Beauty Urban Decay 24/7 Perversion vs Smoke Liner: Shade Showdown
Perversion and Smoke are the two most popular shades. One is bold, one is soft.
| Factor | Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil, Pe | Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil, Sm |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Check price | Check price |
| Shade | Intense black | Soft black-brown |
| Intensity | Maximum | Medium |
| Daytime wear | Bold | Perfect |
| Smoky eyes | Ideal | Good |
| Versatility | High | Higher |
| Best eye color | All | All |
Our Verdict
Choose Perversion for intense, dramatic eyes. Choose Smoke for soft everyday definition. Both share the same great formula. Beginners should start with Smoke. Drama lovers need Perversion.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.
Best for: Statement eye looks and colorful creatives.
Urban Decay 24/7 Eyeshadow, Electric Empire
- Bold electric shade
- High pigment
- Long-wearing
- Single shadow
Pros
- Vivid color payoff
- Blends well
- Stays vibrant
Cons
- Bold for daily wear
- Fallout possible
- Needs primer
Best for: Glitter eye looks without the mess.
Urban Decay 24/7 Moondust Eyeshadow, Diamond Dog
- Glitter eyeshadow
- Brown-gold sparkle
- 16-hour wear
- Micro-fine glitter
Pros
- Stunning sparkle
- Minimal fallout
- Long-wearing
Cons
- Glitter removal effort
- Pricey single
- Needs primer
Best for: Travelers wanting all-day makeup hold.
Urban Decay All Nighter Setting Spray, Travel 1 oz
- 1 oz travel spray
- Up to 24-hour wear
- Matte finish
- TSA-friendly
Pros
- Locks makeup all day
- Perfect for travel
- Controls shine
Cons
- Small bottle
- Spray can be strong
- Needs shaking
Want the Full Picture?
Turning These Shadows Into Long-Wear Liner
Electric Empire and Diamond Dog are eyeshadows, but both double as liner when applied wet, which is exactly where the All Nighter setting spray earns its place. Spritz a flat angled brush once, pick up the shadow, and the damp pigment draws a line with far more intensity than dry powder ever gives. The spray does two jobs at once: it deepens the color payoff and forms a light film that holds the pigment to the lid for hours. Let the brush dry between dips, since a soaking wet brush pushes shadow into the crease and ruins the edge.
This trick works best with the shimmer and glitter finishes here. Diamond Dog's micro-fine glitter clings to damp skin instead of raining down the cheek, which solves the biggest complaint about glitter shadows. Electric Empire's bold pigment goes fully opaque in one wet pass, so a thin line along the upper lashes gives graphic impact without building up dry layers. For beginners who find wet application fiddly, starting with a forgiving liquid pen format makes more sense, and the Clinique Pretty Easy liquid liner guide explains why that format suits unsteady hands.
Bold vs Soft Shades for Your Eye Shape
Perversion and Smoke suit different eyes, not just different moods. Bold dark liner on deep-set eyes can disappear entirely, because the lid folds over the line and hides it. On deep-set eyes, a softer shade like Smoke drawn slightly above the lash line stays visible when the eye is open, while Perversion works better smudged into the lash roots where the darkness reads as lash density. Prominent or protruding eyes have the opposite problem: dark liner all around can make them look heavier, so a softer shade on the lower lash line keeps the balance.
Hooded eyes need the line drawn with the eye open. Draw a bold wing with the eye closed and the hood folds it into a strange angle the moment you look up. With the eye open, map the wing from the outer corner outward along the lower lash line's natural extension, then fill back toward the lashes. Smoke is the safer practice shade here, since mistakes blend away, while Perversion rewards precision with real drama. The Charlotte Tilbury Feline Flick guide shows the exact flick geometry that works on hooded and deep-set eyes.
Tightlining With Shadow for Fuller-Looking Lashes
Tightlining means filling the tiny gaps between the upper lashes, not drawing on the waterline, and shadow applied with a damp flat brush is one of the gentlest ways to do it. Push the brush into the lash roots from below with the eye looking down into a mirror, and the dark base makes every lash look thicker from the root. Smoke in its deepest matte gray is ideal for this, since it darkens the lash base without the harshness a black waterline can give, and it never migrates onto the eye itself the way waterline pencil can.
Work in small sections and blink between them, since a loaded brush near the lash roots invites blinking mid-stroke. If you wear contacts, tightline before inserting them, because even careful application can transfer a speck of pigment that ends up trapped under a lens. Finish with mascara after the tightline sets, which seals the shadow between the lashes and keeps it from flaking down by afternoon.
Sweat, Tears, and Long Days: Making It Last
A standard shadow line gives up by midday on oily lids, which is why the system matters more than any single product. Primer on the lid, shadow applied damp, then one light mist of All Nighter held eight inches from the face with eyes closed: each layer does a different job, and skipping the primer is the step most people regret by 3pm. For workouts or outdoor heat, this three-layer approach survives sweat that melts a simple pencil line, though no eye makeup is truly swim-proof and goggles will press any line out of shape.
Waterproof pencils still beat this method for the waterline itself, since wet shadow on the inner rim washes away fast. Keep the shadow technique for the lash line and above, and reach for a dedicated waterproof pencil when the waterline needs color. Our waterproof eye pencil guide compares the formulas that actually hold on the inner rim through long days.