Beauty Hope vs Happy: Best Rare Beauty Lip Oil Showdown Winner
We put Hope and Happy head to head. Both are popular Rare Beauty lip oil picks on Amazon. But they serve different buyers. This comparison breaks down price, formula, and results. By the end, you will know which one fits you.
| Factor | Rare Beauty Soft Pinch Tinted Lip Oil in | Rare Beauty Soft Pinch Tinted Lip Oil in |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Check price | Check price |
| Size | 0.10 oz lip oil | 0.10 oz lip oil |
| Key technology | Tinted lip oil with jojoba | Tinted lip oil with jojoba |
| Best for | Berry-rose juicy tint | Warm pink juicy tint |
| Ease of use | Very easy, swipe and go | Very easy, swipe and go |
| Finish | Juicy berry tint | Juicy pink tint |
| Overall value | Check price | Check price |
Our Verdict
Choose Rare Beauty Soft Pinch Tinted Lip Oil in Hope if you want berry tint with cushiony comfort. Pick Rare Beauty Soft Pinch Tinted Lip Oil in Happy if you want happy pink tint with cushiony comfort. For most buyers, pick Hope for berry and Happy for pink.
More Top Picks in This Category
Not sold on either of these two? Here are more bestselling options worth considering.
Best for: Best for nude rose everyday tint.
Rare Beauty Soft Pinch Tinted Lip Oil in Serenity, 0.10 oz
- Serenity shade
- 0.10 oz lip oil
- Nude rose tint
- Hydrating oils
Pros
- Nude rose tint
- Versatile
- Comfortable
Cons
- Sheer
- Stains
Best for: Best for warm coral juicy tint.
Rare Beauty Soft Pinch Tinted Lip Oil in Joy, 0.10 oz
- Joy shade
- 0.10 oz lip oil
- Warm coral tint
- Non-sticky
Pros
- Coral tint
- Juicy
- Hydrating
Cons
- Bold
- Stains
Best for: Best for rose brown tint.
Rare Beauty Soft Pinch Tinted Lip Oil in Delight, 0.10 oz
- Delight rose brown
- 0.10 oz lip oil
- Rose brown tint
- Lightweight oil
Pros
- Rose brown tint
- Unique shade
- Comfortable
Cons
- Dark
- Stains
Want the Full Picture?
Lip Oil as Blush: The Multi-Use Case
Tinted lip oils like the Rare Beauty Soft Pinch shades pull double duty as cream blush, and the crossover is not a hack but a legitimate technique. The formula properties that make a good lip oil, blendable pigment, a dewy finish, skin-friendly oils, are exactly what a cream blush needs. The application: dot a tiny amount on the apples of the cheeks and blend with fingertips or a stippling brush. The Serenity, Joy, and Delight shades translate to soft, wearable cheek color in the same families as their lip appearance. Start with half the amount you think you need; lip oil pigment is concentrated and cheek area is larger than lips.
The wear considerations differ between the two uses. On lips, the oil nourishes and the tint fades gracefully with eating and drinking. On cheeks, the oil base means shorter wear than a dedicated powder blush, typically four to six hours before fading, and it can disturb foundation if over-applied. The technique that extends cheek wear: apply over set foundation, blend quickly before the oil sets, and finish with a light press of translucent powder around the edges, not over the color itself. For buyers building a minimal makeup kit, one tinted lip oil covering lips and cheeks is genuine versatility. Our Rare Beauty blush guide covers the brand's dedicated cheek formulas for comparison.
Tinted Lip Oils and Staining
Tinted lip products stain to varying degrees, and the staining behavior affects both wear and removal. Berry, fuchsia, and deep rose tints, the families these Soft Pinch shades touch, leave more residual stain than nude or peach tints. The stain is a feature for longevity: as the glossy oil layer wears off, the stain keeps color on the lips for hours longer. It is a drawback when switching colors, since the residual stain shifts the next application; a red-stained lip under a nude gloss produces a different color than the tube promises.
The removal protocol for stained lips: an oil-based remover or cleansing balm held against the lips for thirty seconds dissolves most of the stain without scrubbing. What remains after one removal round is usually faint enough to ignore or to work with. Never scrub stained lips with an exfoliant to force the color off; the lip skin is thin and the irritation lasts longer than the stain would have. For buyers who dislike staining entirely, blotting the lip oil within the first minute of application reduces stain deposit significantly, trading some longevity for a clean slate at removal. Our lip tint guide explains staining science across tint formats in detail.
Heat and Your Lip Oil
Lip oils and summer heat have a complicated relationship. The oil base thins in heat, which means a lip oil carried in a hot bag or left in a car applies runnier and less precisely than at room temperature. The product is not ruined; it returns to normal consistency when cooled. But the application on a hot day needs adjustment: apply less, blot once after application, and expect shorter wear as the thinner oil migrates faster. The tube itself can leak in heat as the oil expands, so store it upright and check the cap seal before tossing it in a bag.
The longer-term heat question is formula stability. Repeated heat-cool cycles gradually degrade cosmetic oils, shortening the effective lifespan. A lip oil that lived through a summer in a hot car may go off faster than its printed expiry suggests; the signs are a sharp or paint-like smell replacing the original scent. The practical system: keep the daily-carry lip oil small and replace it seasonally if it lives in heat, and keep backups in a cool drawer. For buyers comparing lip product durability across formats, our Fenty Beauty lip guide covers how different lip formulas handle real-world conditions.