Beauty Eyeliner Duel: Avon Glimmerstick vs Revlon Compared Here
Shimmery definition versus budge-proof wear: the Avon Glimmerstick and Revlon ColorStay serve different eyeliner priorities. We compared them on formula, shade, wear time, and value to help you pick your pencil.
| Factor | Avon Glimmerstick Eyeliner, Saturn Grey | Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner Pencil, Brown |
|---|---|---|
| Formula style | Smooth-glide shimmer pencil | Waterproof long-wear pencil |
| Shade | Saturn Grey shimmer | Brown 203, 2-pack |
| Wear time | Good for normal days | Excellent, waterproof |
| Removal | Easy with any cleanser | Needs oil-based remover |
| Best for | Everyday luminous definition | Humid days, watery eyes |
Our Verdict
Choose Avon Glimmerstick Saturn Grey for shimmery everyday definition that removes easily. Choose Revlon ColorStay Brown for waterproof wear that survives watery eyes and long days. Many eyeliner lovers keep both for different situations.
Shimmer Pencil Versus Waterproof: The Wear-Time Truth
The comparison table notes wear time, but the shimmer-versus-waterproof tradeoff deserves specifics. The Glimmerstick's smooth-glide shimmer formula prioritizes comfortable application and luminous finish: it goes on effortlessly, suits daily wear, and removes with any cleanser. Its weakness is longevity on oily lids or in humidity, where the emollient shimmer base softens by afternoon. The ColorStay waterproof pencil prioritizes endurance: it sets firmly, survives sweat and tears, and needs an oil-based remover. Its weakness is comfort during application and removal, since the waterproof film drags more and demands the press-and-hold removal method.
The decision is lifestyle, not quality. Office days, dry climates, and sensitive eyes favor the shimmer pencil. Long days, humid climates, events, and oily lids favor the waterproof. Many wearers own both and choose by calendar, which is the most economical approach at these price points. The hybrid technique: apply the waterproof as the base line for endurance, then trace the shimmer pencil just above it for the luminous effect, getting both wear and glow. Our waterproof pencil guide tests more long-wear options.
Cost Per Use: The Pencil Math Nobody Runs
No guide covers the cost-per-use math for eyeliners: a prestige pencil versus drugstore pencils replaced regularly. The calculation: divide the price by the number of months the pencil lasts with your usage. A retractable pencil used daily lasts roughly two to three months, since the twist mechanism exposes fresh product continuously. A wood pencil lasts longer per unit of product but loses some to sharpening shavings, roughly 15 to 20 percent of the product ends up as shavings over its life.
Retractable versus wood is also a hygiene question: retractables never get sharpened, so the tip accumulates bacteria faster and the pencil should be replaced on the three-month eye-safety schedule regardless of remaining product. Wood pencils get a fresh sterile tip with every sharpening, which extends their safe life. For daily eyeliner wearers, the drugstore retractable replaced quarterly is usually the cheapest safe routine. For occasional wearers, a wood pencil lasts a year safely with regular sharpening. Never use any eye pencil past the point where it drags or smells off, eye products are not where savings belong.
Eyeliner for Mature, Crepey Lids
No guide addresses eyeliner for mature, crepey eyelids: how to line lids with loose skin without skipping. The problem is mechanical: soft pencils skip across textured lids, depositing dotted lines instead of smooth ones. The technique that works: gently stretch the lid taut with one finger while applying with the other hand, which gives the pencil a smooth surface. The Glimmerstick's smooth-glide formula suits this better than the waterproof, since it deposits with less pressure and the shimmer reflects light away from texture.
Placement matters more than formula on mature lids. Keep the line thin and close to the lashes, since thick lines on crepey lids fold into the crease and disappear while leaving a stamp above. Tightlining the upper lashes, filling between the roots rather than drawing on the lid, defines without fighting the lid texture at all. Set the line with a matching powder shadow pressed over it, which locks the pencil and prevents the migration into creases that ages the eye. And the wing technique guide covers flick placement adapted for lids where the standard wing disappears into the fold.
Swimmers and Athletes: Which Formula Survives
Nobody addresses waterproof eyeliner for swimmers and athletes honestly. The ColorStay waterproof survives pool chlorine and heavy sweat far better than the shimmer pencil, which softens within an hour of sustained moisture. The caveats: goggle pressure can stamp any liner onto the surrounding skin, so keep the line thin on swim days, and chlorine plus waterproof film needs the full oil-remover routine afterward, since half-removed waterproof residue irritates eyes overnight. For gym sessions rather than pools, the waterproof holds through sweat while the shimmer pencil needs the primer-plus-powder system to survive. Post-workout, remove fully and reapply fresh rather than layering over sweat, which is how clogged lash follicles and styes start.
Glimmerstick vs ColorStay Questions
The Glimmerstick, for comfort: its smooth formula does not tug the waterline. The ColorStay lasts longer on the waterline but can feel dry. For all-day waterline wear, the shimmer pencil with a midday touch-up beats the waterproof worn uncomfortably.
Yes, Saturn Grey's shimmer is luminous rather than glittery, reading as polished in daylight. Keep the line thin for office wear and save heavier application for evening, when the shimmer catches light beautifully.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.