Beauty Rimmel Scandaleyes vs Nude Waterline Pencil Picks Compared
The Rimmel London Scandaleyes Waterproof Kohl Kajal in black and the nude waterline gel pencil serve opposite eye goals. One adds sultry definition, the other bright-eyed openness. We compared pigment, wear, comfort, and best look.
| Factor | Rimmel London Scandaleyes Waterproof Koh | Nude Waterline Eyeliner Pencil, Waterpro |
|---|---|---|
| Product | Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Kohl Kajal, Black | Nude Waterline Eyeliner Pencil, Waterproof Gel |
| Effect | Sultry definition, intense black | Brightening, wide-awake nude |
| Formula | Creamy kohl, waterproof | Gel-cream, waterproof, smudge-proof |
| Wear | Long-wearing, heat and sweat proof | Long-wearing, built-in sharpener |
| Best look | Smoky eyes, evening drama | Natural daytime, tired eyes |
| Eye safety | Sharpen before waterline use | Gentle formula for sensitive eyes |
| Price tier | Budget | Budget |
| Our pick | Winner for bold definition | Winner for brightening |
Our Verdict
Pick the Rimmel Scandaleyes black kohl if you want bold definition and proven waterproof wear. Pick the nude pencil if you want brighter, bigger-looking eyes for daytime. Most makeup bags benefit from owning both.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.
Best for: stocking the makeup bag
Nude Waterline Eyeliner Pencil Set, 2 Pack, Waterproof
- Two nude gel pencils
- Waterproof long-wear
- High-pigment smooth glide
Pros
- Backup pencil included
- Good value two-pack
Cons
- Generic brand
- Shade may vary by skin tone
Want the Full Picture?
Colored Eyeliner That Flatters Your Eye Color
Pick liner color by the contrast rule and the effect is immediate. Blue eyes gain the most from bronze, copper, and warm browns. Brown eyes sharpen against navy and deep teal without looking theatrical. Green eyes wake up with plum and aubergine. Hazel eyes are the chameleons: Rimmel London Scandaleyes in plum tones draws out green, warm browns emphasize gold. The common mistake is a colored liner too close to the eye color, which muddies rather than defines; contrast creates the pop.
Do not overlook the two workhorse alternatives to black. Brown liner delivers definition at half the harshness, which suits fair skin, mature eyes, and office days better than black ever will. Nude or white on the waterline opens the eye visibly and masks redness, at the cost of midday reapplication. A drawer with black plus brown plus one contrast shade for your eye color, with Rimmel London Scandaleyes filling one of those slots, handles every look from boardroom to evening without a dozen pencils. For the category-wide view, start with our Rimmel ScandalEyes Guide: Waterproof Kohl That Survives Heat.
Eyeliner That Survives the Pool, Ranked Honestly
Swim-proof claims sort themselves in the water. Genuine waterproof liners built on film-forming polymers endure pool sessions and sweaty workouts, while water-resistant pretenders dissolve at the first real immersion. Rimmel London Scandaleyes qualifies for swim duty only in its truly waterproof form; check the claim wording, since resistant and proof are different promises. Mind the goggles too: strap pressure transfers even good liner, so fit them snug but not crushing. Salt water degrades formulas faster than chlorine, so ocean swimmers need the toughest tier.
Protect the liner after the swim, not just during it. A fresh-water rinse right after leaving the pool stops chlorine from continuing its assault on the formula. Pack Rimmel London Scandaleyes for a post-swim touch-up instead of demanding all-day immortality; prolonged submersion softens every formula eventually, and re-lining takes seconds. Remember the cost side of the equation: pool-proof formulas need the most thorough nightly removal, so keep them as occasion specialists rather than everyday drivers. For a direct comparison of more formulas, see our Best Waterproof Eye Pencil Guide: How to Apply Like a Pro.
Lining Lower Lashes Without the Raccoon Effect
The lower lash line rewards restraint and punishes heaviness. Dark liner across the entire lower waterline visually shrinks the eye and harshens mature faces, while Rimmel London Scandaleyes smudged just under the lower lashes on the outer two-thirds defines beautifully. Keep the inner corner bare to maintain openness, and always diffuse the edge; a crisp lower line is what ages, a soft one is what flatters. The notorious raccoon eye comes specifically from waterline product migrating downward through the day, which under-lash placement avoids.
Lock the lower line with a three-part routine. Press matching eyeshadow over the liner to set it, outperforming liner alone significantly. Reserve your most long-wearing formula for the lower line even when the upper line uses something standard, because the lower lid endures more moisture and blinking stress. Finally, do one midday mirror check in daylight to learn your migration pattern; a single observation reveals whether your routine holds or needs reinforcement, and personal data beats generic advice here. Our complete eyeliner buying guide walks through the full application routine step by step.
Lining Eyes When the Lid Is No Longer Smooth
Crepey lids defeat standard eyeliner technique, so change the technique. Ditch the single sweeping stroke, which skips helplessly over textured skin, and switch to dotting: with eyes open and gaze forward, stamp Rimmel London Scandaleyes between the lashes in small connected dots. Creamy gel pencils and pot gels grip folds far better than liquid liners here. Placed at the lash base, the dots read as a continuous defined line even where the lid creases over, which is the entire goal on mature eyes.
Rethink placement for the mature eye geometry. Tightlining gives definition that survives lid folds, since the color lives in the lash base rather than on visible lid real estate. Keep lines on the thinner side; heavy liner on mature lids accentuates the fold instead of the eye. Lock creamy formulas by pressing matching shadow over the line, countering the extra transfer that folded lids cause. For the lower lash line, trade harsh liner for softly smudged shadow, which defines without the aging severity of a crisp lower line.