Beauty ZITAINY vs muxou: Which Colorful Liner Set Wins Out Today
We compare two colorful liner wardrobes head to head: the ZITAINY 12-color waterproof pencil set, a versatile multi-use kit for eyes, lips, and brows, versus the muxou 14-pack of gel liners, fourteen shimmering shades built for creative eye looks. Both promise waterproof wear and bold pigment, but their strengths serve different routines.
| Factor | ZITAINY 12-Color Waterproof Eyeliner and | muxou 14 Pack Waterproof Colored Gel Eye |
|---|---|---|
| What you get | Twelve multi-use pencils | Fourteen gel liner pencils |
| Formula type | Waterproof matte pencil | Gel formula, waterproof and smudge-proof |
| Shade range | 12 matte colorful shades | 14 colorful shimmering shades |
| Pigment payoff | Strong matte color payoff | Vibrant, metallic sheen shades |
| Working time | Sets waterproof, long wear | Blendable gel that sets in place |
| Best for | Eyes, lips, and brows | Colorful and creative eye looks |
| Precision | Good control for detail work | Standard pencil precision |
| Price | Check price | Check price |
Our Verdict
Choose the ZITAINY set if you want one kit that covers eyes, lips, and brows, since twelve waterproof matte shades handle everyday definition and creative color in a single purchase. Choose the muxou 14-pack if you want maximum shade variety for artistic eye looks, since fourteen shimmering gel shades give the widest creative range for around nine dollars. Practical minimalists should grab the ZITAINY kit; color lovers should grab the muxou set. Many makeup fans eventually own both: the ZITAINY pencils for daily versatility, the muxou shades for weekends and events.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.
Want the Full Picture?
Wearing Colored Eyeliner as an Adult: The Shade Rules
The colorful liner sets compared here, ZITAINY versus muxou, raise the question every adult asks: how do you wear blue, green, or purple liner without looking like a teenager? The answer is placement restraint plus shade sophistication. A thin line of deep navy or forest green along the upper lashes reads as polished and modern; the same shades smudged heavily all around the eye reads as costume. Keep colorful liner to one placement, upper lash line only, and let it be the single color statement.
Shade selection by eye color turns colorful liner from random to strategic. Blue liner on blue eyes disappears; on brown eyes it electrifies. Green liner flatters hazel and brown eyes most. Purple liner is the universal donor, complementing every eye color because it contrasts warm and cool tones simultaneously. Teal splits the difference, working across eye colors as a sophisticated alternative to black. The shades to approach cautiously are neon brights, which demand flawless application because every wobble shows.
The daytime integration trick: pair the colored liner with neutral everything else. Nude eyeshadow, groomed brows, natural lips, and the colored liner becomes an intentional accent rather than a full look. This is how colorful liner works in professional settings too; a thin emerald line with otherwise minimal makeup reads as confident, not unprofessional. Our Charlotte Tilbury Feline Flick guide covers classic wing shapes that work in any color.
The Oily-Lid System: Primer, Powder, and Setting in Combination
Colorful liners fade fastest on oily lids, and the common advice to "just buy waterproof" is incomplete. The system that actually holds liner on oily lids has three layers, and the order matters. First, an eyeshadow primer from lash line to brow bone, given a full minute to set; this is the layer that grips. Second, a translucent powder or skin-toned eyeshadow pressed over the primer, which absorbs the oil that migrates through during the day. Third, the liner itself, applied over this prepared base.
Testing shows the primer is the highest-impact step, contributing more to longevity than the liner formula itself. A mid-range liner over good primer outlasts a premium waterproof liner on bare oily skin. The powder step is second in impact, and the setting spray finish, often recommended, contributes least for liner specifically, though it helps the overall eye look. If you do only one thing, prime.
For very oily lids, add the midday blot: press blotting paper gently over the closed lid without rubbing, which lifts migrated oil without disturbing the liner. Re-powdering over liner midday dulls the color, so blot instead. And avoid creamy concealers as makeshift primers; their emollients accelerate liner migration rather than preventing it. The waterproof eye pencil guide ranks liner formulas for oily-lid performance.
Wing Angles for Deep-Set and Prominent Eyes
Every wing tutorial demonstrates the same angle, but eye placement changes the geometry completely. For deep-set eyes, the standard upward wing disappears into the socket when the eyes are open; the fix is a longer, more horizontal wing drawn with the eyes open, looking straight into the mirror. Drawing with eyes open is the key adjustment most tutorials skip, and it is non-negotiable for deep-set eyes.
For prominent or protruding eyes, the standard wing exaggerates the protrusion. The flattering adjustment is a shorter, thicker wing that stays close to the lash line, emphasizing the lash base rather than extending outward. Heavy liner on the lower lash line should be skipped entirely on prominent eyes, since it pushes the eye forward visually. Tightlining plus a modest upper wing gives definition without amplification.
The universal wing-mapping method works for any eye shape: with eyes open and looking straight ahead, mark the outer corner, then draw the wing's lower edge as a continuation of the lower lash line's angle. This anatomical approach automatically customizes the angle to your eye placement, which is why it beats following any fixed-degree tutorial. Practice the mapping with a light hand first; colorful liners forgive less than black because mistakes show more. Our Clinique Pretty Easy liquid guide recommends a beginner-friendly pen for wing practice.