remains, and no guide explains how to pick shades that fade gracefully. When that shade fades, it fades into your lip, not into a visible line. The second fix is technique: fill the entire lip with the liner first, then apply lipstick over it. A full-fill base means the liner wears down evenly with the lipstick instead of surviving as an outline. If you already own a liner that is too dark, use it only at the outer corners and blend inward, never as a full outline. For more shade-matching help across formulas, our best lip pencil buying guide compares how popular shades actually wear through a full day.
Wearing Lippie Pencil as the Whole Look
The liner-only look is having a real moment, wearing pencil across the whole lip with nothing over it, but nobody explains which formulas can handle it. Drier wood pencils skip and tug when used full-lip, so reserve those for lining. This gives you the blurred, bitten look without the dryness of a full matte lipstick. The Double Tap shade is a strong starter for this technique since its mid-tone neutral works across skin tones. If you want to compare prestige options for the same full-lip method, our MAC lip pencil guide covers which iconic shades perform best worn alone.