Feline Flick Panther Vs Super Brown: Which Shade Wins Out

Panther and Super Brown are the two signature Feline Flick shades. One brings drama, the other brings softness. Here is how they compare.
| Factor | Charlotte Tilbury Feline Flick Liquid Ey | Charlotte Tilbury Feline Flick Liquid Ey |
|---|---|---|
| Product | Charlotte Tilbury Feline Flick Panther | Charlotte Tilbury Feline Flick Super Brown |
| Shade | Intense black | Sultry brown |
| Finish | Modern matte | Modern matte |
| Wear time | Up to 12 hours | Up to 12 hours |
| Best for | Dramatic cat-eyes | Daytime softness |
| Tip | Ultra-precise fiber | Ultra-precise fiber |
| Typical price | Check price | Check price |
Our Verdict
Choose Panther if you want the classic intense black cat-eye. It delivers maximum drama with a modern matte finish. Choose Super Brown if you want softer definition for daytime. The warm brown flatters fair skin and looks polished at work. Both share the same ultra-precise tip and 12-hour waterproof wear. Panther wins for evening impact. Super Brown wins for everyday versatility. Let your lifestyle pick the shade.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.
Wing Angles for Deep-Set and Prominent Eyes
Every wing tutorial assumes the same average eye, but the Feline Flick's ultra-precise fiber tip changes what is possible per eye shape. For deep-set eyes: draw with the eye open and looking straight ahead, extending outward and slightly upward from the outer corner; drawing with the eye closed hides the wing in the socket. Keep the wing shorter than instinct suggests, because length disappears into shadow. For prominent eyes: keep the line thin along the lashes and draw the wing more horizontally than upward, avoiding the surprised look that upward wings create on projection. For hooded eyes: the bat-wing method, drawing on the outer-corner skin visible when open, checking throughout with the eye open. The fiber tip's advantage across all three: the ultra-precise point draws the fine lines these techniques require, where a felt tip would be too blunt. The 12-hour wear claim matters for wings specifically, because wings are the first thing to fade at the outer corner; the long-wear formula holds the architecture. The beginner error: copying a wing from a different eye type. Diagnose your eye placement first, then draw. For the dedicated wing-technique guide, our Charlotte Tilbury Feline Flick guide breaks down the method step by step.
Tightlining With a Liquid Pen: Technique and Limits
Tightlining with a liquid pen is rarely taught, so here is the method and its limits. Where the product goes: between the upper lash roots, not on the waterline. The technique: look down, lift the lid gently, and dot the fiber tip between the roots, working outer corner inward. The fiber tip's precision suits this delicate area better than a brush tip, though a gel pencil remains the easiest tightlining tool overall. The limits: liquid pens deposit more product per touch than ideal for tightlining, so use the lightest dotting motion; too much product migrates to the waterline and irritates. Common mistakes: pressing hard, working the inner corner where tears dissolve product into the eye, and tightlining before contact lens insertion. The Panther versus Super Brown choice for tightlining: Panther's intense black gives the fullest lash illusion; Super Brown gives a softer definition that suits daytime. If eyes water during tightlining, stop; watery eyes and liquid are incompatible. The 12-hour wear is an advantage here: tightlined definition that lasts without touch-ups. For a more forgiving liquid pen for beginners, our Clinique Pretty Easy liquid liner guide covers an easier applicator.
Waterproof Liner for Swimmers and Athletes
Which formulas survive pool chlorine and sweat is never tested, so here is the practical guide. The Feline Flick's long-wear matte formula resists sweat well, making it suitable for workouts, but pool chlorine is a harsher test that no cosmetic liner fully passes. The goggle factor: goggle pressure plus water movement dislodge even long-wear liner; the realistic expectation is diminished, not destroyed, liner after swimming. The pre-swim routine: apply liner, let it set fully for five minutes, and avoid touching the eye area; set with a touch of matching eyeshadow pressed over the line for extra grip. The post-swim touch-up: carry the pen for reapplication, because touch-ups are the honest solution, not a mythical swim-proof formula. For athletes: sweat-resistant long-wear like this suits training, with the fiber tip allowing precise reapplication. The removal note: long-wear formulas need oil-based removal; scrubbing after swimming, when the eye area is already irritated by chlorine, is the worst combination. Rinse chlorine first, then remove makeup gently. The shade choice for sport: Super Brown's softer line shows wear less obviously than Panther's stark black. For waterproof pencil options, our waterproof eye pencil guide ranks swim-friendly formulas.
Eyeliner for Contact Lens Wearers
Which formulas migrate onto lenses is never specified per product type. The migration ranking: glitter and powder liners shed most; creamy pencils migrate moderately; long-wear liquid pens like the Feline Flick migrate least once set, because the film locks in place. The tightlining caution: product at the lash roots sits millimeters from the lens edge; use minimal product and keep it off the waterline. The insertion order: lenses in before makeup, lenses out before makeup removal, always. The fiber-tip advantage: precise application means less stray product near the lens than a brush tip flicks. If vision clouds midday, the cause is usually liner or mascara migration; reduce product near the waterline and ensure full dry-down before blinking normally. The dry-eye factor: dry eyes blink more, increasing mechanical transfer; long-wear films handle this better than creamy formulas. The removal interaction: remove lenses before using oily removers, because remover residue films lenses. Between Panther and Super Brown, migration behavior is identical; choose on aesthetics. The 12-hour wear claim benefits lens wearers specifically, because reapplication near lenses is the riskiest moment.