Beauty MAC Liquidlast Eyeliner Compared: Top Two Models Face Off
Liquidlast Point Black and Brushstroke Brushblack both deliver MAC waterproof black liner, but the formats differ completely. Liquidlast is a classic bottle with a brush for intense, traditional liquid lining. Brushstroke is a pen with a precision tip for controlled, mistake-proof application. Both offer deep black pigment and long wear. Your experience level and grip preference decide.
| Factor | MAC Liquidlast Liner, Point Black | MAC Brushstroke 24 Hour Liner, Brushblac |
|---|---|---|
| Format | Bottle with brush | Pen with brush tip |
| Waterproof level | Fully waterproof | Water-resistant, 24-hour wear |
| Pigment | Intense black, opaque | Rich black, buildable |
| Control | Needs steady hand | Easier pen grip |
| Best for | Classic liquid looks | Quick precise lines |
| Removal | Oil-based remover needed | Waterproof remover needed |
| Product amount | More per bottle | Less per pen |
| Skill level | Intermediate | Beginner friendly |
Our Verdict
Pick Liquidlast if you want classic waterproof liquid liner with intense bottle-format payoff. Pick Brushstroke if you want pen control with easier application and 24-hour wear. Liquid veterans choose Liquidlast, beginners choose Brushstroke.
Which Format Is Harder to Remove: Bottle Liquid or Pen Liner?
Nobody talks about what happens at midnight, when the makeup has to come off. Both the MAC Liquidlast Liner in Point Black and the Brushstroke 24 Hour Liner in Brushblack are built to stay put, which means both demand more than a casual face wash at removal time. The Liquidlast bottle formula is fully waterproof, so it bonds to skin in a way that a standard micellar water barely loosens. Plan on an oil-based cleanser or a dedicated eye makeup remover with the Liquidlast, held against the lash line for fifteen to twenty seconds before any wiping motion. The Brushstroke pen is water-resistant rather than fully waterproof, so it releases faster, often with one pass of a balm cleanser, though the 24-hour wear claim means it still needs more effort than a basic kohl.
Tightlining With a Bottle Brush vs a Pen: A Beginner Walkthrough
Tightlining means placing liner in the gaps between your upper lashes, not on the waterline and not above the lashes. The goal is a fuller lash base with no visible line, and the tool you use changes the technique completely. With the Brushstroke pen, rest your elbow on a table, tilt your chin up, and use your free hand to gently lift the lid so you can see the lash roots. Dot the pen tip between the lashes with tiny presses rather than dragging, because dragging on the lash base deposits a thick line and irritates the eye. The pen format shines here: one hand does the work, and the firm tip does not wobble the way a wet brush can.
Tightlining with the Liquidlast bottle takes more practice. Wipe most of the product off the brush first, because a loaded brush floods the lash line and the excess migrates onto the lens area. Use the very tip of the brush and stamp, do not stroke. The payoff for mastering it is a denser, blacker result than the pen gives, since liquid pigment saturates the lash roots more completely. The common mistakes that cause irritation are pressing the brush against the waterline itself and lining before inserting contact lenses, which traps pigment under the lens. If you are new to liquid lining entirely, our Clinique Pretty Easy liquid liner guide walks through beginner-friendly application before you graduate to a high-pigment bottle formula like Liquidlast.
Making Either Liner Survive Oily Lids and Contact Lenses
Oily lids defeat eyeliner through one mechanism: the skin's natural oils dissolve the film the liner forms, starting at the inner corner where oil pools first. Waterproof alone does not fix this, because waterproof resists water, not oil. The system that actually works has three layers. First, an eyeshadow primer or a light dusting of translucent powder on the lid before any liner, which gives the formula a dry surface to grip. Second, the liner itself, and here both MAC options perform, though the Brushstroke pen's thinner film tends to break down slightly faster on very oily lids than the Liquidlast's heavier coat. Third, a setting spray misted over the finished eye or a whisper of powder pressed along the lash line to lock the edge. Skip the third step and you will see fading by hour six on oily skin, no matter which of the two you chose.
Contact lens wearers need a different kind of caution. Liquid and pen formulas can both flake or transfer tiny particles onto lenses if applied too close to the waterline or if the liner is past its prime. Insert your lenses before applying liner, never after, so you are not pressing a lens over fresh product. Tightline with the Brushstroke pen rather than the Liquidlast bottle if your eyes run dry, because the pen deposits less wet product near the lens edge. And if you notice liner migrating onto your lenses by midday, the culprit is usually an old tube: liquid liner past six months old breaks down into particles that travel. Replace it on schedule. Our kajal for sensitive eyes guide covers waterline-safe options for days when your lenses make liquid lining uncomfortable, and the waterproof eye pencil guide lists pencil alternatives that hold up when oil and lenses team up against your liquid liner.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.